4 ms·
I’m a security engineer at a large financial organization and we audit all 3rd party products most of these audits include a code review. This is a compliance
by dogma1138 9y ago
I’m a security engineer at a large financial organization and we audit all 3rd party products most of these audits include a code review.
This is a compliance process and it’s controlled by the SEC.
All of your suggestions would make the company that I at least work for to simply walk away from table.
This has happened more than once and all of our contracts contain a clause that if the application does not get a pass from our application security team the procurement would not continue.
- patio11 9y agoThank you for your comment. Can you add, for the benefit of the peanut gallery, what the typical cost of a one year software license you pay for is? I have a good guess but I think HNers need to hear people-other-than-me say it to internalize it.
- sodosopa 9y agoNot OP, but we were in the same situation and required source review. We negotiated escrow, the whole shebang. License costs for our enterprise was multi-year and ran over $15 million for the project for this one app. It's not an odd or rare request.
- dogma1138 9y agoReally depends usually in the millions especially if this is a product related to trading. It’s also important to note that as far as I am aware contracts on this scale have multiple stages and we are paying for PoC/pilot programmes during which we usually perform our review. This usually isn’t software that a pre-sale engineer would come and setup in a few days so we are paying effectively even for a demo. Overall we audit everything from Xerox software to custom balance sheet management products. The process is dependent on the level of trust/confidence we have in the vendor and the risk profile of the product. But in all cases there will be some sort of review. For vendors that would not give us code access we request permission to pentest the product the pentest would include reverse engineering in most cases and as the vast majority of products in the financial sector are in Java the source code isn’t hard to get through reversing the byte code.
- pcl 9y agoDo you use SaaS products at all? If so, do you audit source for them too, or just products that run on your hardware / network?
- dogma1138 9y agoSaaS is usually just a pentest some we get/request code access for. Overall it depends on the risk profile of the product SaaS products tend to have a lower risk profile becuase they don’t deal with trades/contracts directly. It’s all about managing risks. One of the products we use is Salesforce. Penetesting Salesforce would be a waste of time for us because Salesforce has a good application security team and is a trusted vendor. However we did perform a review of apps/plug-ins that run on the Salesforce platform which we use but have much less confidence in.
- mbesto 9y agoAnecdotal - for a large publicly traded financial services who wants to manage their book of record software (i.e. the software that holds the truth of "dear client you hold this many assets"), you're looking at $3-5M/year in license costs. Depending on the business context of a ML solution for a company like the OP describes, you're likely looking at $500k+, but this is pure speculation and requires more information about the customer situation (e.g. is the ML solution going to save the company money or help them sell more).
- lsaferite 9y ago> controlled by the FCC I'm guessing this is a typo?
- raverbashing 9y agoWhy would a financial product have a compliance procedure by the FCC? > All of your suggestions would make the company that I at least work for to simply walk away from table. Unless the company is already a customer and is paying for the development of the software, please do walk away from the table, I'm sure they have better things to do and better customers to sell to
- CyberFonic 9y agoSeems like FUD to me ! Maybe Sarbanes Oxley.
- jonathankoren 9y agoI'm thinking it's a typo for SEC.
- dogma1138 9y agoThat’s correct.
- dogma1138 9y agoTypo, too many acronyms. As for the second part I wont comment really I’m not in a place to make decisions on procurement I just brake things. I would just say that size/volume wise as far as clearings go there isn’t a better/bigger client. And everyone is the same.
- raverbashing 9y agoAh your other comment makes the procedure and why it's needed clearer
- EpicEng 9y agoFCC is a typo I'm sure. >Unless the company is already a customer and is paying for the development of the software, please do walk away from the table, I'm sure they have better things to do and better customers to sell to This sentiment is similar to things I hear all of the time working in health care / biotech. The fact is you have no domain knowledge and not a clue as to how things work in the real world. If your company just ignores the way things are done and the requirements of the domain you're simply going to go out of business. When the stakes are high (e.g. death/harm, massive financial losses, etc.) the business process changes accordingly.
- heartbreak 9y agoI’ve had a financial product audited by an independent firm the client and I agreed on. In fact they still audit it on a regular basis despite the product no longer being maintained.
- dogma1138 9y agoThis also can be acceptable based on the risk; sometimes we get a full pentest report from an independent security vendor.
- Steeeve 9y agoThere is no compliance rule put out by the SEC that requires (or even suggests) source code review.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]