4 ms·
I am not Russian but I lived in the Soviet Union, and I think your impression is a different than mine. From what I remember, being an engineer on such a projec
by rdtsc 16y ago
I am not Russian but I lived in the Soviet Union, and I think your impression is a different than mine. From what I remember, being an engineer on such a project was a very prestigious job. It came with many perks that others didn't have.
> It's surprisingly easy to meet a budget in a totalitarian state...
That is true, but not because engineers are working in a Gulag. It is because of how a central-planning economy works.
Now of course you can argue that the whole country was one big Gulag and there is truth to that, but engineers working on these submarines probably were much, much better off than peasants in some corner of Siberia...
- jacquesm 16y agoI think with coercion pvg refers to the use of 'perks' (such as education for your kids and the privilege of being able to buy in the hard currency stores) rather than that family members were going to be shot if some device or gadget wasn't produced in time or at all. As for the oppression bit, the satellite states of the USSR were fairly ruthlessly kept in check, lots of very bad things happened there, more than we will probably ever know about and there are definitely examples of scientists that were forced to work on projects that they did not want to work on, such as Theremin. http://www.mediascot.org/atmosphere001 http://www.mediascot.org/atmosphere001
- rdtsc 16y ago> I think with coercion pvg refers to the use of 'perks' (such as education for your kids and the privilege of being able to buy in the hard currency stores) I think that relatively to other professions, engineering was actually prestigious. I was on awe of my uncle and father who were engineers and wanted to be like them. American kids today want to either play professional sports, be lawyers, CEO, or doctors. In ex USSR engineering was a relatively good profession to have without having to necessarily be involved too much into the party politics. The perks were no more coercieve than having health insurance tied to the job + mortgage payments in America. > As for the oppression bit, the satellite states of the USSR were fairly ruthlessly kept in check, lots of very bad things happened there, more than we will probably ever know about and there are definitely examples of scientists that were forced to work on projects that they did not want to work on, such as Theremin. That is true and that is a serious problem. We are yet to have the equivalent of Nuremberg trials for ex Soviet Union apartchiks and those who co-operated with them. I am not excusing them on a absolute moral ground. On a relative moral ground, I would like Americans to stop thinking their empire is less coersive and repressive. It treated many countries around the world very brutally, it installed ruthless fascist dictators all through South America and Asia. They are still fighting wars in the Middle East and "brave" drone pilots in Langley, VA are risking their lives daily driving to work so they can play video-games and with a push of a joystick putton assasinate individual we'll never know or hear about in a country we are not even at war with... So yes, I am for critisizing imperialism and oppression, but I am for doing so for all the imperialism and oppression not just the ones that the popular propaganda machine wants to critisize.
- jacquesm 16y ago> The perks were no more coercieve than having health surance tied to the job + mortgage paymentd in America. We're in agreement there. > They are still fighting wars in the Middle East and "brave" drone pilots in Langley, VA are risking their lives daily driving to work so they can play video-games and with a push of a joystick putton assasinate individual we'll never know or hear about in a country we are not even at war with... And that's a huge problem, and a very bad step to take. The bigger the distance between the opponents the bigger the chance of both fuck-ups and a de-humanizing effect. > So yes, I am for critisizing imperialism and oppression, but I am for doing so for all the imperialism and oppression not just the ones that the popular propaganda machine wants to critisize. Trying to get people to open their eyes to the faults of the country that they dearly love is a very uphill battle.
- pvg 16y agoPrestige and perks and not living in a Gulag don't mean lack of coercion. The central planning economy itself was fundamentally coercive. How many Soviet, say, Andy Groves or Woz's can you think of?
- rdtsc 16y agoAs I replied in another post, the coercion was no less than the coercion someone is under in US when their health insurance is tied to their job, they have mortgage payments to pay, and they have to buy an expensive house in a good school district. I understand that we love to paint everything in ex-Soviet Union with wide black brush stokes, but speaking from personal experience that is just inaccurate.
- pvg 16y agoNo, that's complete nonsense. The coercion was far greater than having your health insurance tied to your job. It included inability to travel, participate in the political process, no significant right to dissent, the constant risk of losing one's livelihood (and 'perks) for purely political reasons, severe restrictions on the ownership of private property, etc, etc, etc. Did Soviet engineers and scientists enjoy a fairly reasonable standard of living? Many did. But the comparison to the US and health care is ludicrous on its face.
