3 ms·
Most of the people in this thread clearly don't understand the situation as Analytics/ML is quite different to normal IT. 1) The company is not going to acquir
by threeseed 9y ago
Most of the people in this thread clearly don't understand the situation as Analytics/ML is quite different to normal IT.
1) The company is not going to acquire you nor will they sue you.
2) They absolutely want to replicate what you've done. It's not so that they can build their own startup and compete with you. It's because they genuinely want to understand how you got the results. Companies are increasingly basing their decisions on ML models and it's not acceptable for them to just "trust your black box". Especially since your model could be based off a misunderstanding of the data.
3) If you decide to say no then chances are they will walk away. Especially in the ML space companies are not going to let their core intellectual property be locked away in someone else's vault. They will simply not work with you.
4) The best way to handle this is simply to get them to sign a NDA or something equivalent that protects you in the case that a rogue employee decides to build a startup him/herself.
I am someone who works in ML for an enterprise company. For god sake give them the code and be grateful they are even doing a PoC with you.
- RHSman2 9y agoBest answer here. I am in the exact same situation BUT I actually share the code from the get go because of the need to understand decisions (and GDPR is going to make that even more important). If the OP company is doing something that is not possible elsewhere then fine but if they are just allowing them to goto market faster then the effort to re-engineer and get working (particularly in the AI/ML space) is pretty time consuming. EDIT: I think that the time of proprietary algorithms as MOATS are an old way. Things are moving SO fast now that your business is going to be outdated with the next release of Tensorflow or whatever is over the horizon.
- wastedhours 9y agoThis is a massively important point (if you're selling to the EU) - as part of GDPR companies need to have a way to audit the decision making process if a decision is being made by a computer.
- mr_toad 9y agoWhat happens if they have their own scientists take a look at the model and decide to replicate it internally without paying a cent? Knowing the sorts of decisions that were made around what types of algorithms and features to use (obvious after a cursory examination of the code) would give them a huge leg-up in developing a similar model.