14 ms·
Police Homicides in the United States
- denweb 9y ago1312
- myopicgoat 9y agoThe question discussed is interesting and important but I felt the structure of this article is somewhat unfortunate: it explains very well and objectively some of the statistical issues and solutions with censored data but then when discussing how it’s applied to the particular case of police homicide does so with a rather obvious bias towards assuming that the situation is very bad and comes up with a number, manually inflated, of 1500/y. It may be, but it’s unhelpful to mix stats and opinion and not separate the two clearly IMO. It would have been nice to present the raw data, then the statistical techniques and then finally an opinion based on the results. That being said some important points are highlighted in terms of a lack of accountability of the police in the US.
- ekianjo 9y agoIn terms of accountability I cannot think of any country where the police force is actually accountable for anything they do. Abuse of power pretty much everywhere and the police gets a blank check.
- usrusr 9y agoTrue. But most countries give their police more powers to abuse and somehow they see less of their police power abuse involving dead people. It can't be a direct reason (police certainly don't shoot to kill because they need to fulfill some imagined power abuse quota), but I suspect that the shootings are indirectly rooted in Americans expecting their police to do their jobs without ever doing more that polite chitchat unless they declare someone a clear and imminent danger. I'd rather be harassed than shot at.
- ekianjo 9y agoI think the book "the rise of the warrior cop" explains that how the police does their job in the US has changed and why. It gave pretty satisfying answers as to why it's become what it is now. https://www.amazon.com/Rise-Warrior-Cop-Militarization-Americas/dp/1610394577 https://www.amazon.com/Rise-Warrior-Cop-Militarization-Ameri...
- leereeves 9y agoI agree, the leap to 1,500 (in three sentences) needs to be explained. The analysis that was actually explained in the article led to an estimate of 1,250/y, which is slightly higher than but rather close to the numbers from other sources. The Guardian's list of people killed by police in 2015 and 2016 identifies approximately 1100/y. [1] And the Bureau of Justice Statistics released preliminary findings (for June to August 2015) from a redesigned Arrest-Related Deaths program that extrapolated an estimated 1200 arrest-related homicides per year. [2] 1: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2015/jun/01/the-counted-police-killings-us-database https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2015/jun/... 2: https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/ardprs1516pf_sum.pdf https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/ardprs1516pf_sum.pdf
- jonchang 9y agoCan you point to exactly where you believe the analysis becomes inaccurate due to the researchers' purported bias? I found the analysis quite clear and the paper was even more illuminating. If your issue is with the "final" 1,500 number (increased from 1,250), you'll find that it's well-supported in both the blog post: >>> Keep in mind that the Bureau of Justice Statistics report itself excludes many jurisdictions in the United States that openly refuse to share any data with the FBI. The true number of homicides committed by police is therefore even higher. Though not a true estimate, my best guess of the number of police homicides in the United States is about 1,500 per year. And the paper: >>> As mentioned in Banks et al. (2015), these list intersection counts only include jurisdictions that reported any data (about 70%). As such, these numbers should be interpreted as estimates of the number of people killed by police in the reporting jurisdictions. If the reporting jurisdictions are missing from the dataset not because there were truly no killings in those areas during this period, but instead because they chose not to report homicides by police, the true number of police homicides could be 30% higher than we have suggested here. Note that 1500 represents a 20% increase over 1250, which is lower than the 30% maximum estimate presented in the paper.
- leereeves 9y ago> If the reporting jurisdictions are missing from the dataset not because there were truly no killings in those areas during this period, but instead because they chose not to report homicides by police That's a rather large assumption that needs to be justified.
- jonchang 9y agoIt is justified, both in the citation and the actual text. The ARD dataset is driven by self-reporting from various local agencies. The fact that the FBI's SHR data and the ARD dataset have a mismatch (that is, there are police-related homicides in SHR that are not present in the ARD data and vice versa) is proof enough that there is underreporting in these datasets!
- leereeves 9y ago
- adamnemecek 9y agoI’m guessing this was posted in response to the release of a cop who murdered David Shaver http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/ct-daniel-shaver-police-video-20171208-story.html http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/ct-daniel-sha... When did this dystopia begin? It wasn’t too long ago right? What can I do to prevent this? There isn’t an organized dissent group. Idk what it really that I want.
