5 ms·
It's surprisingly easy to meet a budget in a totalitarian state where even if not necessarily your life but your well-being, the education of your children and
by pvg 16y ago
It's surprisingly easy to meet a budget in a totalitarian state where even if not necessarily your life but your well-being, the education of your children and basic needs are dependent on it.
I'm a Russian and I imagine I'm reasonably cognizant of actual Soviet achievements. The notion that these were reached by plucky engineering and can-do spirit rather than, largely, oppression and coercion is absurd.
- jacquesm 16y ago> It's surprisingly easy to meet a budget in a totalitarian state where even if not necessarily your life but your well-being, the education of your children and basic needs are dependent on it. Yes, that's true. > I'm a Russian and I imagine I'm reasonably cognizant of actual Soviet achievements. ok > The notion that these were achieved largely by plucky engineering and can-do spirit rather than, largely, oppression and coercion is absurd. Whether oppression and coercion were part of it is not something I can or would like to comment on, I assume it was because of what I know about a bit of that from people working for defense projects in the 'sovblock' before the fall of the wall. But that does not detract from the quality of the engineering. I think that the budgetary constraints forced the Russian engineers to look for the simpler, and often more reliable solutions whereas their Western counterparts often took a more development oriented approach.
- lionhearted 16y ago> Whether oppression and coercion were part of it is not something I can or would like to comment on ... But that does not detract from the quality of the engineering. Jacques, you're one of my favorite posters here, but I really disagree with this sentiment. In the top post you wrote: "they designed that thing on a budget that was probably a very small fraction of what the design of its American counterpart cost and it was just as deadly" -- That's a terrible sentiment. The reason American things cost more is they can't just grab a scientist or engineer and say, "Build this for us, or else..." Yes, we can admire some Soviet weaponry and machinery (the Kalashnikov rifle is amazing for what it's good at, in particular) - but we should also mention the very real costs and atrocities they committed to get these projects done. Saying that they did it on a smaller budget than the Americans is false - their budget was less cash and more violence. Some amazing weaponry came out of totalitarian states - Nazis with rocketry, Soviets with durable machinery - but we should remember the very real costs of human misery, literally human blood, sweat, and tears that were forced into the production of those weapons.
- jacquesm 16y agoDon't get me wrong, I'm about as anti-war and anti-violence as it gets. But we're talking about a piece of pretty heavy artillery here, a nuclear submarine meant to kill people, wholesale. Now, I didn't set the stage for that, someone else did. As far as the methods and the means of the former SovBlock countries goes, I lived in Poland before the fall of the wall for a while and it taught me a lot. For one it taught me how the people in a country like that are to some extent complicit by refusing to stand up for their fellow man when it matters. The Nazis, the Soviets they were pretty bad in their days. But don't overlook the small detail that we today are pretty bad in many other ways, and we are also complicit. We should remember, I'm very much in favor of that. So lets work to create a world in which weapons such as this will be reminders of the period that will hopefully be called 'the crazy years' when looked back at from some arbitrary point in the future. But don't confuse the engineer with the puppet master. Those guys did their jobs to the best of their ability, what pressures were used to make them do their jobs are not part of that story. In fact, I can feel some sympathy for an engineer producing a work like that under duress, but I can find very little sympathy for someone doing that just for money.
- berntb 16y ago>>Don't get me wrong, I'm about as anti-war and anti-violence as it gets. Yes... military -- boring, military tech -- double plus cool. :-) >>I lived in Poland before the fall of the wall for a while and it taught me a lot. For one it taught me how the people in a country like that are to some extent complicit by refusing to stand up for their fellow man when it matters. I didn't live there, but those in the Eastern block knew what would happen if they stood up (e.g. Hungary, Czechoslovakia). When it became clear there wouldn't be Soviet divisions rolling over the border if they stood up, then they threw out their Soviet puppet regimes in months. Edit: OK, sorry for missing the point.
- jacquesm 16y agoThat's standing up on a slightly larger scale than I meant, I specifically meant when the local 'zomos' or whatever they were called in the country of choice were using informants to rat on their fellow men instead of forming a solid block. There always seem to be people willing to collaborate in return for favors. Revolution is a different matter.
- pvg 16y agoBut that does not detract from the quality of the engineering. I think the quality of the engineering is tremendously overblown. It's expressed in urban fables like the one about NASA spending millions on space pens while the Russians used pencils. Straight paste from Wikipedia - In commission: December 12, 1981 Completed: 6 Active: 1 Scrapped: 3 Preserved: 2 There's an order of magnitude more Soviet diesel/electric subs sailing the world's oceans.
- jacquesm 16y ago> It's expressed in urban fables like the one about NASA spending millions on space pens while the Russians used pencils Yes, that's one that's been doing the rounds from before the web. But it looks like the ISS will pretty soon be relying on Soyuz for its provisioning until Elon Musk will be in a position to provide an alternative for the shuttle flights. And that's not a mere pen or pencil we're talking about, and it's not a fable. That's 60's technology still in use today.
- pvg 16y agoAnd that's not a mere pen or pencil we're talking about, and it's not a fable. Well, we were talking about the Typhoons. A piece of megalomaniac, cripplingly expensive technology that mostly rusts in scrapyards. Also not a fable.
