4 ms·
>> Early adopters took a big risk on a fledgling technology I can't agree with that. Early adopters really didn't take a lot of risk, they ran a mining program
by Nursie 9y ago
>> Early adopters took a big risk on a fledgling technology
I can't agree with that. Early adopters really didn't take a lot of risk, they ran a mining program for a while, or bought some BTC for a few cents to a few dollars.
- clarkmoody 9y agoIn some countries, Bitcoin has been outlawed. Owning stuff the government doesn't like is certainly a risk. They also endured 90% drops in value from early peaks to troughs. Bitcoin could have gone to zero at any point if the system had failed. (It still could) Some invested time learning about new technology that could've gone nowhere.
- Nursie 9y ago>> In some countries, Bitcoin has been outlawed. Very few. In more/most it's just taxable. >> They also endured 90% drops in value from early peaks to troughs. Bitcoin could have gone to zero at any point if the system had failed. (It still could) OK, sure, but again not a massive risk if your initial stake was tiny. And it was a stake rather than an investment - it's not really an investment as you're not investing in a productive endeavour. More like buying and holding an asset.
- qsucvatz 9y agoIn the end, either one does or does not own the property. They choose when to buy and when to sell. From your perspective, isn't it a massive risk not to sell at this all time high value? If they hold or sell, do they deserve whatever outcome?
- Nursie 9y ago> From your perspective, isn't it a massive risk not to sell at this all time high value? Not really, if you didn't tie up significant proportions of your net worth in the initial buy. > If they hold or sell, do they deserve whatever outcome? Deserve is a worryingly moral word to apply there. My only dispute is that early adopters took a lot of risk. It's not like they sunk their life savings into opening a small business.
- googletazer 9y agoThey could have been doing something else with their time. Instead they were mining, promoting, and trading this technology. By definition there is an opportunity cost to being an early adopter instead of going with the flow - so indeed they took a risk.
- pessimizer 9y agoThe question was whether it was a "big" risk. Every action, including the decision not to take a particular action, is a non-zero risk.
- UncleMeat 9y agoDoes that opportunity cost justify owning a meaningful percentage of all of the coins that will ever exist?
- googletazer 9y agoWhat does "justify" mean here? Are you somehow saying its not fair that early adopters have a lot of coins?
- scotty79 9y agoIf at some point bitcoin will suck significant portion of saving of whole world then they will own huge share of all of that which seems a bit unfair.
- ric2b 9y agoSo buy it from them. It's a completely voluntary system that requires no permission to participate, has been from the start. I assume 'fair' to you would mean taking it from them to re-distribute between everyone else?
- scotty79 9y ago> So buy it from them. You can't do that if they don't sell and they won't sell untill bitcoin stores large portion of world's wealth. > I assume 'fair' to you would mean taking it from them to re-distribute between everyone else? I have no idea why would you assume that. Especially if you could achieve same thing just by destroying their bitcoin. No need to re-distribute. Share is the thing that matters not the amount. On more serious note fair for me is more or less how actual brick and mortar econony distributes things. You make things other find useful, you get share of humanity's wealth in return. Holding things, bitcoin, gold, real estate, copyright strays for me from 'fair'. I see it as the less fair, the less you contibuted to humanity to acquire those things and the more claim on share of humanity's wealth you have by holding them.