3 ms·
It seems to me that this advice forgets it's own lesson: A policeman/woman can only get you in trouble. In many cases, a copy really does just want to have a 5
by mistermann 9y ago
It seems to me that this advice forgets it's own lesson: A policeman/woman can only get you in trouble.
In many cases, a copy really does just want to have a 5 minute chat, and if you stonewall them (Am I being detained?), they might decide to exercise their power to get you in trouble, just to return the sentiment of unreasonableness.
- jimmywanger 9y agoDid you not watch the video? Even if you tell the absolute truth, the cops _might_ be able to twist that against you somehow. Don't give them any ammunition. Sure, if the cop wants to be a hard-ass, let him haul you in. He probably won't because of all the paperwork. The point of the video is that it's the cop's job to try to haul you in. Don't do the cop's job for him - he's much better at it than you are defending your innocence. For an example, watch "My Cousin Vinnie". The sheriff accuses the defendant of shooting a clerk. The defendant responds incredulously "I shot him?" How do you think that reads in court in a deadpan voice?
- dmix 9y agoRight, telling someone to "say the bare minimum" doesn't mean saying nothing at all and treating the officer poorly. Don't act superior because you happen to know your rights, that's basically as bad as being a two-bit criminal in their eyes. Police don't recruit people based on their sensitivity and grasp of common sense, they are people who enjoy the power dynamic the job gives them and for the most part 99% of the time people go out of their way to respect them (for better or worse) and whenever someone doesn't they over react, like a slighted bully in elementary school. Police culture and training promotes this toxic type of no-common sense approach to handling situations, it trains them to be assertive and the 'alpha-male' in all situations, so any type of rebellion against this idea to them is treated as sacrosanct, at least by the average (aka dumb) officer. And yes, for the most part if you are respectful and non-confrontational you won't have any problems. Some people reject this entirely and think they have rights so they should assert them always. But ultimately these are social situations in which one party is given a significant imbalance of power, that goes well beyond the rational/common-sense "I didnt do anything wrong" context, and which goes well beyond the rights you do actually have - in a courtroom in front a judge. The simple fact is police can make your life miserable without crossing any legal/employer boundaries. The bureaucracy, political culture, and power structures allow this to happen. So if you care about this try to focus your energy on changing politics, police training, and the accepted police culture at the society/community level. In individual moments it's probably not worth the energy. But that said, never ever say anything you don't want to reveal to a police officer, even (or especially) if you broke a law, and never trust a single thing they say about it being "the best thing for you to do at this moment". Be polite and listen to what they say in terms of behaviours, but if you are pressed repeatedly after not wanting to say something, then say you want a lawyer present because you don't feel comfortable in this situation. And yes sometimes that requires you being a "dick" to be assertive, but that's because the police have an incentive to make you feel that way. As long as you are a good citizen otherwise they have nothing on you and the truth will come out in court, if they can prove you did anything to get to that point.
- tertius 9y ago> rebellion against this idea to them is treated as sacrosanct, at least by the average (aka dumb) officer Stereotyping or do you have some evidence is a large population supporting this assertion?
- dmix 9y agoJust the entirety of my life experience and listening to endless hours of police arrest interrogations videos daily which my partner works on in my home office as a defense attorney. Plus the hundreds of true crime documentaries and books we watch/read. If a researcher was to measure the average IQ of a police officer and it's affect on wrongful arrests/convictions I would more than support such a study....