3 ms·
Just want to repeat what lisper said, and even more emphatically as this is personal to me, you cannot tell a native US citizen from their name. I myself have a
by asveikau 9y ago
Just want to repeat what lisper said, and even more emphatically as this is personal to me, you cannot tell a native US citizen from their name. I myself have an 11 character surname from the Baltic States. I was born in Washington DC.
What exactly is a native born American name to you? English origin? German? I honestly think you should be ashamed of what you wrote. It's deeply offensive to those of us with roots in other places.
- cortesoft 9y agoI have no idea if this is the case, but it could also be possible that the person you are replying to actually knows of the people listed. He might not be basing his observation on the names themselves.
- asveikau 9y agoI have encountered too many similar comments to believe that is the case.
- summer_steven 9y ago> I myself have an 11 character surname from the Baltic States. What exactly is a Baltic surname to you? Russian origin? German? I honestly think you should be ashamed of what you wrote. It's deeply offensive to those of us with roots in other places.
- asveikau 9y agoIt's neither Russian nor German. Baltic is a linguistic category on its own. Specifically Lithuanian in my case. Latvian is related. There were also Baltic language speakers in Prussia before it became majority German speaking. "Surname from the Baltic States" implies linguistic precision and specificity that "surname from the United States" does not convey and is in no means equivalent to. There is some vagueness in what I said but I left it there intentionally, people don't get crazy specific about personal details here usually. I was meaning to say I have a "foreign" surname.
- summer_steven 9y agoYour wrong about their being no traditional American. A traditional United States surname is generally English, Scottish, or Welsh as those were the primary people living in the United States from 1550-1850. For instance, I remember from History class that there were atleast 3 famous guys from the 1700s named "John Smith"
- asveikau 9y agoYou're wrong about the history of the United States. Dutch New Yorkers. Germans in Pennsylvania. (German is the predominant ethnicity of white Americans by the way.) French in Maryland. Lots of land purchased from French and robbed from Spaniards. And I didn't even mention the native peoples... All of these groups exist in significant numbers before the 1800s. Since you're interested in around 1850, around there starts immigration from places like Ireland, Italy, Poland.. even a few Baltic people.
- abrowne 9y ago> robbed from Spaniards They were Mexican by that point, right?
- asveikau 9y agoDepends where you are talking about. In the southwest or the west coast yes. I was thinking of Florida though, which was earlier. Though as I look that up maybe "robbed" is not the right word. Then of course much later there was the war with Spain which resulted in caribbean US territories... This is becoming a big tangent though.
- summer_steven 9y agoHere's a list of the top 100 American surnames. The majority of them are British/Scottish/Welsh: https://www.ssa.gov/oact/babynames/decades/century.html https://www.ssa.gov/oact/babynames/decades/century.html No matter what you think, the British Isles are the ones who populated the country.
- postit 9y agoPlease see my reply to lisper