7 ms·
This is based on a false assumption: that the proper police response to life-threatening criminal acts is to kill the perpetrator. If you get past the they des
by keiferski 9y ago
This is based on a false assumption: that the proper police response to life-threatening criminal acts is to kill the perpetrator.
If you get past the they deserve it Puritan mentality, the ideal scenario is for police minimize death (of criminals and police officers) at all costs. Numerous other countries handle violent criminals in ways other than "kill them immediately"; the tendency of police officers to use immediate lethal violence can most likely be explained by the aforementioned Puritan "punishment" mentality, a strong culture of guns and violence encouraged constantly through the media (news, movies, and otherwise) and a myriad of other factors.
- gaius 9y agothe tendency of police officers to use immediate lethal violence can most likely be explained by the aforementioned Puritan "punishment" mentality It must be horrible to be an American cop. All that training, the weapons, the body armour, the radio to immediately summon a whole squad of armed goons who may or may not even have a tank, and they regularly feel so terrified by women in pyjamas or pet doggos that they must immediately resort to lethal force.
- ojbyrne 9y agoBlame the NRA. The proliferation of handguns and the militarization of the police are a positive feedback loop.
- ci5er 9y agoThe NRA is responsible for militarization of domestic police?
- Tomte 9y agoSure, both to that and to policemen‘s fear of simple traffic stops. In most other countries the police officer can encounter a citizen without drawn gun because the odds of the citizen wielding a gun or worse are miniscule. In America even the drawn handgun might not be superior armament.
- krapp 9y agoI'm no fan of the NRA but let's be honest about cause and effect. Fear by the police, the proliferation of firearms in the US and the arms race between the people and the state are all consequences of the Second Amendment of the US Constitution working, arguably, as intended. The NRA didn't cause any of that, although they do make hay of it for their own political and financial ends.
- Tomte 9y agoThe NRA is the predominant defender of 2nd amendment rights, which is, arguably, the second worst idea of the US constitution (after the extreme formulation of the first amendment).
- refurb 9y agoReally? My position is that the 2nd amendment is one of the best ideas in the US Constitution.
- Tomte 9y agoYes, really. One of those points where it seems to matter a lot in which culture one has been brought up.
- macintux 9y agoIf the 2nd amendment were a great idea, they'd have written it intelligibly. Some of us parse the rationale such that it seems obsolete: we no longer rely on a militia to defend the nation, we have a professional military for it. > A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State Some of us, obviously, don't.
- krapp 9y agoThe authors probably thought it was intelligible, the intent was obvious and didn't need to be elaborated on. And now we're still arguing about the meaning of that damned comma...
- KGIII 9y agoCan you elaborate on why you want to blame the NRA? I should disclose that I own a number of firearms, many of them sidearms, and don't like the NRA very much, nor have I ever donated to them or been a member. I'm just curious as to how you see them as being the source to blame.
- ojbyrne 9y agoI’m not sure what I need to elaborate. The NRA promotes wider gun ownership and more expansive concealed carry. Police use wider ownership of guns and concealed carry to justify more use of deadly force and militarization. In any other country than the US, this feedback loop would be obvious. In the US the NRA works to blur the obvious by talking about “responsible gun owners” while eliding the leakage between responsible and irresponsible owners.
- KGIII 9y agoAnd this led to the police militarization?
- ojbyrne 9y agoIt's not the only cause (I'll save you the rant on US defense spending, you can watch Why We Fight (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0436971/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0436971/) , but it's a positive feedback loop. I don't believe I used the word "led" or suggested one caused the other. I am suggesting that once gun ownership (and concealed carry) and police militarization are established, one reinforces the other.
- KGIII 9y agoAh, you said blame them. I'd assumerd that meant you felt they were the cause of both. I was pretty confused. Thanks for clearing that up. I am a fan of responsible firearm ownership, but not the NRA - by the way. I don't know if I'd blame them, but I'd agree that they contribute to the 'gun culture' that ends up with irresponsible people wanting to own firearms.
- blattimwind 9y agoI think your explanation is somewhat simplistic, but the observation that societies different from the US manage without the massive police violence is of course spot on. There was a (now deleted) comment a few minutes ago about a police response resulting in someone being shot by the police, the commenter concluded that it was overall reasonable given the circumstances, since no one else got hurt. That looks like a rather low standard to hold police to, at least from my socialization... ... and I think it is pretty clear that the relation between police and (the other) people [1] is a societal dialogue. When the majority of people think it is ok for the police to shoot people over fairly minimal whateveractions or -inactions, then the police force will act in that direction. If the majority considers that unacceptable, then the police will try harder not shooting people. It is similar to guns methinks; if a majority actually felt that regular shootings are an issue that ought to be fixed, then ... duh... something would happen. Nothing happens, though. What does that say about the society this takes place in? [1] A word that gets used here sometimes (in mostly American, Russian or 3rd world contexts) is civil[ists], which sounds kinda strange to me (from my perspective police is a civil institution, not a para-military institution that you can contrast with civil - more differences in the same vein).
- thisacctforreal 9y agoMass shootings in America are not an easy problem to fix. If 0.00005% of the population decides to spend the last 20 minutes of their life going on a murder spree, there's not much you can do, at least in the context of America. Guns are prolific in the US: between 2000 and 2010, 2,000,000 AR15s alone were manufactured for domestic use. Deciding on a set of laws to control that number of firearms to end these arbitrary events is not simple, and perhaps not feasible with how many citizens regard firearm ownership a right. California has some of the strictest gun laws, but has been victim to more mass shootings than other states (of course depends on the definition of mass shooting). America Uncovered (from Chris Chappel of China Uncensored) does a relatively good unbiased video on the topic https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hAtLnTyimT0 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hAtLnTyimT0 [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/25/us/25shooters.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/25/us/25shooters.html [2] https://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2012/dec/17/how-many-ar15-rifles-sold https://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2012/dec/17/how-ma...