- rdtsc 16y ago> It included inability to travel, participate in the political process, no significant right to dissent, the constant risk of losing one's livelihood (and 'perks) for purely political reasons, severe restrictions on the ownership of private property, etc, etc, etc That did not include engineers only. It was true for everyone. But that doesn't mean people were crying on the streets and committing suicide. Engineers that never participated or cared to participate in dissent or political activities didn't have it bad. No homes with 2 car garages but a decent standard of living. A good apartment, healthcare, 1+ month seaside resort vacation, health care, education for your children. All those thing were included. > Did Soviet engineers and scientists enjoy a fairly reasonable standard of living? Many did. But the comparison to the US and health care is ludicrous on its face. They had a significantly better health even if they became unemployed than someone in US would have if they became unemployed (which is none at all). > But the comparison to the US and health care is ludicrous on its face. Why is it ridiculous? I will take ex Soviet health care rather than no health care or healthcare that results in you having to sell your house and live on the streets. They had good doctors and stressed preventive care just as much as emergency care (which is the case in US nowadays for many who cannot afford health insurance). You can bash the political system all you want. I am with you with that. But I don't think you know what you are talking about when it comes to other stuff. If you don't mind me asking, have you lived there or are you just taking an wild guess? > Did Soviet engineers and scientists enjoy a fairly reasonable standard of living? Many did. I thought that is the whole point of this discussion thread...
- gcv 16y agoThat is true, but not because engineers are working in a Gulag. Wrong. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharashka http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sharashka
- rdtsc 16y agoWrong: Arguing from one example. Yes, they had sharashkas up until 1953. There is no excuse for that, but implying that all engineering was done there is just ridiculuous. It is like saying everyone was stupid and any work that was done was just because someone put a gun to their head. That kind of a message is disingenuous at best and smells like propaganda at worse. Nevermind the fact that Typhoon was commissioned 30 years later after sharashkas were closed. So it doesn't even apply to the article at hand. However, if you are implying some kind of American moral superiority then look at how Americans used Nazi rocket engineers. Also, they appropriated and used most of the research done by the Japanese at Unit 731 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731. There were no Nuremberg trials for those (except some trials in Russia) and some of those working there ended up as heads of big pharma in Japan after the war.
- gcv 16y agoWrong: Arguing from one example. You said engineers were not prisoners. This was not the case, and I provided a counterexample. That's all. I have no idea where you found anything in my post about American moral superiority. As for Soviet scientific progress, I also made no other points in my original post — but I will take the opportunity to do so now. Yes, they had sharashkas up until 1953. The Wikipedia article states that. Do you really believe that Khruschev, just because he chose to oust Stalin, gave up on such a convenient source of scientific labor? Keep in mind that history in the Soviet Union was always a complete fabrication dictated by the latest Party ideology. While I don't question that many forced labor camps closed, I seriously doubt that those closings were universal.
- rdtsc 16y ago> You said engineers were not prisoners. I would be willing to bet you that engineers working on the Typhoon class submarines were not prisoners. In general engineering was an esteemed and respected profession. Think lawyers and doctors in US. These are all general statement relating to the situation in Soviet Union based on a personal experience. Your comment made it sound like "no, that is _wrong_ most engineers were prisoners". That is just simply wrong. There we some engineers who were also prisoners. But most of them were not. Those engineers that worked on building submarines were doing very well. That was a very prestigious job. Again think about someone being a stock broker or a corporate lawyer in US. > The Wikipedia article states that. Do you really believe that Khruschev, just because he chose to oust Stalin, gave up on such a convenient source of scientific labor? Alright the history of the Soviet Union might have been obscured and covered in secrets but you forgot one important thing -- the Soviet Union fell apart. It lasted only 70 years and people from the 50s are still alive. So no matter how much the Soviets tried to rewrite the history, as long as there are still millions of eye witnesses it is just not possible. > I have no idea where you found anything in my post about American moral superiority. You are right, you didn't say it. I put those words in your mouth because I thought you implied it. The reason I thought that is that your perception of the situation in the ex-Soviet Union, especially as far as the naval engineering goes, is completely wrong. Being that you refuse to admit that it is wrong, leads me to believe that you are just drumming up the same boring Cold War propaganda that we've heard before from the Americans -- stuff like "in Soviet Union everyone was in a Gulag", ... , "any progress was made just because people were prisoners and forced to work",... and so on. I am not excusing or romanticizing the ex Soviet empire. I am glad it fell, I didn't like. I want to be able to write whatever crap I want online without the fear of someone knocking on my door and so on. BUT painting everything with a broad black brush is just wrong. Life in the Soviet Union was not hell, people were not crying on the streets, everyone had their basic needs taken care of, crime was law and so on. No matter how much we want to hate it, we cannot re-write that, because that as well would just as dishonest and wrong.