4 ms·
I'm really curious to hear if it's 100% ok to have a company in, say, the UK, and for all intents and purposes operate in Italy. I have heard differing opinion
by davidw 16y ago
I'm really curious to hear if it's 100% ok to have a company in, say, the UK, and for all intents and purposes operate in Italy. I have heard differing opinions on this from various 'commercialisti' (accountants).
- paolomaffei 16y agoMy mother is a commercialista (I think it's safe to translate it as "accountant") so I might ask her better when I'll see her. What I know at the moment is that: - if you pay your taxes fully in Italy (if that's even possible of course) it's ok - if you pay your corporate taxes in UK then in Italy you only pay taxes on your dividends that's called "esterovestizione" and is illegal
- fierarul 16y ago>if you pay your corporate taxes in UK then in Italy you only pay taxes on your dividends that's called "esterovestizione" and is illegal I'm pretty sure double-taxation treaties exist within UK and Italy given they are in the EU. Also, not sure how Italy could claim taxes on the profit of an UK entity. Dividends are another matter entirely and depend on the residence of the person so dividend taxes will probably be paid in Italy directly.
- paolomaffei 16y agoAlso, not sure how Italy could claim taxes on the profit of an UK entity. - I'm pretty sure it does, it is written very clearly in a law (the infamous "esterovestizione" one).
- roel_v 16y agoYes, this is 100% as confirmed by the (relatively) groundbreaking case law by the European Court of Justice in the series of judgments of Daily Mail, Centros, Überseering and Inspire Art (various aspects of this matter were covered in the various cases: moving a companies head seat between Member States in Daily Mail, the real seat theory as a restriction on the freedom of establishment in Centros, Uberseerung about the recognition of foreign companies in other Member States.) Source: last semester's Introduction to EC Company Law course in the law school I'm attending. I didn't get stellar grades but enough to remember this much ;)
- drtse4 16y agohttp://businessupdated.com/shownews.asp?news_id=2031&cat=Freedom+of+establishment+for+companies http://businessupdated.com/shownews.asp?news_id=2031&cat...
- drtse4 16y agoI see mainly 2 possible problems: 1- "Esterovestizione" prevention law, if you are citizen+resident in italy, you are expected to pay taxes related to your company here, but which of the multitude of taxes do i really need to pay? If you are going to open a company this must be crystal clear, different opinions are not acceptable. 2- High entity management costs. I guess our accountants will demand something more to manage the additional layer of complexity... So, i'm not quite sure of the implications this will lead to, but look like it will be pretty painful in a way or another. (For the few italian HNers, see david petition on this: http://www.srlfacile.org/ http://www.srlfacile.org/)
- iuguy 16y agoYes it is, and there's nothing (in the UK) that would stop you from never touching the UK, so you could set up your Italian bank accounts and run everything from Italy. I'd look to use a Commercialista that understands UK finances though rather than a UK accountant that understands Italian banking. That's where you'll see the problems arise.