4 ms·
Slightly tangential, but working for a small software company (<20 employees) who writes Line Of Business code for very large enterprise customers in the health
by FireBeyond 9y ago
Slightly tangential, but working for a small software company (<20 employees) who writes Line Of Business code for very large enterprise customers in the health care industry, we at times offer source code licenses, but at the very least (and this was my original point), our license as a vendor also includes source code escrow in the event of our collapse. We haven't really had anyone request a pre-sale source code review.
- GordonS 9y ago> our license as a vendor also includes source code escrow in the event of our collapse Wow, I've never heard of this before - it sounds great! Do you advertise this on your website, or is it just buried in the terms and conditions? I was just wondering how you might get across this info without worrying potential customers with the mere mention of collapse?
- dboreham 9y agoYou don't advertise it. You say nothing until a customer expresses concern about your long term survival then you say "Oh yeah this comes up from time to time and the solution is code escrow, we've done it for customer Y and X so we know the drill".
- FireBeyond 9y agoGiven the nature of the product we sell (where implementations are in the six-seven digit range, with sometimes over a year of prep work), it tends to come up in discussion most times, and I think may even be in our boilerplate contract (which is signed by both parties, it's not 'order online, enter credit card' purchasing).
- cgio 9y agoEven big vendors do source code escrow for very big contracts (e.g. government).
- dspillett 9y agoIn our case it has always been something our large clients request and expect as part of any project we work on, rather than something we advertise as a feature of working with us. Most companies will dictate that you use an escrow provider from their "preferred suppliers" list.
- matt_the_bass 9y agoAny suggestions for that “preferred suppliers” list?
- dspillett 9y agoIf there is a preferred suppliers list in operation, you don't pick those suppliers your client does. And it will often be relatively local, at least country local, companies in my experience, presumably for legal jurisdiction reasons. So what our clients dictate is probably irrelevant to your needs.
- matt_the_bass 9y agoThanks. I misunderstood. I thought you had a list of preferred escrow services.
- seehafer 9y agoSeconding the “source code in escrow” solution as a mitigation about concerns of working with a startup. IMO enterprise customers happy to pay for it and it usually never gets asked about again
- another-dave 9y agoHow does "code escrow" work in practice? Are you actively syncing to a private Git repo? Or is it more a case of, if we're collapsing, we'll put this in place?
- seehafer 9y agoCorrect there's some (not necessarily daily or weekly) amount of sync frequency that you negotiate.
- dspillett 9y ago> Or is it more a case of, if we're collapsing, we'll put this in place? No-one would trust that. If you are collapsing you aren't going to care enough, or the people who do/did both care and know what to include (source, build toolchain setup, documentation) have already gone. It is surprising, given how important it could be, how little the clients bother to check that escrow updates are happening - so even if the contract says otherwise it could often come down to this! > Are you actively syncing to a private Git repo? Some do that, but in my experience it is more common to provide a snapshot (a full copy of the relevant parts of your repo(s) with supporting documents), with a new snapshot uploaded with each major or minor release. Sometimes it isn't released based but instead the client dictates escrow is updated "at least once per year or X months" which to my mind shows that part of the contract was written by a legal/admin person without a lot of technical experience.
- another-dave 9y agoHaha, was thinking that wouldn't be too trusted alright! Scheduled syncing makes sense. Cheers for the replies, have never heard of the concept of code escrow before, seems like a neat solution