5 ms·
You missed it. The profit comes from the fact that the money paid in step 3 is less than what would have been paid in import duties had he collected the shoes
by btilly 16y ago
You missed it.
The profit comes from the fact that the money paid in step 3 is less than what would have been paid in import duties had he collected the shoes in step 2. And then, having successfully imported shoes at below the cost that other entrepreneurs were capable of getting, he was able to resell those shoes at below market rates and still have a higher profit margin.
If he paid more for special handling, that would have been covered. If the shipments were big enough, then postage is based on some combination of weight and volume. This is unchanged.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoWe're still back to "fraud", then, which is not a particularly creative (or viable) strategy in my book.
- confuzatron 16y agoOK, where's the "fraud", or are you just harrumphing at having missed the point of the article?
- Retric 16y agoFailing to pay the correct import taxes. Consider someone who reports importing used furniture vs antiques.
- confuzatron 16y agoI'd call it 'gaming the system' rather than 'fraud', but am not a lawyer. @maushu, the real solution here is to get rid of the dumb trade barriers in the first place. The 'problem' of dodging round them pales into insignificance in comparison, if indeed it is a problem at all. Presumably a lot of Indian politicians thought the way you did, until policies changed, and India started growing.
- davidw 16y agoI agree with getting rid of the trade barriers, but dodging them is not a solution and leads to a society where avoiding "inconvenient" laws is seen as the norm. This is very much a slippery slope - and is one of the things I feel is problematic with modern Italy. Berlusconi has been on trial for attempting to corrupt judges, but many people seem not to care - who hasn't tried to skirt around the law, anyway?
- Gormo 16y agoThe businessman in the example did not avoid the laws. Far from it - he found a way to comply with them at the lowest possible cost. Deliberately subverting the law should not be commended. But in this example, he was able to work around the deleterious effect of a bad law while fully adhering to its provisions. I can't see a problem with this.
- Retric 16y agoThe way the law is enforced is not the same thing as what it says. Let's say he shipped one shoe out of a pair to the country and it's worth 10c. Then he ships the second shoe in the set and it's now worth 10$ because the first one is already in the country.
- Gormo 16y agoDo customs duties ever apply to the resale price of merchandise after it has been imported and made available on the local market? Do they apply to the market value of finished goods when importing their unfinished components? The way the law is enforced is very much a function of what it says. I'm fairly confident in assuming that the customs authority didn't arbitrarily make up the "auction goods with duties unpaid for 30 days" rule, and that it was fully rooted in applicable law.
- Retric 16y agoFirst off, I don't know Indian law, but normally import tax is based on wholesale value. AKA One ton of steel is worth X, pay Y% of X. Now, there are plenty of loopholes in the law but, just as you can get a speeding ticket while traveling below the posted speed limit in a blizzard the basic rules are usually still enforceable. The law may go to great detail about what how and why to post a given speed limit, but they are only guidelines. EX: A friend was given a speeding ticket by a cop who did not know how fast he was going AND did not know what the speeding limit was on that road. However, the Judge decided that the cop as an expert witness and he had to pay the fine. PS: You often see the same sorts of things in IRS audits, because you don’t get to just follow 95% of the rules.
- maushu 16y ago'Gaming the system' or 'fraud', doesn't matter what you call it. This is what causes the vicious cycle, you avoid paying the taxes, the taxes increase to compensate, repeat.
- Gormo 16y agoIf they want the tax revenue to be more consistent, perhaps they should write the tax laws more carefully. And high import tariffs are much more likely to be protectionist than to be legitimate revenue sources - raising the tax rates wouldn't be a sensible response for a protection tariff.