2 ms·

Yeah, I think the real problem I have is the impossibility of opting out of the indentation style. Not using any indentation or newlines seems pretty extreme. A

• masklinn 9y ago
  > Not using any indentation or newlines seems pretty extreme. You can certainly use indentation and newlines, my examples were just demonstrating the ability to "obviously" not invoke layout since there's nowhere layout information can be. Whether to use layout (braceless) or explicit structuring (braceful) is solely determined by a brace being present after a listed keyword, you can have any whitespace you want around it, and you can make that decision on a keyword-by-keyword basis[0] although it will apply to the entire block, so you can write module Main where -- no brace, layout rules main = do { -- brace, no layout let { a = 3 }; let { b = 5 }; print $ a + b; } Now here the let statement (rather than expression) is a bit tricky because if we don't use the braces the ; will bind to the "let" which is not using layout, resulting in a parse error. An alternative — and the way do blocks normally desugar — is to use ; as a separator prefix, a style also used by e.g. Elm: module Main where main = do { let a = 3 ; let b = 5 ; print $ a + b } [0] this is very very useful when generating code which must surround user-provided code: the generated code can be braceful and the user-provided code can independently use layout without conflicts.
  • moomin 9y ago
    Thank you. Need to spend a bit more time grokking this.