3 ms·
Ask HN: Is www. deprecated?
Really, why does (nearly) every website start with www. instead of allowing access directly through their main domain? Wouldn't it be time to call the death of the www subdomain? What is HN's opinion on the matter?
- gdl 16y agoYes, as of August 14, 2003. (Of course opinions may vary.) http://no-www.org/ http://no-www.org/
- mooism2 16y agoAllow access through both. Whether you default to using www or not is up to you. On the one hand it's four more characters to type, but on the other hand lots of people still expect web addresses to start www.
- madhouse 16y agoIt should be dead for a few years by now.
- gmac 16y agoI expect we can agree that (1) sites ought to be accessible by both the bare domain name and the www subdomain, and (2) to avoid cross-domain cookie/AJAX/analytics (etc.) issues, one should be chosen as the canonical form, and the other silently redirected to that. But which should be canonical? Recently I tend to go for the bare domain for sites with a more technical audience, and www for sites I hope will attract some more normal visitors. My feeling is that most of the times I speak a URL to someone non-technical, they mentally add www to it (they often clarify verbally that they're doing that, too). Even if, like this site, it's already a subdomain. Seems like it's comforting - why fight it?
- anigbrowl 16y agoAgree completely. I am surprised it has persisted so long; the positive reason I can think of is that people are familiar enough with it that 'w w w dot (something)' is a useful cue for people listening to radio or TV adverts, who might otherwise not register the internet context until they hear the 'dot com'. For example 'Attention listeners! Are you sick of your nose? Get a new one at Doctor Bob's rhinoplasty. Whether you want roman, retrousse, or rhonocerous, we have them all in stock! Just go to...' ...our office on 5001 big highway? or nosesbybob.com? Of course, you could signal with 'point your browser to...' but apparently a majority of people don't even know what a browser is, they just think of it-and-the-web as 'the internet'. So I think 'wwwdot'* will stick around as an aural cue. On the other hand, any sysadmin who doesn't redirect automatically from the main domain should be shot. * There was once a comedy program on TV that used to read it out as 'wuh wuh wuh dot...,' and I have to admit that this is how I've always thought of the string in my own mind.
- _delirium 16y agoThere are some minor technical niceties with using www as the main one, in that you can CNAME it to somewhere else, while you can't CNAME a bare domain.
- jagbolanos 16y agoIts information value is 0. If it is just the website everybody just assumes www. is at the beginning, ignore it (or type the domain name in google).