7 ms·
The Latest Bull Case for Electric Cars: The Cheapest Batteries
- matt_wulfeck 9y agoOne of the greatest things about owning electric car is the absolutely minimal maintenance. It's actually a simple machine even though it's got a lot of technology in it. With less moving parts there's less things breaking. This is great news for the battery. The $209 price puts a new Leaf's battery in the $5k range, which is slightly more than what Nissan currently charges to replace it. At $100 then a new battery costs just $2400, even less with a trade in. I can imagine pay that amount every 8 years.
- manmal 9y agoWhat I don’t understand about the Leaf though - it’s about €13k more expensive than my car when it was new 2y ago (Kia Ceed SW), which even has more extras than the basic Leaf. If the 40kwh battery costs about 8k now, and the rest of the car is cheaper to build - where does the remaining 5k go? Nissan’s pockets? Or is this owed to lower unit production?
- oillio 9y agoThe Ceed is arguably the most mediocre car since the Pacer (with the possible exception of the Yaris). It is less expensive because it is cheaper, in every sense of the word.
- paganel 9y agoSeems to be pretty damn reliable though, at least judging by the comments I could find online from what looked like genuine owners. Not a lot of people can afford nowadays to drive expensive stuff, i.e. cars that break when you least expect it and that have expensive repair bills.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI imagine it's the lower unit production.
- dangrossman 9y agoNissan could almost certainly sell the Leaf for much less. When they wanted to clear out 2017 inventory, they offered $10000 discounts on top of all the government incentives. People took a brand new "$32,000" car home for $11,500 or less. But the market's currently willing to bear the price they're asking, so why not ask it? They sold over 20,000 units of the new 2018 Leaf in its first month on the market, and government incentives around the world make the actual buying price much lower than the sticker price for many buyers. I also have to disagree about the Kia Ceed being nicer than a basic Leaf. There's many years of fuel savings to factor in as well.
- ec109685 9y agoThey lowered the prices because they needed to sell a certain number for compliance reasons, so it was a better deal to sell them at a loss: Nissan says that lands the Leaf in a sweet spot between so-called compliance EVs—low-cost electrics with relatively limited range that manufacturers produce to meet certain regulations—and Chevrolet’s Bolt EV and Tesla’s Model 3, both of which offer greater than 200 miles of range but at a higher cost. https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/2018-nissan-leaf-first-drive-review https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/2018-nissan-leaf-first-...
- dangrossman 9y agoThat'd be a plausible explanation if they didn't run the $10K discounts outside CARB states, which they did. There were no "compliance" benefits to offset any theoretical losses on those sales.
- jacquesm 9y agoA good chunk of that difference is Korea vs Japan. Korean brands tend to be a lot cheaper than Japanese ones for the same level of trim and kind of car. And Nissan is one of the more expensive Japanese brands.
- cr0sh 9y agoIsn't there a limited amount of easily minable lithium metal, though? I could have sworn I read that somewhere...
- aeleos 9y agoAccording to this [0] with the current mining rates of lithium it was last us 365 years. However, given the exponential rate that technology has grown at, we will hopefully have figured a solution to this, either with different battery technology or some other way of getting lithium. [0] https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/is-there-enough-lithium-to-maintain-the-growth-of-the-lithium-ion-battery-m https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/is-there-enough...
- flyinghamster 9y agoAlso, let's not forget that old batteries can and will be recycled.
- linkregister 9y agoAnd are. Honda and Toyota have battery recycling programs for their hybrids.
- StillBored 9y agoRecycling or "reuse" because it seems that Toyota at least just gives them to green energy projects... An old hybrid battery when provided in quantities of a few hundred make great off grid energy storage devices. http://corporatenews.pressroom.toyota.com/releases/2015+yellowstone+lamar+battery+lentz.htm http://corporatenews.pressroom.toyota.com/releases/2015+yell...
- woodandsteel 9y agoI wonder how much of the cost of producing lithium is for energy that could come from renewables. And the trucks that transport the ore could be EV's. Let's get a whole ecosystem going here.
- simonsarris 9y agoI'm really grateful to Tesla/GM/Nissan and the people buying their cars. It seems like even with all the missed milestones (mostly Tesla) they're still dragging the industry forward by leaps. I wonder what it would look like without them. Remember, the original cellphone cost $4000-something, before inflation. I don't even like cars, I like trains and walking and hate what cars have done to our cities and villages, but electric cars are the first tech in a long time that has given me a sense of optimism for the future that I've only ever felt looking at old advertisements[1] from before I was born. If there were Beatitudes for technology, maybe they'd go like: "Blessed are the early adopters, for they allow the meek-pocketbook'd to inherit the earth." [1] https://imgur.com/FRKdZ2o https://imgur.com/FRKdZ2o (Have you ever seen an advertisement this positive? Ads these days mostly seem to fall into categories like glib humor and narcissistic 'buy this because you deserve it/you're the best/you can't be the best unless you have it'.)
