4 ms·
That's clearly a foul and has nothing to do with the open web. I disagree. On the "open web", users must have the right to consume the content the way they wan
by userbinator 9y ago
That's clearly a foul and has nothing to do with the open web.
I disagree. On the "open web", users must have the right to consume the content the way they want to. Or do you also think that adblockers, user styles, and the like are "clearly a foul"?
The fight is understandable, but that's why I'll always choose to consume content using a general-purpose computer instead of these restrictive appliances.
- jclardy 9y agoI think the difference comes by who is doing it. An end user doing it is their own right. A corporation bypassing another corporations monetization is something they should be permitted to deal with. They are essentially gaining a competitive advantage by bypassing ads for youtube on their own devices, so Google should block them until they comply.
- muninn_ 9y agoAnd Amazon should do whatever they feel is appropriate in response. They also don't sell the Apple TV (IIRC) on the Amazon store - Apple seems ok with it and now I have iTunes, Youtube, and Prime on my Apple TV.
- notheguyouthink 9y agoI mean, yes I agree - adblockers are "a foul" In the sense that it's very likely against the content providers wishes. I'm not saying users shouldn't be using them, but don't be surprised if the content provider tries to block access to people who actively avoid any monetization via adblockers. I'm very open web in concept, but just because I want the web to be open doesn't mean I'm entitled to everyones content for free with no restrictions. As a content provider, you should be allowed to put whatever restrictions on it that you want - just like the real world. Just keep your restrictions off of my computer. Eg, I DO NOT want to see DRM chips on my PC to protect companies. I am certainly fine with them requiring a DRM specific browser though, I can choose not to go to their site and not to use their browser.
- nathan_long 9y ago> As a content provider, you should be allowed to put whatever restrictions on it that you want - just like the real world. In the real world, I can sell you a paper magazine or give it to you for free. I cannot prevent you from ignoring the ads or hiring someone to cut them out with scissors. If a site wants to require me to pay in order to access it, that's valid. But if they want to say "you must instruct your computer to download and display our ads", that's not valid, IMO. My browser is an agent that works for me. The server is an agent that works for the site. We should each be free to instruct them as we wish.
- ythn 9y ago> But if they want to say "you must instruct your computer to download and display our ads", that's not valid, IMO. Why not? I can sell you a video stream without ads for $1. Or I can let you watch it for free with the implicit agreement that you'll watch ads (which will cover the costs of the bandwidth you are using). You want the best of both worlds - you want to watch it for free and not watch any ads. How is that not stealing my bandwidth? If you are going to block the ads, that's fine, but it's your moral obligation to back out of my site and not to consume my bandwidth.
- nathan_long 9y agoIf I mute the TV and go to the bathroom while the commercials play, am I stealing? If I read a magazine and flip past the ads, am I stealing? If I change the channel on the radio on a commercial break, am I stealing? I understand what you're saying about the producer's dependence on ad revenue. But never before has a media existed where someone could force you to consume advertising against your will. If you provide content with ads and people decline to look at your ads, you've got a problem with your business model. And by the way, I don't block ads on, eg, StackOverflow, because the ads are tasteful and useful. But if a site with news articles wants to show me animated, sexually suggestive ads for cheap pharmaceuticals, yes, I'm going to block that. I'm not going to let them steal my bandwidth and my mental calm for that.
- madeofpalk 9y agoUsers have the 'right' (and I used that word very lightly) to do such things, but companies and publishers also have the 'right' to respond to things that interfere with their products or business models.
- Scea91 9y agoExactly, the rights go both ways. Just as clients can choose which servers they want to access, servers can decide which clients they want to serve.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]