3 ms·
Disaster relief has been self-organized among local volunteers in many parts of the US for a long time, it is almost a cultural tradition. I would make the poin
by jandrewrogers 9y ago
Disaster relief has been self-organized among local volunteers in many parts of the US for a long time, it is almost a cultural tradition. I would make the point that it is encouraged in part because it is anti-fragile; the people that live in an area often have better information and communication/resource networks, and can react faster, than the more centralized disaster management the government provides. Especially in the early stages, it provides a more thorough and robust response because it is so well distributed.
I've lived through a few major natural disasters around the country. These ad hoc disaster organizations materialized out of the community and were effective every single time. The government will often step aside, and just act in a supporting role if the volunteers have a good ground organization. In one case where I was volunteering, we came up with a shopping list of things we could use immediately to mitigate the major problems, and the state government rooted through warehouses, found what we needed in other parts of the state, helicoptered it in, and just gave it to us to use as we saw fit. We had a plan and an ability to execute it much more quickly than the official agencies.
(As an aside, during my first major natural disaster, I discovered that union regulations limit the hours the government workers onsite can put in, the conditions they can operate in, and the kinds of things they can do without regard for if those things need to be done given the nature of the disaster. These volunteer organizations are unhindered by such rules and will work their ass off, whatever is necessary. Letting these volunteers run a lot of the relief efforts and supporting them instead taking point is a way for the government to work around its own structural lack of urgency.)
- tomohawk 9y agoVolunteer organizations are also often there much longer than the government agencies. After Katrina, the Army Corp was done in about a year, but volunteer organizations continued to work in the affected areas for much longer.
- Spooky23 9y agoWhere did you see that? I’ve been involved in a few disasters, including in places with strong unions. Never saw that happen.
- jandrewrogers 9y agoCalifornia, in the 1990s. I thought it was surreal at the time, but I had more pressing concerns since I personally had life and property on the line; I was a victim trapped in the disaster area, doing what I could. There was a lot of stopping and starting work, and they had supervisors flying in to make sure everyone was following whatever their workplace SOP was. There was a memorable 1 hour work stoppage because someone complained that (in all seriousness) the tasks were not equitably distributed across genders -- the lead supervisor on site deftly squashed that but it kind of blew my mind that it took precedent over the task at hand. I have a lot of great "wtf?" stories from that experience. Don't take it as anti-union, they just had a lot of rules and processes that made them relatively unproductive under the circumstances. There were 30-40 of us working together, an ad hoc organization of volunteers, working 16-hour shifts with almost no breaks that essentially did the bulk of the disaster mitigation work. It made for poor optics with the locals; they saw a bunch of ragtag out-of-towners trapped in the disaster with them working their asses off while the government employees stood around drinking coffee half the time. I understand how that happens but it wasn't a good look. And this is why communities love their volunteer disaster response. (And full credit to the local community, they took fantastic care of us the best they could.)
- Spooky23 9y agoThat’s unbelievable. I’ve spent most of my work in New York. I’ve seen my share of work to rule bullshit, but never anything like that. I cannot fathom what a toxic shitshow that agency must be.
- jandrewrogers 9y agoFWIW, I strongly encourage people to informally volunteer in disaster areas, it is an exceedingly rewarding and effective action you can take in your own and surrounding communities, and they always need the help. You can do a lot of good with a small investment in time and effort. There is no glory in it but you can make a real difference. My first experience was as a trapped disaster victim, who volunteered because I literally had no way out so I opted to make the best of a terrible situation to the extent of my abilities. But it was such a positive experience that I've since volunteered to go into places I had no need to go. It is a very high leverage and much of the best disaster response comes from ordinary people, don't wait for the government to do something.