4 ms·
You're missing one even more heinous point, renters. A family paying off their 300k mortgage is getting a decrease in taxes owed while being subsidized for payi
by munk-a 9y ago
You're missing one even more heinous point, renters. A family paying off their 300k mortgage is getting a decrease in taxes owed while being subsidized for paying into an asset. The renting family is not being subsidized and they will never again see the money they are spending on rent. In most areas this is particularly twisted as mortgages will run beneath rental costs for the same standard of living. So the only real difference is that renters don't have to deal with the costs of damage to their asset... no money out of pocket for repainting or replacing appliances or structural issues and if their building slides into the sea they aren't out the value of the property.
Often times this also gets a bonus racist angle since minorities have a harder time securing a mortgage which traps them into overpaying for housing while struggling to save to pay less for their housing.
- smsm42 9y ago> The renting family is not being subsidized Guess what happens to rent if cost of ownership rises due to interest not being deductible?
- refurb 9y agoMy guess is housing prices fall and rents follow?
- smsm42 9y agoNope, at least not in the short term. In the short term, house price is locked for the current owner, and usually by their payments to the mortgage holder. If the expenses rise, so do the prices. And since this will happen on the whole market, the price rise would not be substantially constrained by the competition. On the long term, this could depress the housing market and thus lead to lower prices. That would depend on the overall market state - in markets with housing shortage that probably won't happen anyway.
- refurb 9y agoIf the expenses rise, so do the prices. Not sure I understand. If expenses rise, housing prices fall, not increase. And yes, a landlord might say "my expenses went up so rent will go up as well". However, the market sets prices, not landlords. He might raise the price, the tenant leaves and his place sits empty. There are plenty of people out there losing money as landlords because their rents are higher than what people will pay.