3 ms·
> 1. What about the property tax deduction? Why are property taxes deductible, but income taxes are not? There's no objective reason why it should be. But sinc
by smsm42 9y ago
> 1. What about the property tax deduction? Why are property taxes deductible, but income taxes are not?
There's no objective reason why it should be. But since deductions are largely arbitrary policy instruments anyway - because property tax deduction encourages and makes easier home ownership (at least this is the theory) and the government wants more home ownership. State tax deduction does not really have such goal (unless you see moving people to high-tax states as a goal, but I don't think federal government identifies such goal).
> 2. How do you feel about the mortgage interest deduction? A very similar question could be asked.
Same as above. Only much bigger - given 20% down mortgages, mortgage interest - especially for new mortgages on standard equal-payment plan - is very substantial. So, tax deduction makes owning home easier - and, on the reverse, removing this deduction would seriously hurt current mortgage owners and discourage new ones.
The difference here is that with property-related taxes there is a policy goal linked to it, and also long-term choice individuals make based on this policy, which would make them very upset if the policy changes. With state taxes, there's no real policy goal (for federal government at least) and most people don't choose state to live it because of state tax deduction.
- vostok 9y ago> The difference here is that with property-related taxes there is a policy goal linked to it, and also long-term choice individuals make based on this policy, which would make them very upset if the policy changes. Wouldn't you agree that choosing to live in particular state is just as much of a long term decision as choosing to live in a particular house?
- smsm42 9y agoYes, but how much state tax deduction figures in that choice? I wouldn't say it's a lot. Presence and absence of state income tax - maybe, but presence of deduction - not very likely. And of course, if the state wanted to compete on that metric, they could easily lower the taxes, but I haven't seen many high-tax ones to be willing to.
- vostok 9y agoOf course it's a significant factor. You're talking about a pretty large portion of a household's budget.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> State tax deduction does not really have such goal State tax deduction has an even better goal: avoiding discouraging tax and spending decisions that pay for themselves and provide additional returns before considering federal tax distortions.