3 ms·
It may be "pretty well established" but I don't believe it. I read your link, and you are basing memory based on an experiment that is unlikely to have strong
by btilly 16y ago
It may be "pretty well established" but I don't believe it.
I read your link, and you are basing memory based on an experiment that is unlikely to have strong emotional impact for the kid. Without strong emotional impact, I wouldn't expect memory to last. That says nothing about what can happen with memories of more impactful events.
Here is an anecdote that happened with my son. Before he was 7 months he spent several hours a week in a mommy and me run by one Tandy Parks. Then we moved and he never saw her again. When he was 1 1/2 we had the opportunity to drop in on that mommy and me class. Despite normally being shy, he quickly found his way to her lap, which is most emphatically not a behavior he shows with strangers.
Going back to your link, the researcher says, "Most single experiences before age 8 months, unless they are very emotional or painful, are probably lost." That qualification makes perfect sense to me, and is very relevant to the example at hand. My son had very emotional interactions with Tandy, and so he still had associations with her. I'm sure he wouldn't have remembered a toy from the same period. And particularly not a toy he had limited interactions with.
Furthermore the researcher has another good reason to put that qualification in there. A number of research studies that demonstrated that strong pain can alter responses to pain months to years later, even in very small infants. This is clear evidence of memory. In particular these studies have focused on comparing the responses of circumcised and uncircumcised males to shots. Many groups of researchers have demonstrated that circumcised males have more trouble with pain at 6 months. Some research suggests it may still apparent as late as 2.5 years.
If you're talking about conscious and structured memories, they appear to start much later than 1. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Childhood_amnesia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Childhood_amnesia for more on that topic. Bringing it back to my son, at 5 he shows no conscious memories of things that happened when he was 2 (though he still has positive associations with things we did together), but he has some memories from when he was 3, and a lot of very specific memories from age 4.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoI read your link, and you are basing memory based on an experiment [...] No, I'm not. I'm basing memory on a large, varied body of research, of which the link was just one example. My point is that the research, as a whole, is not supportive of the idea of infants remembering their birth or in utero experiences.
- btilly 16y agoDetailed, constructed memories? Clearly not. However given the research on circumcision, I'd be curious to see whether babies who were born through natural childbirth have a different reaction to shots at 6 months than ones born in a planned Caesarean.