4 ms·
I've stopped buying devices that require some nebulous "cloud connectivity" to function. It's no longer an exchange of value that benefits me. My personal data
by ryandrake 9y ago
I've stopped buying devices that require some nebulous "cloud connectivity" to function. It's no longer an exchange of value that benefits me. My personal data is valuable and I see no reason to just hand it over to companies for no compensation. That's what you're doing when you use one of these cloud connected devices. You're giving up real value to gain nebulous value. At least that's how I see it--you might disagree and that's OK.
Particularly annoying are those devices that should be able to function without phoning home via an internet connection:
Security camera? Shouldn't need to phone home. Camera should turn on and stream directly to my display device. There's no need to connect to the mothership.
Thermostat? Shouldn't need to phone home. Device should let me control the temperature of my home and respond when I command it remotely. No need to connect to the mothership.
Media player? Shouldn't need to phone home. I have a library of files I'd like to play and don't care for any online services. No need to connect to the mothership.
I used to have a rule: If I don't have root on the device it goes on the guest network (no internal network access, only Internet). I still have that rule, but it's time to up the rule to "no internal or external network access without root".
- lph 9y agoI have a couple of devices that need to connect to the mothership, as a matchmaker between the device and its client app. NAT and firewalls are a big part of the reason, as is the need to have a way to locate the device in the absence of a static address or domain name. Sure, it's possible to work around these obstacles without a mothership, but doing so makes it too difficult for most mass market consumers.
- melling 9y agoYes, it’s a given on HN that someone will complain about privacy. I wrote this blog about the “groundhog day” comments back in September. https://h4labs.wordpress.com/2017/09/27/groundhog-day-amazon-updates-echosomeone-rants-about-privacy/ https://h4labs.wordpress.com/2017/09/27/groundhog-day-amazon...
- ryandrake 9y agoIn order to understand, try replacing "privacy" in your blog response with some other thing that you care deeply about. I believe the most straightforward way to normalize something you believe is wrong is to simply give up and stop calling it out as wrong. That said, if people think my viewpoint does not add to the conversation, I accept downvotes with grace.
- icebraining 9y agoYour post ignores the social effects of technology. In the early 20th century, someone complaining about cars could be told the same - after all, cars were still rare, they couldn't annoy you that much if you just didn't get one. Fast forward a few decades, and now they're impossible to avoid, and often there is realistic alternative if you don't want to uproot your life. This is because by their expansion, they shaped society until they were impossible to avoid. Similar thing happen to cellphones: in the 80s, if you complained that you didn't like that they allowed the provider to track your position, you could just be told not to get one. Nowadays, that decision is not nearly as easy, since many jobs expect you to be reachable at all times (e.g. those with "dynamic" working hours). A person building a DIY for personal use is fine. A company pushing a device to every home they can get it into can't be that easily ignored.
- jhall1468 9y agoYou are exchanging your data for convenience. Or in the case of Gmail, you are exchanging your data for a service/product. In the case of your Safeway card, you are exchanging your data for discounts, in the case of your credit cards you are exchanging your data for a loan. So no, you aren't "handing it over". You are being compensated in one fashion or another. Maybe that's not a good enough trade for you, and that's totally fine, but claiming there is no exchange of value is just nonsense.
- imgabe 9y agoNone of those are the examples OP was talking about. What value are you getting by having the thermostat connect to Google's servers rather than connecting to it directly? What do I get by letting Google see inside my house with a security camera that I couldn't get by connecting to the camera directly?
- username223 9y agoOff-topic, but... > In the case of your Safeway card, you are exchanging your data for discounts,... Does anyone not lie on those forms? Last time I checked, 234-567-8901 worked at Safeway, and someone else created it. Poisoning surveillance companies' databases costs you nothing, and hits them where it hurts.