4 ms·
TLDR: "Hell is other people." I wish I had more to add. I don't. No one in my family is quadriplegic, but we all three have special needs. Special is the new
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
TLDR: "Hell is other people."
I wish I had more to add. I don't. No one in my family is quadriplegic, but we all three have special needs.
Special is the new retard. As the author so eloquently describes, so many people see that and only that and erase everything else about you.
- adam-seeliger 9y agoPeople do, but you will never change people.
- emodendroket 9y agoEasy to say that, but mores can in fact change quite substantially even in one person's lifetime.
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoPeople used to think murder and theft were OK before religion came along. Society is a tool to change people. People most certainly can be changed... maybe difficult for individuals but across generations a lot can happen.
- adrianN 9y agoCitation needed. I'm pretty sure murder and theft are frowned upon even in groups of monkeys.
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoFind a citation yourself if it bothers you. Or you know, try to understand what im saying rather than nitpicking, pick another example like widespread racism and genocide which was once common and now isnt. Also read this https://medium.com/incerto/the-intellectual-yet-idiot-13211e2d0577 https://medium.com/incerto/the-intellectual-yet-idiot-13211e...
- adrianN 9y agoIf you claim something like "society is a tool to change people" you should provide some argument to convince people. Since this is just an Internet forum, it doesn't have to be a double blind study, but claiming that murder was okay before religion just seems wrong to me. I could equally claim that society is just a natural result of people living together and being forced to share resources and does exactly nothing to change human nature, in fact, it is just an expression of human nature.
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoI listed more examples above, such as how racism and discrimination were once widely accepted. I don't think I need to provide a citation for basic facts such as claims of racial/genetic superiority in the era of Hitler, or historical beliefs that white people were inherently superior to dark-skinned people for hundreds of years, of how ordinary people had no qualms in keeping "sub-human" blacks as slaves.. this is all extremely common knowledge to the point where citing it would be like citing "the earth is round-ish". I think if you take a charitable interpretation of what I'm saying as a basis for discussion and try to find things that SUPPORT the statements truth rather than counterexamples, you would see them and understand my argument. I really don't believe taking a purely adversarial stance and poking holes instead of attempting to first understand contributes the discussion usefully.
- tomhoward 9y agoChimps are sometimes observed to be violent and murderous, either for territorial[1] or hierarchical[2] reasons. I'm not of the belief that religion is necessarily what made murder taboo, but self-reflective consciousness and sophisticated ethical systems (especially development of an understanding of the mutual self-interest of the "golden rule"[3]) would seem to be key factors. [1] https://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/06/100621-science-chimpanzees-chimp-gangs-kill-mitani/ https://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/06/100621-scie... [2] https://www.newscientist.com/article/2119677-chimps-beat-up-murder-and-then-cannibalise-their-former-tyrant/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2119677-chimps-beat-up-... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Rule
- simion314 9y agoCan you tell exactly what you mean, it sounds like you are referring to a specific religion, the logic contradiction is that humans always had religions, mass murder still happened where the killed people were from other group. Also remember how the US slave owners would use religion to show black people do not have souls.
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoIt reminds me of privileged people who dont care about safety nets, rich people who dont care about high taxes, innocent people who couldnt care less about throwing weed dealers in jail for 10 years, healthy people who have no concern for healthcare costs... People lack the imagination to really put themselves in others shoes. They are shitty and cruel when they cant empathize. And they have little incentive to try.
- urahara 9y agoExactly. This is a problem of lack of imagination and empathy. How do you think it can be fixed in mass? I think we need mechanisms that make people understand experiences of disadvantaged groups. Like maybe some VR app showing their reality + some laws that those who deny other groups problems must use it.
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoI dont think there are any easy solutions, certainly not as easy as a VR app. People harp on about empathy/tolerance/diversity but dehumanize "the other" consistently, and at a very early age. Tribalism is part of human nature, and caring more about those with similar genes is a primal evolutionary drive.
- urahara 9y agoIt definitely won't be easy, but we have to start somewhere. Currently I don't have any better ideas than something like an app to share experience. Any other ideas to start battling dehumanizing?
- hammock 9y ago>Like maybe some VR app showing their reality + some laws that those who deny other groups problems must use it. Texas has this for abortions. The law requires that a woman get a sonogram from the doctor who will be performing the procedure at least 24 hours beforehand, during which the doctor must display sonogram images and make the heartbeat audible to the mother. It's controversial.
- ianai 9y agoMy mom has psoriasis. It’s no disability and I’m not making any indication toward that here. I grew up with strangers treating my mom like a lepper. We would be asked if she was contagious. Simple interactions like paying for goods at the grocery store became awful confrontations. There’s exactly one correct way to treat everyone in the world and prejudicially is not it.
- spoovy 9y agoI have psoriasis too and was interested to find out that many years ago people thought psoriasis literlly was leprosy, and people like me were forced to ring a bell constantly to warn others of our presence. That or be forced to live in a leper colony and presumably then catch and die of leprosy. Thank the lord for education.
- taneq 9y ago> Special is the new retard. And so shall it ever be. While you hold disdain for the thing itself, no word that you use for it will ever be acceptable for long. See 'euphemism treadmill' at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euphemism#Evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euphemism#Evolution
- gebeeson 9y ago'Special is the new retard.' Still to this very day, I refer to myself as a retard. It is truly what I grew up with and for me, over time, it has become a badge of honor of sorts. As a humorous aside, I also tell people that 'I used to be a card carrying retard.' After the looks of shock and dismay wear off, someone asks - 'No card anymore? Did you get 'better'?' - my reply is always - 'Nope, I ate it with some paste in kindergarten. It was delicious.' Never gets old for me.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoSo, educate me here. Was that just for kids deemed to have low IQs or for any kind of learning disability or special needs? I never heard of there being a card. I am taking you literally here, but maybe that is the wrong thing to do.