4 ms·
When you have to judge papers/findings by the motives and qualifications of the authors rather than by the data, you no longer have science you have opinion. W
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
When you have to judge papers/findings by the motives and qualifications of the authors rather than by the data, you no longer have science you have opinion.
When the theory of relativity was introduced by Einstein, it did not matter what you thought about Einstein's qualifications or motivations. Einstein himself gave several ways the theory could be tested independently.
Because of the prestige that science garnered - it gave us airplanes, radio, tv, internet, landed a person on the moon, etc, many knowledge disciplines branded themselves as "x science". Thus, has the word "science" become devalued.
- forapurpose 9y ago> When you have to judge papers/findings by the motives and qualifications of the authors rather than by the data, you no longer have science you have opinion. To a significant degree, that is exactly how the scientific community operates. Amount of funding, prestige of journal (in which the research is published), and acceptance of results depend highly on reputation. I'm not a scientist, but I've heard that from many scientists and I believe there is research and journalism that support it. As in any industry, the ideal is not the reality. Think of programming; how much code actually follows the norms, ideals, and theories of how it should be done? Very, very little; OpenSSL comes to mind as an obvious example; OpenBSD tries to do it 'right', at least to a degree, but they make significant sacrifices in functionality and productivity, and many people think they are over-the-top, self-indulgent obsessives. The reality is that getting things done requires a lot of hacks; few people review any code, even open source; and if Linus Torvalds and I submit competing code to something, his will be accepted regardless of the quality - probably,
- forapurpose 9y agoMods / @dang / @sctb: I can't seem to edit the parent comment. When I made an edit, it cut off the end (about 1 sentence + 1 short paragraph). Now, no matter what I append in the edit, when I click submit it returns to the state above. I'm telling you so that you are aware of a bug. This one comment isn't a big deal.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 9y agoYeah. If someone claims data, reproduce their experiment. If someone makes a point, check their math. If it's beyond the realm of repoducing experiments and checking math it's beyond the realm of human knowledge. Sorry, but time and time again our kind have proven to be liars; and worse, self-decievers. Nothing else is left in ourselves to trust.
- throwawayjava 9y agoThis is true and it would be ideal if all lawmakers were well-versed in the process of science, as well as the subject matter relevant to their decisions. Unfortunately, that's an unrealistic assumption in the messy real world. In fact, I doubt even the most genius of researchers could be reasonably expected to verify the veracity of all the scientific claims that are advanced in defense of various policies that lawmakers must form opinions on. > Because of the prestige that science garnered - it gave us airplanes, radio, tv, internet, landed a person on the moon, etc, many knowledge disciplines branded themselves as "x science". Thus, has the word "science" become devalued. This is perhaps a bit off topic, but I'll just note that this includes Computer Science [1]. Also, you can replace "science" with "engineering" in that quote ("Software Engineering"). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_science#Etymology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_science#Etymology
- rayiner 9y agoDo you understand the math of climate modeling? Have you checked the equations, data, and made your own measurements? If not, why do you believe climate change is happening? And why do you believe the scientists that say it is happening versus the ones that say it is not happening?
- fleitz 9y agoI understand the math, they have a bunch of simulations that produce wildly different results, they average these and make predictions based on a number of models running a number of simulations. The predictions have so far yet to have come true. (Although temp is rising, it's not to the degree predicted by the average of the models, despite there being more CO2 than the models were given input for, obviously the average of models are inaccurate. ) I believe it's not happening to the degree the IPCC said it was in 1992 which is why in the 2000s they observed a warming 'hiatus'. This is why people talk about consensus rather than data, or falsifications of the null hypothesis.
- forapurpose 9y agoWhat were the predictions in 1992 and what level of confidence was assigned to them (the IPCC reports are very careful to assign confidence levels)? Also, there have been many generations of reports since then; why focus on 1992, 25 years ago? As far as I know, their predictions have been pretty good - though not perfectly accurate, of course. There is so much nonsense posted about climate science; it would be great if someone could back up claims, perhaps by citing the IPCC reports or some serious analysis of them (i.e., in a prominent journal).
- fleitz 9y ago1992 because it's the first report. Here's a decent summary: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_hiatus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming_hiatus 'climate is classically averaged over 30-year periods.[5]' 'Publicity has surrounded claims of a global warming hiatus during the period 1998–2013. The exceptionally warm El Niño year of 1998 was an outlier from the continuing temperature trend, and so subsequent annual temperatures gave the appearance of a hiatus: by January 2006, it appeared to some that global warming had stopped or paused.[2] A 2009 study showed that decades without warming were not exceptional,[6] and in 2011 a study showed that if allowances were made for known variability, the rising temperature trend continued unabated.' Essentially in 5 years we'll have enough data to confirm / deny the 1992 predictions, currently it's an unproven theory because of a lack of forward data. We're essentially using consensus as a proxy for a falsification of the null hypo
- goialoq 9y agoIf you ban opinions, it's impossible to get anything done that isn't very basic physics and chemistry.