3 ms·
You called the original poster out on making an absolute statement, and he clarified it was his experience, gathered from the people he knew. The first sentence
by scott_s 16y ago
You called the original poster out on making an absolute statement, and he clarified it was his experience, gathered from the people he knew. The first sentence in your final paragraph seems to deliberately disregard what he said to maintain outrage.
- ergo98 16y ago>You called the original poster out on making an absolute statement No, I didn't. I called them out for stereotyping why someone would choose something other than the iPhone. It's akin to saying "The Nexus One is the best device, but I can understand that if you're gay, a follower, or strongly susceptible to marketing pressure, the iPhone might be a better device for you". (You know, instead of finding it to be the right device for them) The outrage is about the strawman.
- scott_s 16y agoIn this context, I don't see how "making an absolute statement" is significantly different from stereotyping someone. He owned up to it and clarified where he felt his point applied. I now understand that he meant to say that among the people he knows, they consider the iPhone the better choice objectively, but some choose Android for ethical reasons. I don't see why you don't see that as well.