- thephyber 9y ago> I'm really grateful to Tesla/GM/Nissan and the people buying their cars. I find it interesting that it's GM and not Ford. In the pre-2008 years (when Ford didn't need a bailout but GM did), Ford was investing in and rolling out gas-electric hybrids while GM was very heavily invested in SUVs and opted to minimize hybrid development while maximizing the $500/unit upgrade to "FlexFuel" type ICE drivetrains. When the price of gas spiked in 2005-2007, Ford benefitted while GM was reeling. I wonder if the restructure during the bailout changed GM's priorities...
- mywittyname 9y agoFord's electrification strategy was and still is hybridization (much like Toyota's). Personally, I think Ford/Toyota's strategy is best. Any improvement in the pure EV space also impact hybrids. It's completely possible for battery tech to improve to the point that a hybrid option is basically no cost (or at a cost savings). As in, instead of offering a V6 or turbo 4, a Ford can offer a hybrid drive train at the same price as those engines, but with the better performance and fuel economy. Also, keep in mind that Ford is a really a truck builder with a car division. The bulk of their profits come from F-series pickups and EV pickups are probably a long way off, but hybrid pickups are coming this generation. I think Nissan and GM are capitalizing on the fact that Ford and Toyota are sitting back, watching how the market evolves. But so far, neither the Leaf, Volt, nor Bolt have earned any any real ROI.
- saturdaysaint 9y agoThe new Nissan Leaf looks like an impressive step forward. Double the driving range and around a third more horsepower from last year's model for the same price. https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/2018-nissan-leaf-first-drive-review https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/2018-nissan-leaf-first-...
- dangrossman 9y agoIt's only 25-40% more range than last year's model, not double. The battery went from 30 kWh to 40 kWh.
- mywittyname 9y agoThe first generation battery was 24.0kWh, the 30.0 came a few years later as an option. The original range was 73 miles, then 105 miles, to now 150 miles. The OP was apparently comparing 2011 figures to 2018 ones.
- epx 9y ago+40% two times is double, so it is encouraging
- CalChris 9y agoI have a 2013 Nissan Leaf which is down to about 70 miles of range which is annoying. And still, I'd never buy another ICE again. My next car will be a Tesla or a Bolt. I don't think the 2018 Leaf is in the picture but maybe if Nissan gave me a good trade-in.
- esaym 9y agoThanks for the info. What was the range when new and what type of batteries does it have? And charge times?
- thephyber 9y agoNot the original poster, but I also own a first-gen Leaf. > What was the range when new When I bought my Leaf (used, 1.5 years old, half of MSRP) it showed 89mi with 12/12 of total potential capacity (compared to a new battery). After 5 years of ownership, it's down to about 60mi and the dash shows the battery is about 7/12 (meaning 5/12 of total potential capacity has been lost over time). > And charge times? All I know is it takes less than 8 hours. The local utility has a pricing plan for EV owners which encourages charging from 11p to 7am (cheaper during off-peak hours). I set the car to have full charge by 7a and it takes less than 8 hours for a full charge, even with the 120V plug. I have to remember to plug it in every night or I'm screwed in the morning (I don't use the phone app, but it has features that can mitigate your forgetfulness). I only drive it in-county and generally only one trip per day. I don't charge it during the day. I've also learned to drive like a very conservative retired person (to optimize range). The newer Leafs have a different battery (not interchangeable with 1st gen bodies) and the next gen Leaf will have even better range at a similar price).
- vvanders 9y agoI never found out if the new leafs actually use proper thermal management with a coolant loop on the pack. It's a shame the never did it on the original and battery life suffers because of it.
- CalChris 9y ago
- Animats 9y agoThat's just assuming ordinary mass production economies, not improved battery technology. This is just a 50% price decrease on increased manufacturing volume, which is not unusual. Battery cells are a good item for automated manufacturing. They're all the same, and they're made by the millions. (For some reason, Panasonic is having troubles at their battery cell plant in Nevada, but they should get past that. Panasonic makes the cells, Tesla assembles them into packs.) That also holds for recycling. Taking apart packs and recycling them should be an efficient process. It already is for lead-acid batteries.
- itchyjunk 9y agoHey didn't I see an article on the same website claiming Musk made some claim about semi which can't be true because of battery costs? I'm on phone so I couldn't double check it easily. Apologies if my memories are failing me.
- haberman 9y agoI just can't bring myself to replace my aging 2003 Subaru when I know cars are going to improve so much in the next 5 years. Between electric drivetrain technology and self-driving, it seems like things are going to improve rapidly in the next 5-10 years.
- BuckRogers 9y agoIf you get a Model 3 with the option, you're prepared for autonomous driving. Stretching out an 03 another 10 years will be a trying affair. It'll be a 24 year old car. Just buy one when you feel it needs to be replaced, which I'd assume should be soon. Be glad that there is an option out there that covers you, at least on the autonomous driving front. Tesla will enable it as soon as the legal situation it is sorted out. We're past the days of worrying about getting the battery chemistry good-enough too. I'd say you actually stretched that car out just the right amount of time to reap the benefits, perfect timing. I'm holding onto my '07 till I get my own Model 3, so I'm in a similar boat.