2 ms·
Let's see what happens with each of those reactions. CO2 + H20 + CaCO3 yields Ca(HCO3)2 + energy. This reaction turns calcium carbonate into calcium bicarbona
by btilly 16y ago
Let's see what happens with each of those reactions.
CO2 + H20 + CaCO3 yields Ca(HCO3)2 + energy. This reaction turns calcium carbonate into calcium bicarbonate, which is water soluble and floats off.
HC03 is unstable, and only exists in a stable form when combined with a metal ion. Such as happened above in a reaction that came out of destroying calcium carbonate.
C03 is unstable, and only exists in a stable form when combined with a metal ion. The supply of such metal ions at the present time is relatively stable and is uncorrelated with temperature.
And when you dissolve CO2 in H2O, there is an equilibrium balance between C02 + H2O and H2CO3.
So half the compounds you list don't exist on their own. And even high school chemistry is enough to tell you that adding CO2 to a marine environment with lots of CaCO3 is going to have an inevitable net effect of dissolving some of the CaCO3 that is there.
You'd have been better off falling back on the fact that the oceans are large, and that ph is locally more affected by ocean currents and upwelling from the deep ocean than it is by anything in the atmosphere. Because it is true that the yearly variation at any given location exceeds the total rise in the 20th century, and also exceeds the projected rise in the 21st century. (That said, the problem appears at the peaks, and high peaks can cause die-offs even though ph levels spend most of their time in a good range.)