6 ms·
I don't think the intention was to block access to the web site. The problem was that Amazon was using a proprietary native app to access YouTube videos, bypass
by simonh 9y ago
I don't think the intention was to block access to the web site. The problem was that Amazon was using a proprietary native app to access YouTube videos, bypassing the web site and without support for any of Google's monetisation strategies they have in their own YouTube apps. That's clearly a foul and has nothing to do with the open web.
Arguably Google went too far by blanket blocking based on device, but it might have been the only viable option available to them. Now that Amazon has folded and made the app a wrapper to the YouTube web page rather than accessing the videos directly, I expect Google will enable access again.
- yread 9y agoExactly the same thing happened with Windows Phone's Youtube app. https://www.theverge.com/2013/8/15/4624706/google-blocks-window-phone-youtube-app https://www.theverge.com/2013/8/15/4624706/google-blocks-win... What was Amazon thinking?
- alaxsxaq 9y agoThey are definitely blocking access to the web site now. First, Google blocked the app because it 'didn't comply with their policies'. Then Amazon changed it so YouTube access from these devices was, essentially, directly through the website. Now that is blocked as well. Google has a point about Amazon not carrying their devices, but I'd take a different approach - I'd lead every YouTube video played through a Fire device with an ad for Google's devices.
- hrktb 9y agoWhat I find jarring is the asymetry of the effect. Amazon punishes Google directly as a company: users wanting Google product only have to change the URL in their browser. Google in return punishes customer having already bought their Amazon device. If the customer uses a Fire stick for intance, the only alternative to have youtube on the tv is to buy another dongle. The level of fucking with the end customer is disproportionate.
- majewsky 9y ago> users wanting Google product only have to change the URL in their browser. For most customers, that's about as "doesn't work" as it gets.
- b4lancesh33t 9y agoNot true. Amazon punishes me every time I want to cast Amazon video to my Chromecast. I think the two situations are quite analogous.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- glenneroo 9y agoAnd Amazon Prime Video punishes me for trying to play video on a device via VGA cable, which they say is not HDCP compatible, therefore they limit it to 480p (when the projector supports HD/1080p).
- ygra 9y agoIs that Amazon Prime Video punishing you or the wishes of content copyright holders?
- glenneroo 9y agoI suppose both. But Netflix works fine.
- Spivak 9y agoIf this really annoys you, and it would annoy me, you can buy an HDMI splitter that strips HDCP. They run from between $5-$40 depending on whether you trust some no-name brand.
- oneweekwonder 9y agoand the rest of the world just source their content via explicit means. Because they find their time more valuable then a "legal grey area"/"moral high ground"/"doing what is right".
- userbinator 9y agoThat's clearly a foul and has nothing to do with the open web. I disagree. On the "open web", users must have the right to consume the content the way they want to. Or do you also think that adblockers, user styles, and the like are "clearly a foul"? The fight is understandable, but that's why I'll always choose to consume content using a general-purpose computer instead of these restrictive appliances.
- jclardy 9y agoI think the difference comes by who is doing it. An end user doing it is their own right. A corporation bypassing another corporations monetization is something they should be permitted to deal with. They are essentially gaining a competitive advantage by bypassing ads for youtube on their own devices, so Google should block them until they comply.
- muninn_ 9y agoAnd Amazon should do whatever they feel is appropriate in response. They also don't sell the Apple TV (IIRC) on the Amazon store - Apple seems ok with it and now I have iTunes, Youtube, and Prime on my Apple TV.
- notheguyouthink 9y agoI mean, yes I agree - adblockers are "a foul" In the sense that it's very likely against the content providers wishes. I'm not saying users shouldn't be using them, but don't be surprised if the content provider tries to block access to people who actively avoid any monetization via adblockers. I'm very open web in concept, but just because I want the web to be open doesn't mean I'm entitled to everyones content for free with no restrictions. As a content provider, you should be allowed to put whatever restrictions on it that you want - just like the real world. Just keep your restrictions off of my computer. Eg, I DO NOT want to see DRM chips on my PC to protect companies. I am certainly fine with them requiring a DRM specific browser though, I can choose not to go to their site and not to use their browser.
- 9y ago
- sfifs 9y ago> ...wrapper to the YouTube web page rather than accessing the videos directly, I expect Google will enable access again. Probably they won't. WebViews don't return device ids amd don't let you set persistent cookies which are basically what's needed to get ad targeting correct on mobile.
- throwawaybbqed 9y agoThey can the webview change code on their platform?
- JoshMnem 9y agoAnother example: I can't watch purchased YouTube videos at full resolution on in my Web browser. It tells me that I need to buy a spyware-infested device that doesn't give me full control over the operating system.