- stoolpigeon 9y agoIt's not a Puritan mentality. It's the fact that any person they interact with could be armed. The reason many other countries police deal with violent criminals in a different way is because it is very unlikely those criminals will be armed. Where I live (Hungary) there is almost no gun violence. The few instances I'm aware of that do involve guns are things where violent groups are involved like organized crime or right-wing groups. In those cases I think that the police go in prepared for something different when they interact with people on a day to day basis. When I moved here from the US it was a big adjustment. I would hear a loud bang and think someone had fired off a gun. Now I hear the same noise and realize it is fireworks or construction. When I'm out in the city I no longer have to worry about an armed confrontation and that's relaxing. In fact I didn't realize how much those things weighed on me in the US until I got away from it. The proliferation of guns is the reason so many people get shot in the US and it's no surprise the police are a big part of it.
- ci5er 9y ago1) Where did you live in the US? I'm in a medium-ish sized metroplex (whatever that means) of about a million people, and I never hear live fire. 2) Why would you worry about a (remote) gun-shot that you heard? By the time you hear it, you will be already shot-or-not. If not - why worry?
- yorwba 9y ago> By the time you hear it, you will be already shot-or-not. If not - why worry? If you're not shot now, you could still be shot later. So trying to assess the situation to find out whether more shots will be fired seems like a good idea.
- stoolpigeon 9y agoI have lived in a number of places - Phoenix, AZ, Chicago, IL, Orlando, FL are probably the spots I spent the most time. When I lived in Glendale, a suburb of Phoenix, the city installed a system that could track gunfire and pinpoint the location for police. I can say I've heard gunfire in every city I've mentioned and called it in to police in those places more than once. I don't even know where to begin with 2. I was fishing with a friend on the Verde river in AZ. We were just below the Horseshoe dam. We were fishing for catfish at night. Someone a little further down river (couldn't see them through the bushes and such) started firing off guns. We immediately packed up and left. They were probably partying and shooting up into the air. The idea that if you hear gunfire you should just ignore it unless you've been hit - well I have to believe you are just trolling.
- ewjordan 9y ago> the ideal scenario is for police minimize death (of criminals and police officers) at all costs Do you really believe this in all situations? I don't. In a standoff between 5 cops and 15 criminals I'd rather see the cops kill them all than vice versa, since the cops didn't create the bad situation in the first place. We all weight lives based on their moral value and culpability in the situation. Maybe that's an extreme example, but the way it happens more often is that a suspect pulls a gun, points it at a single cop, and the cop has to decide whether to kill the suspect or die him/herself. I'd always argue that in such a situation the cop should shoot. Are you suggesting that shoot to wound is a better policy?
- vidarh 9y agoIf there is a standoff and the police does not have a significant advantage of numbers, they've already messed up. Maybe using their guns will be the right response at that point, but where they failed at minimizing death was when their response was so crazily inadequate in the first place that they got pinned down by superior numbers (if they're not pinned down, and there aren't civilians at immediate risk, they can/should wait for reinforcements). In the UK for example, police is more likely to respond with a factor of 4x-5x more officers than suspected criminals, and will avoid approaching until they know they have numerical and tactical superiority. Of course, sometimes that fails - you can't predict every possible situation, but it's rare.
- vidarh 9y agoAn example I tend to give is the case a while back where someone was wielding an axe. Two police officers went after him, and the axe-wielding man was shot and killed because he went for one of them. Success, surely? He protected his partner, who might have been harmed. The way something like this would likely have gone down somewhere like the UK would be that the first responders would have called for reinforcement, and then kept their distance and waited. You don't engage someone armed unless there is immediate danger to others. She should never have been close enough to be in danger. In the UK they may or may not call in a firearms team in such a case, but if they did, they'd be brought in as a precaution. More likely they'd close down the area around him and wait, and wear the guy down, and then see if they could get him to drop the weapon peacefully. For comparison there was a case of a man robbing a house near me a while back unarmed, and the police brought in 20 officers, chased him until he climbed onto a roof. Then they simply waited for 4-5 hours until he accepted he had no way out. So many of the cases I hear about from the US is down to impatience and seemingly some kind of belief that they need to stop things as quickly as possible rather than trying to stop things with as little conflict as possible. I don't think it's necessarily so much punishment as fear that if they don't do something, things will escalate. But most of the time if you contain a threat and wait, the level of conflict will de-escalate. So much violence boils down to fear that the other side will be willing to use more violence. And that fear is pervasive through some groups of people. E.g. we see that in the insistence of keeping or carrying weapons.
- __s 9y agoOn that last point: people are more likely to resist arrest when they're afraid police are going to kill them during the process of arrest
- heurist 9y agoOr through neglect after arrest
- michaelt 9y agoI wonder if some of the preference for violence in the American policing tradition goes back to Western films - where outlaws are wanted dead or alive, a quick draw is the main thing a lawman needs, and the climax of the film is the lawman meeting the bad man in the street, drawing first and shooting him dead.
- thescribe 9y agoIf the government cannot be counted on to use their monopoly of force why wouldn't everyone resort to vigilantism?