2 ms·
I have to laugh at this. I know this is in reference to their manufacturing process, but I have worked with Toyota's IT department and they don't follow anythin
by tootie 9y ago
I have to laugh at this. I know this is in reference to their manufacturing process, but I have worked with Toyota's IT department and they don't follow anything like this. They are a typical stodgy, waterfall, design by committee, ivory tower architect kind of IT department. We pushed agile on them, but they still insisted on signing off on 100-page BRDs before work started. Maybe I just had a bad experience, but I recall constantly wondering why we had to work so hard to sell agile on the organization that practically invented it.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe Toyota Way is, as I understand it, much more closely related to Plan-Do-Check-Act, empirical, metrics-based approaches in Lean Manufacturing, Six Sigma, and other optimize-a-figure-of-merit methods (a lot of which are anchored in approaches championed by W. Edwards Deming and other contemporary advocates of empirical/statistical process control.) Agile philosophy is loosely similar in that it has a “do what works without dogma” core, but has much weaker focus on actual concrete measurements and empirical validation, which is one reason why despite its fundamental (in the Manifesto) opposition to canned, one-size-fits-all process that isn't adapted to the particular context, it devolves into a lot of that—without a cultural value of empirical measurement of outcomes, social proof and “this is the way to do it because this is what other people who succeeded were using”, or “this is the way to do it because it comes from <authority figure> who makes <abstract argument> and/or gave <subjectively appealing presentation>” become the bases available to make decisions on how to implement the vague ideals of the Manifesto. And also why it can be particularly hard to sell to an organization that does believe in changing process based on a specific, testable hypothesis about improvement in a key measure.