3 ms·
Health insurance is a fairly competitive market - narrow profit margins, commodity good, many competitors (in most states, including NJ). If a health insurance
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Health insurance is a fairly competitive market - narrow profit margins, commodity good, many competitors (in most states, including NJ). If a health insurance company can raise prices, it's probably because costs are going up or are likely to do so in the near future. The calculus is fairly simple:
If I raise prices, my competitors don't, and costs don't go up, I lose customers.
If I raise prices, my competitors don't, and costs go up, I lose competitors.
Insurance companies all seem to be placing their bets on the latter case. If you feel they are wrong, feel free to bet against them.
- Ardit20 16y agoI don't quite know the situation in that market, but to provide an alternative, it could also be an oligarchy. That is, there's a number 1 guy with 60% share, a number 2 guy with 20% a number 3 with 10% and some little guys. It is not hard in an oligarchy to act like a monopoly.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI think you mean an oligopoly. In NJ, the top guy has 34%, the number 2 guy has 25%. Is that an oligopoly? http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/2009/06/pdf/health_competitiveness.pdf http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/2009/06/pdf/health_co... Oligopolies do tend to be correlated with monopolistic pricing, but I'm not sure they allow it in an otherwise competitive market. Most oligopolies which successfully raise prices tend to be in uncompetitive markets, e.g. cell or cable service, and the price increases may be caused by the hindered competition rather than the oligopoly itself. Consider the case of an oligopoly in the DRAM market: when they tried to raise the price of DRAM (2001-2002), they succeeded for a short time. They also collectively lost 3.3% of market share over those 2 years and members of the oligopoly (Hynix was the first, I think) quickly broke ranks in pursuit of increased profits. http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0EIN/is_2002_Dec_17/ai_95511290/ http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0EIN/is_2002_Dec_17/a...
- Ardit20 16y agoIf you are going to make a misleading statement, at least do not provide the data to clearly show your bendy argument. The combined market share of the largest and second largest insurer provider goes below 50% only in four states. It goes below 60% in only 5 states. That makes a combined 9 states out of 52 or so where there might not be an oligopoly. There are 19 states where their combined share is above 70% and I have used that cut off line strictly, not counting for example 69%. So yeah, it might be very competitive in 4 states, ok maybe in 9 states. These states seem to be the one I recognise such as California where the combined share is the lowest at 44%, but it seems that for the vast majority of people the market is hardly "very competitive" or competitive at all.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWhat misleading statement do you feel I made? Would it be the statement where I explicitly gave market share for the #1 and #2 companies, cited a source, and asked if you considered that an oligopoly? Also, a market can be highly competitive even if it supports an oligopoly. It may simply be the case that the oligopoly is outcompeting smaller players. See, for example, DRAM, PC's, cars (ignoring their recent bailout), big box retail stores.
- Ardit20 16y agoWell yes it is not a misleading statement strictly. The statement is true, but it is presented in a misleading way as the one you chose is hardly representative of the general market. I am not saying that the market is or is not highly competitive. Personally with seeing such share markets of 80% and 90% and one even 98% I think they hardly differ much from monopolies especially since unlike internet businesses there is I would think a high barrier to entry and unlike PCs it is not a new market. As for retail stores, at least in the UK, they hardly are competitive. We hear of price fixing all the time. They just engage in some game where they lower the prices by a penny and put them up by ten pence etc. But in any event my point was not to conclude whether the market is or not competitive, but only to provide and alternative.