4 ms·
Portugal’s policy is deeply flawed because it does not legalize the sale of all drugs, only the consumption. When selling is legal is when organized crime leav
by andrewstuart 9y ago
Portugal’s policy is deeply flawed because it does not legalize the sale of all drugs, only the consumption.
When selling is legal is when organized crime leaves the picture, taxes can be collected, product is clean and measured and of quality.
Both sides of the equation are important to legalize, doing one without the other means huge problems remain.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoI don't think that something as harmful as heroin should be legal to sell, even in a taxed and regulated scenario. Other options that, in my amateur opinion, would be better, would be to more heavily penalise adultered drugs, or to have pharmacies supply, with a prescription, addictive drugs, but only to addicts. The latter idea is basically an extension of safe injection clinics.
- rblatz 9y agoThere are multiple drugs of the same class as heroin that are actually stronger and more dangerous than heroin that are legal. But they aren’t sold cut to hell with fillers in order to make extra money.
- eitland 9y agoThey are also only sold with a prescription. And while I know US has an opioid crisis this prescription thing seems to work here.
- justrobert 9y agoExcept anyone can buy fent online easily. Far more dangerous for anyone who is near those that buy it.
- derefr 9y agoIt doesn't have to be sold to the end-consumer; but it does have to make a profit for the producer/distributor (e.g. one of the big pharma companies) if you want to disincentivize the black-market producers. Probably this would mean that the government itself buys the drugs from the pharma companies, and then gives them away for free to prescribed+registered users. It's the fact that the pharma company has someone to profit by selling the drugs to, that incentivizes clean/pure/safely dosed drugs to be produced.
- herbst 9y agoPharma grade heroin from the state is a thing in Switzerland. It works pretty well actually and turned a big problem into a small controlled one. Most addicts even have normal jobs.
- barry-cotter 9y agoAlcohol abuse is more harmful than crack or heroin abuse, according to a new study by a former British government drug advisor and other experts. Neuropharmacologist David Nutt, MD, of Imperial College London, and colleagues rated 20 different drugs on a scale that takes into account the various harms caused by a drug. Drugs are rated on nine harms a drug causes an individual and seven harms a drug causes society. The scale, developed by a panel of experts called the Independent Scientific Committee on Drugs (ICSD), ranges from 0 (no harm) to 100 (greatest possible harm). It is weighted so that a drug that scores 50 is half as harmful as a drug that scores 100. "The highest and lowest overall harm scores … are 72 for alcohol and 5 for mushrooms," Nutt and colleagues calculate. "The ICSD scores lend support to the widely accepted view that alcohol is an extremely harmful drug both to users and to society https://www.webmd.com/mental-health/addiction/news/20101101/alcohol-more-harmful-than-crack-or-heroin https://www.webmd.com/mental-health/addiction/news/20101101/...
- alphaalpha101 9y agoSelling shouldn't be legal. They're controlled substances. Now I think marijuana should indeed by legalised, but heroin certainly shouldn't be.
- zaarn 9y agoIn which case the policy would be similar to germany; german law considers drug consumption a form of selfharm, which the law has no authority to forbid. Selling, owning or doing anything but consuming drugs is basically illegal though.
- icebraining 9y agoThe important part of the law regards to carrying: in Portugal, carrying small amounts (eg. up to 1gr of heroin or 25gr of marijuana leaves¹) is considered to be for personal use and decriminalized. Is the same true in Germany? ¹As defined in the law, but prosecutors and judges can and often do avoid charging people with crimes if they have a bit more and there's no evidence of trafficking.
- zaarn 9y agoCarrying/Owning any amount of drugs would be illegal, though small amounts are rarely prosecuted when the general area has comparatively high amounts of addicts.
- 627467 9y ago"deeply flawed"? Maybe legalizing distribution returns other benefits, but this article (and other from past years) and reality seem to indicate that the benefit of decriminalizing drug consumption (ownership of small quantities) is higher than criminalizing it.
- aquadrop 9y agoI don't think _selling_ is a must, but the end user should have an ability _to get_ the drug. Marijuana should be sold and profited off (though regulated) to serve as a barrier so people won't have to switch to hard drugs. But hard drugs should be controlled more tightly. It can be a special block at hospitals or something like that, where a person can come and get the dose, maybe even free. But that place should also provide help and ways to overcome the addiction - opportunities for rehabilitation courses, education prospects, psychologist and previous addicts who got clean etc. It should be an outpost for fighting hard drugs addiction. Yes, that will required money, but it can come from all the savings from 'War on Drugs'. And if user will have an ability to get drugs there, criminals will still lose profits, and yes, I agree that removing profits from the criminals is one of the main points of "legalization".
- icc97 9y agoI think you mean "not as good as it could be" rather than "deeply flawed". They're leading the world in getting to a stage where all drugs could be legalised. The Portuguese doctor Goulão who leads most of the drug panels does want to legalise all drugs. He makes the argument that all drugs should be legalised not just baby steps of cannabis, so he definitely agrees with you. What Portugal has achieved is amazing because they also had very conservative governments and yet still got as far as decriminalisation.