5 ms·
> I cannot see this bill as anything short of theft. Why do I have to pay double-digit percentage more on my taxes to give the ultra rich a tax cut? In what fuc
by vkou 9y ago
> I cannot see this bill as anything short of theft. Why do I have to pay double-digit percentage more on my taxes to give the ultra rich a tax cut? In what fucking world does that make any economic sense.
My rent isn't tax deductible. Why is yours blessed with such a status (In the form of a mortgage, and property tax deduction)?
All that mortgage tax deductions do, economically, is increase the overall price of homes, and have non-homeowners subsidize home-owners.
- mattchristen 9y agoBecause the person that owns the property you rent is receiving those benefits.
- mmanfrin 9y agoMortgage interest and property taxes are costs on top of the actual cost of the house. My mortgage itself isn't tax deductible.
- refurb 9y agoIt's still a concession to homeowners that renters don't get. We want taxes to be fair, no?
- rootusrootus 9y agoNot really. Trying to make taxes fit some arbitrary definition of fair is most of the problem. We should be looking at macro effects on our whole economy when making decisions on taxes.
- froindt 9y agoFWIW, only the interest is deductible, not the entire payment. I agree with the sentiment though. The realtors have arguably the most effective lobbying efforts, and to be able to tie their industry in with the "American Dream" has been very effective. I was out in DC earlier this year speaking with my congressional representatives about some changes to the bankruptcy code. We were working with a lobbyist who said something along the lines of "everybody knows when the realtors are in town. Nobody tries to get meetings that week because they have such a great mobilization effort, everyone gets booked up."
- gizmo 9y agoThe rationale is to encourage home ownership, because that gives people an incentive to care about upkeep and the community. It's hard to create good neighborhoods with renters who can just pack up and leave.
- hbarka 9y agoRelax. You’re not subsidizing anyone. Homeowners pay a larger share than renters to begin with. And if you know anything about Western society, home ownership creates stable societies—that’s why ownership is encouraged.
- BeetleB 9y ago>Relax. You’re not subsidizing anyone. Homeowners pay a larger share than renters to begin with. As someone who knows many landlords: Completely wrong. They buy properties with a loan. They pay interest on that loan. The money the renter pays goes towards the interest payments. Renters are essentially buying the properties for the owners. And landlords can keep deducting it, no matter how many properties. Homeowners can deduct only for two houses. And renters deduct none of it. The landlords literally deduct what their tenants are paying (interest, which is part of their rent). And not sure about your other comment, but rarely do renters of similar size houses/apartments pay less than homeowners. As an example, my house I bought only a few years ago: I pay just a little more than some 3 bedroom apartments (which are much smaller than my house). Most 3 bedroom apartments in desirable areas in my city pay more in rent than my monthly payment. And then with all the deductions I was getting, I was effectively paying less than most 2 bedroom apartments, and some single bedroom apartments. And if I take into account the amount going towards the principle, I'm paying about the same as most single bedroom apartments in my area. I did not put in a huge down payment. Less than 20%, in fact.
- hbarka 9y agoUhhh, the topic was about taxes. The homeowner demographic is statistically a higher earner than the renter demographic, thus pay more taxes.
- tzs 9y agoBusinesses generally get to deduct interest on loans used for the business, so landlords would probably be able to deduct mortgage interest under that even if there was no specific mortgage deduction in the tax code. Accordingly, I'm not sure it makes sense to discuss landlords when discussing the mortgage interest deduction.
- AznHisoka 9y agoOk, lets play this game. From now on its renters that have to pay 50% of the property tax. No? But you get to deduct it! an extra deduction for you! whats not to like?!
- SmellTheGlove 9y ago> Ok, lets play this game. From now on its renters that have to pay 50% of the property tax. No? But you get to deduct it! an extra deduction for you! whats not to like?! Renters already are paying a piece of the property tax. It's built into the rent. They just can't deduct it.
- AznHisoka 9y agoOk that may be true but why should they be allowed to deduct it? They are not a business owner (unlike the landlord). Its like allowing people to deduct 10% of everything they buy from Amazon because they are paying a part of Amazon’s warehousing costs.
- SmellTheGlove 9y agoI'm not advocating for renters to be able to deduct a piece of the underlying property tax. I don't think it makes sense to have property tax as a federal deduction at all. In general, I'm not sure how great it is that we favor home ownership over renting in our tax policy. My bigger issue is being able to deduct mortgage interest but not rent. Mortgage interest is essentially rent on money, so I've always thought it'd be fair to make rent (or a percentage of it at least) deductible as well. Or, even better, eliminate the mortgage interest deduction entirely. Full disclosure, I'm a homeowner. Fuller disclosure, my home is paid off, so it's easy for me to say these deductions shouldn't exist. I would gladly give up the property tax deduction if that additional revenue was used for something other than cutting taxes for the wealthy, though.
- AznHisoka 9y agoOK, I see your point with mortgage interest interested being deductible.
- mcbruiser4 9y ago> My rent isn't tax deductible. Why is yours blessed with such a status Because for better or worse (for better IMO), the government wants to encourage homeownership and families, which is why there's also a credit for children.