- acover 9y agoI was curious. Apparently in the USA police shootings aren't tracked centrally [1]. The Washington Post only started trying to track it in 2015. 1 - http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-36826297 http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-36826297
- TaylorAlexander 9y agoI would think Black Lives Matter would be an organized resistance group, no?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoIt's an organized resistance group, but it's not what we need. Just the name Black Lives Matter is loaded with racial connotations that don't help the situation. We need to focus on police demilitarization everywhere and with everyone, not just around a single race.
- dadada07 9y agoBlack Lives Matter does want demilitarization everywhere and with everyone. You're getting hung up on the name.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoIt's not just me. It's just not a good organization to stand behind to focus on the demilitarization of the police. It's too racially motivated to gain popular support. "Black Lives Matter is an international activist movement...that campaigns against violence and systemic racism towards black people... The U.S. population's perception of Black Lives Matter varies considerably by race... former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani, meanwhile, has accused it of racism." [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Lives_Matter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Lives_Matter
- pm24601 9y agoand this is why i don't like to deal with police. They can't control their weapons
- cies 9y agoState is not controlling their police: they mostly walk after committing brutalities. Thus they've learned there is no need to restrain themselves.
- ako 9y agoThey can't control their weapons because they have to operate in a society that can't control its weapons...
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoOther countries have plenty of weapons around, yet don't have police that use deadly force immediately. Finland is a prime example[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estimated_number_of_guns_per_capita_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estimated_number_of_guns_per_c...
- indubitable 9y agoIt's not about the weapons, it's about the people with the weapons. Finland has a national murder rate of 1.6. [1] At first that doesn't seem too bad as our murder rate is "only" about 300% higher. But that comparison by itself is quite misleading. Crime, and especially the most violent crimes including murder, are not evenly distributed in the US. They're heavily centralized into relatively small areas. So for instance these [2] are the crime data for Ferguson, Missouri where Michael Brown was killed. In the year Michael Brown was killed, their homicide rate was double the US average. It's now skyrocketed to 42.8 - 2,675% higher than Finland. To give some context to that 42.8 the murder rate in Mexico is 16.35. In Columbia it's 26.5. As a matter of fact, in terms of nations - there are only 5 places in the world more dangerous than Ferguson, Missouri -- a town of some 20k people. I'm certainly not condoning police actions, but at the same time I think people don't really consider these situations in terms of context. Somebody, seemingly without irony, suggested we ought disarm the police. Imagine disarmed police in Mexico.. now increase the danger they face by 300%. That's what disarming police in areas like Ferguson, Missouri would be akin to. This sort of reality is very foreign to us, who I suspect for the most part have led very privileged lives. And so we extrapolate our lives to a situation where suddenly the police are just killing people. And that would indeed be insane. It's so foreign for us to imagine how dangerous many places in the US are -- and it's these locations where the systemic police violence tends to also be heavily centralized. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intention... [2] - http://www.city-data.com/crime/crime-Ferguson-Missouri.html http://www.city-data.com/crime/crime-Ferguson-Missouri.html
- gt_ 9y agoIt’s understandable that Americans continue seeking measurable blame, but I think this is a complicated result of wider cultural issues, none of which can be isolated. So sad.
- snsr 9y ago> but I think this is a complicated result of wider cultural issues, none of which can be isolated The lack of accountability for murders committed by police in the US is not a difficult "issue" to isolate.
- gt_ 9y agoI think the causes for it, particularly why we are apparently unable to adjust it are.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- foepys 9y ago3 years ago German police officer /u/krautcop posted on reddit about his opinion on why police violence is much higher in the US than in Germany. [1] This might open a new perspective to some people. 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskLEO/comments/2dgwkp/what_makes_american_police_use_deadly_force_much/cjpgcbe/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskLEO/comments/2dgwkp/what_makes_a...
- tomalpha 9y agoThat is an excellent, well thought out and well written post. It’s not short but it’s well worth a read. I think he pretty much nails it. He also manages to be reasonably objective which can be tough for someone close to the subject matter. To summarize crudely, through the lens of my own biases and in a way that doesn’t do it justice at all (no really, go read it in full): - Police in Germany don’t have to shoot first or have twitchy trigger fingers because it’s so unlikely anyone will shoot at them. So they don’t. - The problems in the US are systemic, deep rooted in the culture of the society not just the police, and gun availability doesn’t cause the deaths but does significantly exacerbate the problem.
