5 ms·
That's a good point, but much of social research breaks down when you start talking about imaginary worlds. For example, I see (mostly very young) people oppose
by pron 9y ago
That's a good point, but much of social research breaks down when you start talking about imaginary worlds. For example, I see (mostly very young) people oppose affirmative action on grounds similar to, "but in a perfect world, skin color shouldn't matter, therefore such laws are bad." This may be true, but laws are aimed to tackle the world we actually live in, not the one we wished we lived in. I call that "spherical-cow sociology".
Similarly for most of social research; it assumes that the findings be taken in the context of other information we have about our actual world. In a perfect world, 100% of homicide deaths would be for those who "deserve" it (I don't think resisting arrest qualifies, but let's say they're killed in the course of stopping them from killing others on the spot), but the assumption of such statistics is that we don't live in such a world. It would still be interesting to know how many of those deaths were necessary, but I think that knowing what we know about the chance of the police being present during homicides, the number of perpetrators vs. number of victims etc.[1], one third seems like a high number. That it's low compared to what we'd expect in a spherical-cow world where the police have super-powers should not affect much how we view the data given what we know about the real world (although it's true that some additional data would clarify matters further).
[1]: For example, one of the few very clear cases of justified homicide is during mass shootings, vehicle-ramming and the like. The ratio of perpetrators to victims in those cases is usually much lower than 1:3.
- ci5er 9y ago> I don't think resisting arrest qualifies This pull quote isn't related to your main point, but to digress a bit on it... The state, having a presumed monopoly on the legitimate use of pre-emptive force, reacts this way to application of laws, no? For example - there is a law that says that I can't plant pink flowers or sell looseys or whatever. I violate that law. The progression of consequences subsequently goes like this: o I get a fine. I don't pay it o I get a fine on that fine. And a stern warning. I don't pay it. o They send a note or an armed-or-not person to invite me to go spend a few days in a metal box. I do not go. o They send armed persons to forcibly retrieve me to put me in that metal box. I resist. o They apply overwhelming force to ... well, force me. I resist more. o They kill me. It does NOT matter what the law is (chewing bubble gum, paying taxes, open container, lemonade stand licensure, drinking a beer outside of 7-11), the sequence of escalation is largely the same. How can we NOT expect cops to kill us? That's what the state is - that's what it does - that's its function when faced with non-compliance with whatever set of rules our elected representatives have put into place.
- pron 9y ago> How can we NOT expect cops to kill us? That's what the state is - that's what it does That's not what happens in most countries, though, so clearly it's not a problem with "the state", but with American law enforcement. Police can overpower one unarmed person, regardless of how strongly he resists, without killing him. Not only they can, but that's what they do in most places: you resist -- they take you by force, but they don't kill you. Also, using violence to enforce the laws long predates the state (what we call "the state" today was largely created only in the 17th century). The role of the state is to reduce the number of people who can employ violence when enforcing the law (and, of course, to centralize the law itself), from your local lord and his soldiers, the church and its inquisitors, your local robber-baron and his Pinkertons, to those whose training and licensing is, at least hopefully, supervised and sanctioned by the general public.
- ci5er 9y ago> That's not what happens in most countries ... with American ... Fair point. In the process of resisting, USians are a risk of shooting back. But I can't say whether I agree or disagree with your election of the qualifier "most" In my small (I say) set of adversarial encounters with law enforcement in Japan, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam, there were more than one person on the law-enforcement side of the encounter that appeared more than willing to do terminal violence, should there be any sort of excuse to do so. And those are "nice" places! I don't know what I would have found if I'd actually gone somewhere rough...
- scotty79 9y agoIf force is overwhelming then you are overwhelmed and put in the metal box. There's no posdibility for you to meaningfully resist so there's no reason to kill you. The killing is only possible by mistake at any stage of this process. Even on the first one. They collected a fine from you and you have no money to buy yourself life saving medicine and you die. They killed you by taking away you last money at the moment your life depended on it. Probability of killing you obviously increases as escalation progresses but never reaches 100%