3 ms·
I think you've inverted the intent of that point. You ask "Why on earth would anyone expect otherwise?" This expectation appears to be the core of Patreon's mar
by eesmith 9y ago
I think you've inverted the intent of that point. You ask "Why on earth would anyone expect otherwise?" This expectation appears to be the core of Patreon's marketing.
"Patreon had all these great selling points and stats. I could get “meaningful revenue” from my fans, and finally find the “creative freedom” I’d heard so much about. Patreon’s about page said creator’s incomes “doubled annually.” Their blog has story after story after story of their users making thousands a month. Of course I was grateful for everyone who contributed to mine, but none of the site’s promises were coming true." ... "It’s easy to feel like the failure of my Patreon is entirely on me. It’s an anxiety most artists feel acutely: Am I actually any good? This paranoia is bolstered by the presence of wildly successful creators on the site, and there is a nascent market for Patreon advice in the way that Kickstarter birthed an industry of professional crowdfunding consultants."
Regarding the rest of your comment, you mentioned the goal was "so that its members are more equal".
As an example of how that might work in Patreon, consider the recent change in fee payment, which ended up taking a bigger cut of small donations while reducing the cut on big donations. Since most people have only small donors, and only the elites have significant numbers of big donors, this disproportionately affects those making less money from Patreon.
While if they had reduced the cut from small donations and increased that from large donations, then the result would have lead to more equals (meaning, less dissimilar) incomes.
It would still mean that "the elite lives much better than the average subject. (This is not even a controversial point.)"
As you say, "we have an entire century of communism and socialism to draw conclusions from." That experience (which is not limited to just communism and socialism) includes a progressive tax rate, where those elites pay more because they are more able to pay.
Under the analogy you are using, Patreon is changing their tax system to be more regressive. Have you drawn the conclusion that more regressive taxes are better for a country?