4 ms·
I don't get it... svn commit file1 file2 somemorestuff Surely you just commit the files you want, and leave out the ones you're still working on :/ What am I
by axod 19y ago
I don't get it...
svn commit file1 file2 somemorestuff
Surely you just commit the files you want, and leave out the ones you're still working on :/
What am I missing?
- gcv 19y agoYou're missing that you may have made not one, but multiple substantive changes to file1, and you want to commit those changes separately.
- axod 19y agoThen you have a mess whatever revision control system you use. You have to manually decide which changes you want to commit in the file, and which you don't. I still say it's better to avoid that mess in the first place.
- mhartl 19y agoThen you have a mess whatever revision control system you use. True, but some make it much easier than others. Git is one of the easy ones. I still say it's better to avoid that mess in the first place. The article addressed this, and concluded as follows: Here’s a general principle I would like my VCS to acknowledge: moving from the present point B to some desired point C should not require a change in behavior at point A in the past. More simply, the phrase: “you should have,” ought to set off alarm bells.
- gcv 19y agoFrom whose perspective is that a mess? From the perspective of a source control system which cannot deal with how I choose to work? Honestly, no offense meant, but I'm starting to wonder if Subversion is the Blub of source control systems.
- axod 19y agoFor me it's a mess. If I start to fix bug B on top of a half implemented feature A, I end up with a mess. I don't understand why you would work that way, and don't understand what git solves that svn doesn't. You still have to untangle the mess yourself.
- gcv 19y agoYou've seriously never looked at a file and said to yourself, "These changes belong in two separate commits"?
- allertonm 19y agoThis only works if you can guarantee that the changes are not intertwingled in the same code block. He is also taking a gamble that the result of his selection will actually parse/compile/pass unit tests (select as appropriate) - he has no way to be sure of this. He is pretty much going to have to do a "get" into another working copy to be able to check this out, so I don't think he is gaining quite as much as he believes.