- jacquesm 16y agoThat's true. The cripplingly expensive is very apt, in that sense they did more for the Russian people than they did against their intended targets, it is believed that this sort of prestige project hastened the downfall of the USSR considerably and set the conditions for a more democratic form of government. So in a way maybe it was good that those megalomaniacs did their typhoon project, I'm not sure how much longer they would have been able to hold out otherwise but less seems to be better. With the specter of the USSR gone as archenemy #1 it seems we have now been duped in to being afraid of terrorists and the spending in the west meanwhile continues unabated. I wonder if we (as in here in Western Europe, though I'm currently writing this from Romania) will ever have a 'typhoon' project.
- gahahaha 16y ago"""I think that the budgetary constraints forced the Russian engineers to look for the simpler, and often more reliable solutions whereas their Western counterparts often took a more development oriented approach.""" I am reminded of the interview with Edsger W. Dijkstra on HN recently. http://cacm.acm.org/magazines/2010/8/96632-an-interview-with-edsger-w-dijkstra/fulltext http://cacm.acm.org/magazines/2010/8/96632-an-interview-with... : """The OS/360 monitor idea would have never occurred to a European? No, we were too poor to consider it and we also decided that we should try to structure our designs in such a way that we could keep things under our intellectual control. This was a major difference between European and American attitudes about programming."""
- krschultz 16y ago>I think that the budgetary constraints forced the Russian engineers to look for the simpler, and often more reliable solutions whereas their Western counterparts often took a more development oriented approach. You are pulling that opinion out of thin air with 0 basis in fact. If you ask me, a bunch of pressure hulls put together in one outer hull is a lot more complicated than a single pressure hulls. That can only be cheaper/simplier becasue the cost of labor is so much lower. Welding the pressure hull is extremely expensive. If you look at reliability, all 18 of the US Ohio class which were design/built starting in the 70s (while the Typhoon came out in the 80s) are still in operation and are slated to be replace in about 2020. None have had a catastrophic accident. They've had something like 130 succesful Trident practice launches in a row. There are a lot of signs that the US ones are the most reliable in the world.
- protomyth 16y agoThey have some truly bad failures where simple and cheap were not more reliable. Take a look at that torpedo test that went bad.
- jacquesm 16y agoTake a look at the challenger... Accidents of enormous magnitude have happened because of cheapness, the Russians did not have a monopoly on that.
- rdtsc 16y agoI am not Russian but I lived in the Soviet Union, and I think your impression is a different than mine. From what I remember, being an engineer on such a project was a very prestigious job. It came with many perks that others didn't have. > It's surprisingly easy to meet a budget in a totalitarian state... That is true, but not because engineers are working in a Gulag. It is because of how a central-planning economy works. Now of course you can argue that the whole country was one big Gulag and there is truth to that, but engineers working on these submarines probably were much, much better off than peasants in some corner of Siberia...
- jacquesm 16y agoI think with coercion pvg refers to the use of 'perks' (such as education for your kids and the privilege of being able to buy in the hard currency stores) rather than that family members were going to be shot if some device or gadget wasn't produced in time or at all. As for the oppression bit, the satellite states of the USSR were fairly ruthlessly kept in check, lots of very bad things happened there, more than we will probably ever know about and there are definitely examples of scientists that were forced to work on projects that they did not want to work on, such as Theremin. http://www.mediascot.org/atmosphere001 http://www.mediascot.org/atmosphere001
- rdtsc 16y ago> I think with coercion pvg refers to the use of 'perks' (such as education for your kids and the privilege of being able to buy in the hard currency stores) I think that relatively to other professions, engineering was actually prestigious. I was on awe of my uncle and father who were engineers and wanted to be like them. American kids today want to either play professional sports, be lawyers, CEO, or doctors. In ex USSR engineering was a relatively good profession to have without having to necessarily be involved too much into the party politics. The perks were no more coercieve than having health insurance tied to the job + mortgage payments in America. > As for the oppression bit, the satellite states of the USSR were fairly ruthlessly kept in check, lots of very bad things happened there, more than we will probably ever know about and there are definitely examples of scientists that were forced to work on projects that they did not want to work on, such as Theremin. That is true and that is a serious problem. We are yet to have the equivalent of Nuremberg trials for ex Soviet Union apartchiks and those who co-operated with them. I am not excusing them on a absolute moral ground. On a relative moral ground, I would like Americans to stop thinking their empire is less coersive and repressive. It treated many countries around the world very brutally, it installed ruthless fascist dictators all through South America and Asia. They are still fighting wars in the Middle East and "brave" drone pilots in Langley, VA are risking their lives daily driving to work so they can play video-games and with a push of a joystick putton assasinate individual we'll never know or hear about in a country we are not even at war with... So yes, I am for critisizing imperialism and oppression, but I am for doing so for all the imperialism and oppression not just the ones that the popular propaganda machine wants to critisize.
- cabalamat 16y ago> The notion that these were reached by plucky engineering and can-do spirit rather than, largely, oppression and coercion is absurd. All the oppression and coercion in the world will not produce good engineering without competent engineers. The USSR, for all its faults, did produce some impressive weapons -- such as the T-34, Il-2 or AK-47.