5 ms·
I've seen economists mulling over your second point a little lately - it's not a new concept though, it's called "basic income": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ba
by petercooper 16y ago
I've seen economists mulling over your second point a little lately - it's not a new concept though, it's called "basic income": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income
A fictional basic income exists in Star Trek TNG in relation to Federation credits. This is achievable because the Star Trek TNG universe is post-scarcity but credits are used to ration non-replicable goods.
- jsz0 16y agoPresident Nixon mulled over the idea of a guaranteed minimum income for Americans which, IIRC, mutated into the earned income tax credit program. Of course these days no mainstream progressive or liberal would support the idea. Things have changed a lot.
- _delirium 16y agoIt used to actually be a quite popular position among libertarian-ish economists, strangely enough: Friedrich von Hayek and Milton Friedman were both in favor of a guaranteed minimum income.
- dublinclontarf 16y agoReally, sounds awfully like something they would be dead set against. Certainly if it was guaranteed by the government. Got any sources for that?
- _delirium 16y agoThe three main reasons they gave were: 1) a functioning free market with rational agents voluntarily exchanging goods and services requires non-desperate individuals who can realistically say "no" to proposed economic exchanges; 2) a guaranteed minimum income would make people more autonomous market participants, as they would feel more free to be entrepreneurs, and to break from more cliquish kinds of safety nets like churches and ethnic groups; and 3) pragmatically, direct cash transfers are the least distorting kind of anti-poverty program, so a minimum income will greatly reduce political pressure for more distorting measures, like restrictions on when you can fire employees. Here's one place Hayek discusses it, starting at the bottom of p. 54 and continuing through the middle of p. 56: http://books.google.com/books?id=0HzIUyFkwlYC&pg=PA54 http://books.google.com/books?id=0HzIUyFkwlYC&pg=PA54
- tomjen3 16y agoIn Milton Friedmans capitalism and freedom, he discuss (among other things) that proposal - he admits not liking it too much, but it is better than the current system of welfare and it is more realistic to create that than to kill the welfare system. In addition you save the expenditure associated with paying for the enforcement, social workers, etc.
- orangecat 16y agoAlso see "the Plan", recently proposed by Charles Murray. The welfare state is entirely done away with; in its place every adult gets $10k/year for life. http://www.radicalmiddle.com/x_murray.htm http://www.radicalmiddle.com/x_murray.htm
- scotty79 16y agoIt might be extremely healthy for economy. Market works because consumers make thoughtful decisions. Poor people have to put much thought in their purchases. Increasing money available to poor people without making them feel rich increases market ability to prefer more efficient producers and service providers. Of course curbing commercials a bit to allow people to make less brainwashed decisions also would be good for market. You also need safeguards in place so companies in search of greater efficiency won't release harmful products.
- marvin 16y agoThis is a pretty interesting idea. I actually saw it discussed in the Norwegian popular financial magazine Your Money (Dine Penger) last year. In this instance, the relevant point was that Norway already has a sort of de facto basic income system. It's called "uførepensjon" (a rough translation would be "pension for those unfit to work"). It consists of approximately 23,000 pre-tax US dollars per year, and it's where you end up if you are sick, disabled or otherwise unable to acquire a decent job over a period of a few years; basically if you have received unemployment benefits for years and all attempts by the bureucratic system to get you back into the workforce have failed. Approximately 7% of all Norwegians currently receive these payments. The author of the article in question suggested a system of gradual negative taxation for very low wages, so if you earn less than 23000 USD per year at your current job, the missing part will be paid to you by the government. The line of reasoning is that most people will not be happy without more money than this, and hence will work normally. I'm not sure if even Norway is rich enough to support a system like this on a full scale, and taxation in the US is _definitely_ not harsh enough to do it, even with the amount adjusted to GDP per capita. But it would be nice if we someday ended up rich enough that extreme poverty could be eliminated in this way. None of the people covered by this system have to starve, and all health payments are also handled through the official system.
- bugsy 16y ago"taxation in the US is _definitely_ not harsh enough" It seems to me that the US spends 46.5% of all money spend world wide collectively by all nations on military spending. China, France, UK, Russia, and then next 10 biggest spending countries spend less than the US when they are all added together. In addition the US imprisons more of its population than any other country in the world, including totalitarian police states, and a much greater proportion than any modern western nation. In addition, the US spends a fortune on education and gets very poor outcomes. In addition, the US spends far more per capita on health care than any other country in the world and has far worse outcomes than most countries, with infant mortality now falling behind many third world nations, and the interesting reality that the life expectancy of an indigenous Lakota indian man living in South Dakota receiving free unlimited federal health care is now 44 years. This is lower than 187 out of 195 of the nations in the world and is only higher than nations which are afflicted with BOTH massive civil war AND endemic AIDS, Malaria and Cholera. Surely there is a way to pay for a basic living standard for the unskilled without raising taxes.
- gaius 16y agoHmm the thing is, the Star Trek universe isn't post-scarcity in any meaningful way. Sure, if you are living on a starship you can replicate anything and spend all your free time on the holiday deck. But the Federation (and all the competing civilizations) have very finite capacity to build and crew starships.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThey can't build holodecks and replicators on the ground?
- gaius 16y agoJames T Kirk grew up on a farm in Iowa - what was he farming?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoKirk grew up in an era with neither holodecks nor replicators, on starships or anywhere else.
- petercooper 16y agoPeople might do it for fun as they do now. No-one needs to farm anymore because you can just buy your food at the grocery store cheaper than it could be grown.
- Ras_ 16y agoBasic income aka perustulo is popular topic in current Finnish politics. I believe the Green League (which is unusually large party here - nearly 10% share) adopted it first. Recent polls indicate that the idea of Basic income could be favored by 30% of Finns. More about the lengthy Finnish debate on Basic income: http://translate.google.com/translate?js=y&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&layout=1&eotf=1&u=http%3A%2F%2Ffi.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2FPerustulo&sl=fi&tl=en http://translate.google.com/translate?js=y&prev=_t&h... marvin commented about Norway's "uførepensjon". Finland has it too. If you aren't able to get work for years and are deemed unemployable, you can get "unemployment pension" much in the same way as sick pension. But basic income is another thing. Everyone - including the employed - would get a lump sum of basic income. On top of that they could earn extra by working (taxable income) or just live off with the basic income. It is seen as a way to drastically simplify the welfare system, where some money is simply lost to bureaucracy. The caveat is the possibility that too many could choose not to earn extra money by working.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWe could probably accomplish it as well, though I'd favor providing goods and services rather than money. It would not cost a lot to provide millions of people with nutritious food, beds in a dormitory built in cheap locations and 1970-era health care. We do live in a world where scarcity no longer applies to many goods. We just don't realize it because we compare ourselves to our neighbors rather than our ancestors.