3 ms·
> Biologists have long debated what constitutes an individual organism. The record-breaking A. solidipes clonal colony passes the test based on a definition of
by crazygringo 9y ago
> Biologists have long debated what constitutes an individual organism. The record-breaking A. solidipes clonal colony passes the test based on a definition of being made up of genetically identical cells that can communicate, and that have a common purpose or can at least coordinate themselves.
From the article, I'm unclear -- are all the cells physically connected to each other, or are they 1,000's of fruiting bodies which are genetically identical and can communicate somehow but aren't all actually connected to each other within the trees and among them, underground? (Even if some are connected?)
Because if it's the latter, it doesn't feel like a single organism to me, any more than communicating and coordinating with an identical twin would make two people into one.
- FRex 9y agoEven the 'identical twins' are not 100% genetically identical[0] and they can't 'fuse' with each other like these fungi are and can. Humans also can't asexually produce more of their own clones to cooperate with while these fungi apparently can do both asexual and sexual reproduction with asexual one being more common. Even if we could then our clones have their own central nervous system and aren't enslaved by their genes to do the same as us and 'fuse' and cooperate with us. On the other hand, common bananas are sterile clones[1] but they are more 'separate' from each other and not 'fused' in any way (I guess? I have no idea) then these bunches of fungus... But we are all over the Biological Kingdoms (Animalia, Fungi, Plantae), methods of reproduction, human intervention, 'fusing' and so on by now. I'm not a biologist but I had very high level biology class with a really good (and demanding..) retired biologist as the teacher and I still remember how WTF this all gets (the entire Protista Kingdom which is just a bag of stuff that doesn't fit elsewhere and varies a lot internally, the pseudo-life of viruses, the scyphozoan jellyfish life cycle, concept of biological immortality, etc.). Pluto planet debacle is nothing and a 100% clear cut case with 0 controversy in comparison to this. [0] - https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/identical-twins-genes-are-not-identical/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/identical-twins-g... [1] - https://piecubed.co.uk/bananas-facts/ https://piecubed.co.uk/bananas-facts/
- crazygringo 9y agoThanks! That was really informative and helpful.
- Scarblac 9y agoIt's this hard to say what a single organism is, and many people still believe there is a simple definition of what a species is.