4 ms·
Curious, is this a violation of net neutrality? This seems even worse for the consumer than simply having to pay more. At least then you still can get access.
by freedomben 9y ago
Curious, is this a violation of net neutrality? This seems even worse for the consumer than simply having to pay more. At least then you still can get access. Do we clamor for the government to come regulate it?
Be careful when considering this so as not to be inconsistent with your reasoning behind NN for ISPs.
- ucaetano 9y agoNo. This is not developing an app for a certain device.
- guelo 9y agoNo. the network refers to the transit medium. Network non-neutrality would make it worse because comcast could decide you can't watch youtube or amazon video on any device.
- wang_li 9y agoThe network only refers to the transit medium if your premise is that the power to control content lie with one particular interest group instead of another. What's special about Twitter that they get to decide who can use their computers, routers, switches and so on, whereas level-3 is not allowed to do the same?
- guelo 9y agoThe physical medium is the limited public resource. We have all the public ground and all the radio spectrum we'll ever have. Tearing up roads, wiring up cities, assigning spectrum, blanketing the country in antennas, are national infrastructure projects that take decades and billions of dollars. In America with our belief in the free market we've traditionally done these projects with public/private partnership. But we can't give corporations complete free reign because they're using our one set of physical resources, if they screw those up then we lose access to our shared telecommunication infrastructure. On top of these physical networks the digital companies are building virtual networks. Twitter, Snapchat, Medium, Google, Facebook, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, and a thousand more companies vigorously competing in these virtual domains. The virtual worlds are so vast and we're still trying to understand their potential that even when these companies seem to be forming monopolistic locks we should give them free rein. You have more communication channels today then anybody else in human history. Stop calling for government control of our unlimited virtual resources.
- alacombe 9y agoGoogle can not be in favor of non-neutral net. They would be among the first impacted by ISP restricting content providers. This has nothing to do about "user"'s freedom, but all to do about their own business model. It doesn't matter if it's good for the end-user, Google main focus is Google (and its shareholders), not Joe Blow. Now, this would probably not be in the scope of NN and the FCC, but more of anti-trust laws.
- paul7986 9y agoHA equating this to net neutrality is like HUH and WHAT! Google nor Amazon control the pipes and here in the US for home broadband it's a monopoly or a duopoly. With Net Neutrality gone my monopolistic broadband provider can start blocking sites, charging me to access different sites and etc. They can turn the Internet into the horrendous model and experience that is Cable TV. No way is Google's actions here have anything to do with Net Neutrality. Rather in this instance a consumer can go just go ahead and buy another streaming device if they choose to do so. That's because there's competition and lots of it in this space vs. fast uncapped broadband.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Curious, is this a violation of net neutrality? No, Amazon leveraging it's exclusive content and video service to sell FireTV, or Google leveraging YouTube to sell Chromecast, is not a violation of Net Neutrality, or within the statutory mandate of the FCC even more generally. Either might be a violation of anti-trust law within the purview of the FTC, of course.
- Terr_ 9y agoThis reminds me of those older consumers who think "The Internet" is program on their computer. They have a confusion between labels and ideas. Network neutrality means neutral behavior of the transmission networks. It does not mean "Everything consumers think of when they hear the words 'The Net'" neutrality.