3 ms·
> How can we NOT expect cops to kill us? That's what the state is - that's what it does That's not what happens in most countries, though, so clearly it's not
by pron 9y ago
> How can we NOT expect cops to kill us? That's what the state is - that's what it does
That's not what happens in most countries, though, so clearly it's not a problem with "the state", but with American law enforcement. Police can overpower one unarmed person, regardless of how strongly he resists, without killing him. Not only they can, but that's what they do in most places: you resist -- they take you by force, but they don't kill you.
Also, using violence to enforce the laws long predates the state (what we call "the state" today was largely created only in the 17th century). The role of the state is to reduce the number of people who can employ violence when enforcing the law (and, of course, to centralize the law itself), from your local lord and his soldiers, the church and its inquisitors, your local robber-baron and his Pinkertons, to those whose training and licensing is, at least hopefully, supervised and sanctioned by the general public.
- ci5er 9y ago> That's not what happens in most countries ... with American ... Fair point. In the process of resisting, USians are a risk of shooting back. But I can't say whether I agree or disagree with your election of the qualifier "most" In my small (I say) set of adversarial encounters with law enforcement in Japan, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam, there were more than one person on the law-enforcement side of the encounter that appeared more than willing to do terminal violence, should there be any sort of excuse to do so. And those are "nice" places! I don't know what I would have found if I'd actually gone somewhere rough...