- sjg007 9y agoIt's highly unlikely anyone will shoot at a cop in the USA as well, especially during a traffic stop.
- foepys 9y agoThere are enough videos on the internet where exactly this happens to US officers. I don't want to link any because they are often very graphic but you can find one in 10 seconds on youtube. I dare you to find a single article about something like this from Germany or even the EU.
- sjg007 9y agoJust because there are videos and it happens doesn’t mean they happen enough for cops to be afraid.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoInteresting analysis. As a counterpoint to the headline that might be little fear-inducing, my first reaction when reading it was: only so little? Things must be bad. I mean: the perfect situation is when there are no homicides at all. But in a little less perfect imaginary world, in which bad people never get the chance to hurt innocents because police stops it, some bad people might still go down resisting arrest, at which point 100% of all homicides would be police-inflicted, and that would be good. Not perfect, but better than what we have. Statistics are funny this way. The real question is, how many of those killed by the police were killed in totally justifiable self-defense, and not just because of policemen being trigger-happy. Or, put another way, what's the probability that a person who is not resisting arrest to get "accidentally" killed by the police.
- headShrinker 9y agoI believe the reality you described is the basis for the movie minority report, where the cops are so good crimes are stopped before they happen. If I am a relatively good person when I decide to commit a crime there would be no warning for cops. There’s no trail of paperwork, rap sheet, or perp associates... if cops were to be able to stop me given what I just described, I’m not sure I would want to live in that reality. With the title in mind a third of strangers killed are killed by cops, shouldn’t they be better at not killing people?
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> I believe the reality you described is the basis for the movie minority report, where the cops are so good crimes are stopped before they happen. Or maybe criminals are mostly nonviolent. Implementation details, anyway. What I was aiming at is: in a world where the only people killed are ones who absolutely deserve it, the statistics would likely show that close to 100% of homicides are committed by police. > With the title in mind a third of strangers killed are killed by cops, shouldn’t they be better at not killing people? Yes, of course.
- StavrosK 9y ago
- Banthum 9y agoThe statistical abuse in this headline is extreme. It's so meaningless, yet so carefully designed to appeal to irrational confirmation biases. Consider some extremely simple thought experiments: e.g. Imagine a world where police do their job even better, and eliminate all murder. But, in some cases, they have to kill the murderer before he takes an innocent victim. They never kill unless it's absolutely necessary and justified. In such a world, this statistic rises to "All people killed by strangers are killed by police", which sounds worse than the headline, yet such a world is obviously better than ours. e.g. Imagine a world where police never do anything. They drink beer in the station all day. All people killed by strangers are killed by non-police. Such a world is much worse than ours, yet this stat looks a lot better. Just these very simple thought experiments should give you pause about what this statistical comparison actually means (or if it means anything at all). --- My two questions to those who think this is some sort of obvious travesty: 1. What would be a healthy ratio between [people killed by non-police strangers] and [people killed by police]? 1:5? 1:10? 1:100? Why? 2. How is this random choice of two statistics not just another variation on the Chinese robber fallacy? [1] [1] http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/09/16/cardiologists-and-chinese-robbers/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/09/16/cardiologists-and-chine...
- oblio 9y agoWell, maybe it helps to compare: Germany: 2155 homicides in 2011, 6 by the police.
- basicplus2 9y agoGerman killers are smarter?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI can't manage to read the whole thing. It starts from an assumption of guilt and corruption. It is looking for support for an accusation. Such an agenda does not make for good science. Don't get me wrong. I would be very interested in finding real solutions for the tendency to see Blacks gunned down by the police. My assumption is this known trend is the driving force behind this piece. I just think this is the wrong way to approach the problem space. How to lie with statistics is an excellent book. I highly recommend it. It is a large factor in my decision to not bother to read this piece too thoroughly.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agonot bother to read this piece too thoroughly. I wish I hadn't bothered to read your comment so thoroughly now.
