3 ms·
> This does not follow. If the ban didn't actually lessen the number of handguns, then we don't have the left hand side of the implication! These are two thing
by alkonaut 9y ago
> This does not follow.
If the ban didn't actually lessen the number of handguns, then we don't have the left hand side of the implication! These are two things:
ban on handguns -> less handguns
less handguns -> fewer deaths
Someone argued that the second is true, and you seem to refute it by saying the first isn't. So maybe you aren't talking about the same thing. I'm going to argue that the second thing isn't controversial. What's difficult and possibly controversial is whether item #1 is possible in Brazil, or the US (where guns are already common).
My take on it is this:
stricter laws + wait 2 or 3 generations -> fewer guns.
fewer guns -> fewer deaths.
- ueushzvzis 9y agoFewer guns does not equal fewer deaths in the developed world. You are doing exactly what you claim to be against. Cherry picking data to suit your narrative.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- daemin 9y agoYeah it does, Australia. That's the prime example of fewer guns = fewer deaths.
- andrenth 9y agoAustralia also had reduced number of gun-unrelated deaths. In fact the percent reduction in those cases was larger than the reduction of gun deaths. So the stricter gun laws can't be considered the sole explanation for fewer deaths.
- ceejayoz 9y agoThere's been a world-wide reduction in crime since the 1970s. It's very possible to isolate the impact of Australia's gun laws by comparing to other similar countries that didn't implement a major gun ban at the time.
- andrenth 9y agoHas that been done? I think it would be quite hard to provide any meaningful comparison between countries, because the results would be clouded by many other factors that can influence them.
- repsilat 9y agoI don't have a horse in this race, but this argument seems to do double-duty: > "Violent crime without firearms went down, maybe it was just people getting less violent." > "Violent crime without firearms went up, people are going to be violent with or without guns."
- hectorlorenzo 9y agoIt's the second time you mention this without providing any source. Can you please elaborate?
- alkonaut 9y ago> Fewer guns does not equal fewer deaths in the developed world I didn't argue against cherry picking (which I'm also against) I was arguing against the parent opposing something entirely different than the post he was responding to. I divided the implication into two. The guns-to-deaths implication isn't clear cut either, but less so than the laws-to-guns one. My argument is that this is mostly cultural, which is why it's so hard to measure. The reason being that gun culture both creates a cliate of many guns, but also the other way around (many guns means people are more likely to use/buy guns). Comparable societies (such as US vs rest of western world). By "more guns" I include not just more guns sold/owned but "more guns in circulation" i.e. number of guns on streets, in cars, in bedside tables, as opposed to in gun safes. A lot of countries with lots of guns have mostly locked up rifles and very few handguns. That blurs these statistics.
- bbot23 9y agoYour implication fails in the real world in the same way that banning, demonizing, and siphoning drugs out of the country has failed. Yes, stricter laws, a buy-back policy and a generational shift will most definitely lower the current amount of guns in circulation in a given society. But just like with drugs, and sadly with a lot of gun-strict cities in the US, it has no bearing on the subsequent widening of the illegal gun pipeline. Not to mention the ever-present lack of a generational shift among current and potential illegal gun owners. It's interesting to me that a lot progressive, popular armchair analysis of the issue advocates for strict gun laws, and at the same time advocates for loose drug laws. What are the inherent differences between both problems that most people use to reconcile the cognitive dissonance?
- alkonaut 9y ago> it has no bearing on the subsequent widening of the illegal gun pipeline All guns were legal at one point. Buy backs, fewer sales etc mean fewer legal and illegal guns in circulation (unless you see an increase in illegal smuggling and manufacturing - but obviously that's a problem you need to address first then). There will always be demand for weapons, legal or illegal. Just like with drugs. If you don't want people to buy illegal drugs or illegal guns, you only need to keep supply so low that prices are too high for most. The problem for the US is that there are already so many guns, that effective legislation is problematic. For any legislation to be effective you'd first need to lower the amount of guns in society - because as you say otherwise there are too many guns that flow into the "illegal gun pipeline". So it's a chicken and egg problem. The questoin is: is it really an ok solution to say "we can't change regulation to something that would mean less guns in society because we have too many guns"? > It's interesting to me that a lot progressive, popular armchair analysis of the issue advocates for strict gun laws, and at the same time advocates for loose drug laws I think progressives mostly argue for looser drug laws for USE, not sale, apart from possibly also legalizing a few drugs. I don't think many progressives argue for lower penalties for drug smuggling, manufacturing and sales. The big difference between gun ownership and drug use in that context is that gun ownership would be a choice. If you are conservative you might argue that using drugs, being gay etc. is also a choice - but that's the philosophical side of it - I won't go there.
- 9y ago
- andrenth 9y agoA law to ban guns will lead to less guns... but only in the hands of people who care about laws.
- alkonaut 9y agoThat's a pretty tired tautology. It might also lead to less guns also in the hands of those who don't care about laws. For example because fewer guns can make them a lot more expensive and/or more risky to aquire illegaly. One can't simply argue that "A law against X only affects those who care about laws!". That's always the case. Seatbelt laws leads to fewer deaths - among those who care about seatbelt laws. A ban on smoking in restaurants leads to fewer people who care about bans smoking in restaurants...
- andrenth 9y agoThose are absolutely flawed comparisons, because a criminal, by definition, is someone who doesn't care about the law. You cannot make that assumption about smokers or drivers.
- alkonaut 9y ago> a criminal, by definition, is someone who doesn't care about the law. That was my point too: that it's not really a good argument to argue against laws because they are uneffective against criminals who don't care about them. Laws against child abuse are only effective on people who care about child abuse. Laws against plane hijacking are only effective on people who care about laws on plane hijacking. What's the difference?
- andrenth 9y agoThe correct question following your line of reasoning is not the one about gun ownership, but "Laws against murders are only effective on people who care about laws about murder". However these cases are fundamentally different. Only criminals abuse children, hijack planes or commit murder. Guns, on the other hand, are not only used by criminals. They can be used by citizens for their own protection, to prevent crimes. For example, consider a woman preventing a rape attempt by using her gun. Or the recent case of the Texas church, which could have resulted in many more deaths if not by the actions of an armed citizen. When you forbid gun ownership, then only criminals will have access to them. You remove access for regular people but keep it for criminals who would already have access to them anyway.