5 ms·
> Because, you know, no Scandinavian women ever kill themselves at double the rate of Americans. Is that true? All women or only mothers? This would be a stran
by scotty79 16y ago
> Because, you know, no Scandinavian women ever kill themselves at double the rate of Americans.
Is that true? All women or only mothers? This would be a strange bias. General suicide rates are not that much different?
- Tichy 16y agoOne aspect is that in Scandinavia winters are very long.
- scotty79 16y agoThat was my first thought but I checked suicide rates by country and they are not much different between Sweden, Canada and US. Now I noticed that there's list of suicide rates by country and gender here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_rates http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_rates There seems to be higher rate of suicides in females in northern countries but they are much less likely to commit suicide than males. Suicides in males seem to be correlated more with economic situation that latitude. Assumption made in article that suicide rates are correlated with how much child care is provided by the state seems unfounded.
- furyg3 16y ago> Assumption made in article that suicide rates are correlated with how much child care is provided by the state seems unfounded. I don't think that that was the assumption made in the article. The original NY article made some vague claims about scandinavian women being happier and that being somehow tied to childcare... which was not thought out or supported in any way. The author of the rebuttal article used the suicide rates to show that other conclusions could easily be made about the happiness of scandinavian women.
- scotty79 16y agoLack of support for this claim in that NY article is not proof for it's falseness. Author in his rebuttal also did not show that suicide rates of women correlate with their happiness nor that their average happiness of all woman in the country has anything to do with amount of child care provided free if charge. I think it's far worse because he claims that more people help you with your burdens the less happy you are which seems paradoxical and tries to found this claim with suicide rates which seem to have some apparent correlation with how much sunlight individuals get. I personally know young mother who gives her 3 year old daughter all her awake time and I find it hard to believe how she could not benefit from easing up getting child care for her. 24 hours in a day is for one person just barely enough to take care of the kid. You need other peoples help and I don't see how making it easier could lead to lower happiness let alone increasing suicide rates.
- Goosey 16y agoAnd Scandinavian metal is very very metal
- Tichy 16y agoCause and effect, though? :-)
- cabalamat 16y agoOf course it's true. No American woman has ever killed herself more than once, and no Scandinavian woman has ever killed herself twice. (The article should have read "Scandinavian women don't kill themselves at double the rate of Americans")
- arkx 16y agoIt's true: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_ra... General rate is almost twice as high as well, so it's not bias. Scandinavians are also generally much happier, according to OECD: http://www.forbes.com/2009/05/05/world-happiest-places-lifestyle-travel-world-happiest.html http://www.forbes.com/2009/05/05/world-happiest-places-lifes...
- delackner 16y agoWould one possible explanation for a country to have a very high suicide rate but also a high happiness index be survivorship bias? The winter depression might be so harsh that it pushes the unhappy off the edge, and the remaining population consists of those who are just so happy that it doesn't bother them. I suspect though that someone with more knowledge would find this argument a bit vapid.