3 ms·
The UK doesn't have fully nationalized healthcare. * GP surgeries (doctors offices) are private businesses, and may provide NHS services or private services.
by vidarh 9y ago
The UK doesn't have fully nationalized healthcare.
* GP surgeries (doctors offices) are private businesses, and may provide NHS services or private services.
* The NHS contracts out for a growing number of services, ranging from operating whole departments (e.g. Virgin operates the out-of-hours walk in centre for non-emergency care next door to the A&E/ER at my local hospital) to cleaning.
* The NHS rents out facilities to private providers, and individual NHS trusts may derive income from carrying out private work (though the proportion of this income is limited, and the revenue goes back into their budgets). This is in addition to NHS staff often renting NHS facilities to carry out private surgeries outside their normal rotation.
* Dentists are mostly private and generally dentists that do NHS work also do private work, and often mix and match with the same patient (e.g. the NHS does not reimburse more expensive types of fillings, so your dentist may recommend e.g. things like porcelain veneers on visible teeth and stick to NHS options for less visible work).
* Pharmacies are mostly private - the NHS mostly operates pharmacies only in hospitals etc. but they too can be privately operated.
* 10% of the population have private health insurance. This is mostly "top up" insurance offering additional services or faster turnaround for non-essential surgeries etc. than the NHS.
* Many types of healthcare services are mostly private. E.g. while you can get some types of cosmetic surgery on the NHS
As it stands, the NHS is the most cost-effective hybrid or private system in any developed country. Too cost-effective some would say; to the point where it comes at the cost of making things more miserable for patients. But that's what you get when we pay far less than any other countries at a comparable income level.
- ryanwaggoner 9y agoOK, you're sort of shining a spotlight on my ignorance here, but a few thoughts: 1. Maybe "fully nationalized" isn't technically true, but my understanding was that the UK was widely regarded to have a nationalized healthcare system. Not really interested in whether that's technically true at the margins unless there's some major policy impact. 2. "Cost-effective" is an interesting term, because it assumes we agree on what "effective" means. I want choice, innovation, better health outcomes, more convenience, shorter wait times, etc., and I'm willing to pay some premium (but not 4x or something) for them. For these reasons, I don't want want the NHS system here (nor do I think it'd work here), despite it being better for some values of "cost-effectiveness". 3. If by "cost-effectiveness", you just mean per-capita spending on healthcare, are you sure the NHS is the most cost-effective of any developed country? Doesn't seem to be the case here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_hea... -- maybe you're using some more complicated measure of spending per health outcomes?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vidarh 9y ago> 1. Maybe "fully nationalized" isn't technically true, but my understanding was that the UK was widely regarded to have a nationalized healthcare system. Not really interested in whether that's technically true at the margins unless there's some major policy impact. Which countries do you consider not to have a nationalized healthcare system, then we can make a comparison? Note that even in the US, the government covers roughly half of all healthcare expenditure. The UK government covers about 79%. > 2. "Cost-effective" is an interesting term, because it assumes we agree on what "effective" means. I want choice, innovation, better health outcomes, more convenience, shorter wait times, etc., and I'm willing to pay some premium (but not 4x or something) for them. For these reasons, I don't want want the NHS system here (nor do I think it'd work here), despite it being better for some values of "cost-effectiveness". Even if you for some reason believe you don't get this with the NHS (meanwhile most people here considers the US system to be terrifying), you have all of that by combining the NHS with private top-up insurance. The average cost of combining NHS and private insurance in the UK is far lower than the average cost of healthcare in the US. So you can get the benefits that socializing services have in ensuring universal coverage and ensuring nobody drives up overall costs by waiting until things get more expensive to treat, with the ability to pay for whatever extra services you want. Fewer people go without coverage, and you get cheaper coverage and more choice since you can still pick and choose from private providers but also get a public option if you prefer that. In fact, because of the ability of the NHS to rent out resources, even privately paying for operations etc. tends to be so much cheaper even at top end London specialists that if you're in the US and need elective care it is worth checking the cost of flying to London, having it done, and staying in a nice hotel while recovering. For a lot of conditions that'll be cheaper. Personally I find it telling that it is almost impossible to find people holding your positions in places where people have experienced these socialized systems unless they have the money to pay far more for care that is out of reach of most people. For 3., note that you're referring to PPP adjusted numbers. The UK costs have also increased more the last few years than I realized. Even so, while the PPP adjusted data does not have the UK stand out as much as it used to, the gap between the UK and e.g. the US still illustrates the most important point.