- cup 9y ago>finding real solutions for the tendency to see Blacks gunned down by the police Stop hiring racist police. Stop aquiting police of murder. Stop using tax payers dollars to pay for compensation claims.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoStop hiring racist police. One of the problems is that racism is insidious. People who self identify as idealists who are not racist will still agree with cultural norms that are secondary or tertiary forms of racism. To try to illustrate this idea: In my twenties, after months of hearing about my husband's new best friend from work, I finally met the man. He was black. My husband and I were both white. My husband had never once mentioned that his new best friend was black, even though he talked about him constantly. I was shocked to realize that I had assumed he was white since my husband did not mention his race. In that instant, I realized this assumption was the product of a racist culture where such details mattered and needed to be stated privately ahead of time to avoid any awkwardness or misunderstanding. I realized that was how racism worked -- you just have certain social norms that may seem innocuous, but that reinforce the ongoing issue. Many people will not consciously question myriad social norms. People soak up social norms by being exposed to them and trying to fit in. There usually isn't lots of overt instruction on how and why we do such things. So, first you need someone to sort this out in their own heart and mind. Second, they need to disseminate this new standard, often at enormous risk to themselves. Questioning social norms is generally dangerous business and has a history of getting people killed. Trying to find genuinely not racist people in a generally racist culture is very challenging. Most people from such a culture who see themselves as not racist will still have ugly bad habits and mental models. And then, when they need to decide whether to pull the trigger or not, their biases will show, not because they hate Blacks so much that they want them dead, but because they don't trust Blacks as much as Whites. I don't believe this is a problem that will really be solved by simply punishing people more a la The beatings shall continue until morale improves. Instead, we need to improve trust and I don't how that can happen. But it certainly won't happen with our current approach to the problem space, where trust issues between the races in America seem to not even be part of the discussion. My original comment was downvoted to the negatives and one of the first three replies is a personal attack. The US was founded on the idea of innocent until proven guilty, but the public is not willing to follow that precept for this issue. Witch hunts tend to result in finding people guilty because that is what they set out to do. It is a very serious and damning flaw in this paper, but my comment on that aspect is not PC and is reason enough to lump me in with killer cops as part of the problem. In such an atmosphere, good luck with even having a productive discussion. And if you can't even discuss it, you are unlikely to solve it.
- always_good 9y agoOne of the worst videos I've seen on the internet is the Daniel Shaver execution from last year: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M62Va6Ft2cw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M62Va6Ft2cw The Sergeant (voice in the vid) thinks he's fucking Jigsaw, and he wasn't even the guy that pulled the trigger. America is fucked.
- cies 9y agoAnd it's one of many, just in 2017 and on camera. > America is fucked. Yups. Unless when you have a lot of money/influence. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVHmshtmDqo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVHmshtmDqo
- jopsen 9y agoWhile guns are disproportionately aimed at poor people and minorities, bullets generally kill indiscriminately of wealth once fired. I don't understand why rich Americans let it sink so far...
- cies 9y ago> While guns are disproportionately aimed at poor people and minorities, bullets generally kill indiscriminately of wealth once fired. No idea what you are trying to say here...
- bufferoverflow 9y agoWhat's the percentage of the police killing are unjustified though? Even in this video the guy is reaching behind his back a couple of times, while being told to keep them visible.
- albertgoeswoof 9y agoBy those rules you can make any shooting justifiable. The man in the video is clearly distressed and trying to obey. The officer escalates the situation significantly.
- katastic 9y agoThat's a super careful wording when you realize two thirds of all people are killed by someone close to them.
- verroq 9y agoNo it only means two thirds of the people who are killed by a stranger are killed by someone who isn’t police.
- cybersol 9y agoThe article says that 75% are killed by people close to them. Of the remaining 25% killed by strangers, two-thirds of those are killed by non-police-officers.
- chrisan 9y agoCan we then say 8.3% of people killed are by police? 75% killed by people close to them (not sure if they showed police close to them deaths) 16.6% killed by a stanger 8.3% killed by a police stranger (not that that is good!)
- flexie 9y agoIn a few hours the Americans will wake up and a bunch of them on HN will say that it's a loaded or divisive or misleading title or that the statistics is flawed. And HN is decisively more progressive than most of the country which simply ignores this kind of news. It is the way it is in America, because - as a whole - they don't care that much about gun violence. It's mostly blacks and Latinos getting killed and they are still minorities. And the poor white Americans that also fall victim to police and other gun violence just don't have much political influence.
