3 ms·
Putting aside all their misadventures with crypto and other bugs (it's crypto after all), they don't have a functioning currency or network. The Tangle is an i
by csomar 9y ago
Putting aside all their misadventures with crypto and other bugs (it's crypto after all), they don't have a functioning currency or network.
The Tangle is an idea that has no theoretical solution yet.
What I did understood is the following: A user that makes a transaction, picks two txs (from the unspent pool) and send his transaction. Then another user picks it with another one and send his. And so on and so forth. But who gets to decide which tree to follow?
This is exactly what mining is for: It is election based on mining capacity (or hash rate burn rate). The one who burns more hash rate gets elected to publish the next blockchain.
Not that mining can't get centralized, it is. But there is a difference: Mining is democratic. The nodes elect based on it. That's not the same with the coordinator in IOTA. It is run by the creator of the cryptocurrency.
Edit: Thinking about it now, is it ever possible to achieve this without "burning" something? (I mean equal consensus election without a non-free criteria). Doesn't this somehow conflict with the physic law of conservation of energy.
Now let me get to the important part: It's a premine. It has a nice façade and polished website. That's all you need to know.
This is going to end in tears for lots of people fomoing right now. (or later if this still ramps up)
- wslh 9y ago> The Tangle is an idea that has no theoretical solution yet. Not talking about IOTA specifically but DAG oriented blockchains, there is a good foundation in the SPECTRE paper which was done by recognized researchers in the field. In the following document we made a summary of emerging new research in blockchain technologies: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1J8hehbnZWzcIUMQcxMiGbjz86wDu3zDFF7UtkR0XjGE/ https://docs.google.com/document/d/1J8hehbnZWzcIUMQcxMiGbjz8...
- lojack 9y agoTo be fair, there are times in bitcoin when two hashes are found consecutively. In this case, who decides which one is the correct hash? The answer is that the network enters a contentious state and the miners compete over the correct hash until a new one is found ad infinitum. The chances of there multiple competing chains becomes virtually zero as time goes on. The same thing happens with IOTA, except the mining happens on the node sending the transaction (and confirming two others). Competing transactions can happen, and are propagated through the network, but eventually a consensus is reached. I’m only familiar with IOTA in passing, but the biggest flaw I see is of a malicious actor flooding the network with transactions to themselves. I believe the theory is that once the network is big enough this will economically not be feasible, but until then they have the master node. Whether or not this will end up working out, I’m not sure. Happy to be corrected for any of this. I’m not super familiar with IOTA, this is just my understanding of it.
- csomar 9y agoThe contentious state in bitcoin is a network fork. Fork A and Fork B. Both have equal chances. It is the next winning miner that decides which fork will be elected. So the responsibility is just pushed to the next guy. That's not the same with IOTA. Who gets to decide which fork is better? Based on what? Number of txs? That wouldn't work and I think it is obvious why.
- lojack 9y agoThe network fork is exactly what I described. With IOTA, it operates in a similar fashion. The winning chain is the one with the most successful hashes discovered. Just like bitcoin, except instead of a winning chain happening after ~2 hashes, it happens after hundreds(?) of hashes.
- csomar 9y agoHow do you reach a consensus and certainty though? What if there is low activity, few transactions; and then comes a big guy who was burning hash to generate txs and take over the chain?
- lojack 9y ago> How do you reach a consensus and certainty though? I feel like we're going in circles. In both Bitcoin and Iota, we never reach an absolute certainty. In Bitcoin we reach a point where its infeasible for transactions to ever be overwritten. For high value transactions this is generally around 5 or 6 confirmations. I don't know the exact number people use with Iota, but I remember hearing it was some percentage of confirmations within the tangle. > What if there is low activity, few transactions; and then comes a big guy who was burning hash to generate txs and take over the chain? That's the big flaw I pointed out in my original comment, that I suspect may exist.
- csomar 9y ago> In both Bitcoin and Iota, we never reach an absolute certainty. That's not correct. You are only uncertain in bitcoin when there are two equal (hash wise) blocks. This happens very rarely. That's not the case in IOTA since it does happen all the time and I'm guessing somebody could calculate txs to make it happen on purpose.
- lawn 9y agoTheir "solution" to the double spend problem (which is the real problem Bitcoin solves) is to have a centrally controlled entity, the coordinator, declaring which transactions are considered confirmed. When pressed the lead dev retorts with insults instead of answers [1] and tries to redirect to their subreddit where these questions conveniently disappear. [1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/7hgi2g/iota_warning/dqri89v/ https://www.reddit.com/r/btc/comments/7hgi2g/iota_warning/dq...