- chrisan 9y ago> It's mostly blacks and Latinos getting killed and they are still minorities. And the poor white Americans that also fall victim to police and other gun violence just don't have much political influence Honest question: Couldn't this just be grouped into "poor people" Are affluent blacks and latinos being killed? I am not denying racism by any means, but it seems people of poverty are most at risk.
- sintaxi 9y agoEven more accurate would be to say people who commit crimes are most at risk of being killed by the police.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y ago> they don't care that much about gun violence Don't blame either our messed up political system or our militarized police on us. At this point, our government is a corporate oligarchy that has been gerrymandered and rigged to the point that our vote does not matter, and the low pay of our cops combined with the stream of military gear and low amount of training made them trigger-happy. It's not our people that want this.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Feniks 9y agoSay what you will about US police departments: they keep the population in line and when shit goes down they don't run away. Trust me: you do NOT want the police to be your friend. They tried that experiment here.
- tsmarsh 9y agoWhats the ideal here? 1. Doctors 2. Foreign combatants 3. Police 4. Motorists 5. Other I can see how all of those groups perform tasks that might result in the death of strangers unavoidably. Doctors are the only ones who I’d actually pay to wager with my life, so I’d them to win. I’d like a world without wars, but I’m happy that we have a stading military. I lived in the UK for 30 years. It’s national news when they kill someone and they stand up and appologise for not having a better solution. That feels about right. But their number isn’t zero. And finally, cars. We’re already talking about the trolley problem wrt automated cars. It seems we accept that death from going 2-3 times our natural speed in vehicles 10x our weight is dangerous. But It would be nice if technology could get that death rate to lower than law enforcement.
- sintaxi 9y agoKeep in mind the ideal number would be 100% via proper police procedure.
- drallison 9y agoThe frequency of police homicides suggests that we, as a society, need to disarm the police.
- tomohawk 9y agoMichael Brown was shot because he was charging at a police officer. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/25/us/witnesses-told-grand-jury-that-michael-brown-charged-at-darren-wilson-prosecutor-says.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/25/us/witnesses-told-grand-j... Lumping him in with actual victims does actual victims a disservice.
- stctgion 9y agoIf an unarmed man charges at you, you don't have the right to kill them. Police forces all round the world manage fine with battons and other non lethal weapons.
- tomohawk 9y agoThere's plenty of other exemplars of police violence to make the point. No need to turn the incident with Michael Brown into something it wasn't. I'd hardly describe a violent, 6'4", 300 pound guy charging at me as something that needs to be dealt with with kids gloves. According to our legal tradition, you can use deadly force if you fear for your life. This is the universal right of all free people - to defend themselves.
- briandear 9y agoHow many police officers have been killed in the line of duty this year?
- danielvf 9y agoI'm wondering about the source data used for this. I looked up the nearest city, and the first two records listed aren't remotely homicides. In the first, a armed felon killed himself during after an eight hour standoff with the police. In the second, a man attacked a clerk at a hotel. When police arrived, then man was lying on the floor, bleeding. Police immediately called for medics, but the man became unresponsive and died before fire/medical arrived. These deaths are both counted as "arrest-related-deaths", which is to say, the actual moment of death was when the police were on scene, but in neither case did the police even use force. I didn't see a place in the article where these kind of situation was excluded. Did I miss something? [Edit, after more digging into the BJS data, it does contain a homicide flag, which is on about 61% of the records. As long as the OP is filtering by this, it's a good start. But take stats on public police killing websites with a big grain of salt, since these kinds of non-force cases are still included in the top level stats for the sites I checked.]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cyphunk 9y agoThe description of this technique is excellent. I once used this many years ago to determine the hidden depth of card card sharing networks for pay tv. it's not exact but it does help quantify issues with deep unreachable data, and sets a base line to compare against over time.
- RickJWag 9y agoI have known many cops, correctional officers, military police, etc. Without exception, all the ones I have known have been good, helpful people who would not harm someone intentionally. (There are obviously a few bad ones, but none that I have known.) It's one of the hardest, scariest, least fairly compensated jobs I can think of. Thank God for cops.