3 ms·
I think this is a great trend for usability and security. For software companies that can actually do it well. But at the bottom of the article it mentions tha
by mattmanser 16y ago
I think this is a great trend for usability and security. For software companies that can actually do it well.
But at the bottom of the article it mentions that Adobe are experimenting with doing it. Argh!
Flash yes, I can see it. But Reader? I don't want it to update on the rare occasions I open a pdf.
Actually the only reason I oppose Adobe doing it is because I think of them as having some pretty awful programming teams. And whoever writes their updaters is one of those bloody awful teams.
Certain parts of their products are very buggy compared to Google, MS or games programmers. They just do not have quality across their brand.
My constant nightmares with adobe updaters across a wide variety of machines has made me believe this.
When it comes to updaters Adobe have always chosen the worst paths, annoying prompts when you hadn't used readers for weeks, horrible confusing UIs and obviously not thoroughly tested.
They're just not up to the task.
I guess what I'm saying is this trend should be welcomed, but with a pinch of salt, some companies like Google and MS I trust to do it. Others I would not (Adobe if you hadn't guessed ;).
- CrazedGeek 16y agoIf Reader silently updates though, the UI issues and annoying prompts are pretty much eliminated.
- daychilde 16y agoI definitely agree that there should be options to turn the silent updates off... There are several companies I disable: Winamp, for a while, was updating WAY too often; I used to have trouble with Quicktime - but, in my humble opinion, that software is just... ugh. bloatware and badly written. Thank goodness we've moved on from it as a standard... Adobe's updater is another one I turn off - I really dislike the companies that add a "quickstart" app to my startup - I don't need update checkers from ten different companies stealing my resources.... But there are some smaller names that I do think get it right: Filezilla - even though they tend to update more than I'd like, the update process works pretty well and doesn't take too long; uTorrent is another, as well as VLC does okay... I definitely think that different classes of users will have different experiences. For Gramma and Grampa, autoupdating is generally better, because they never will. For us geeks: well, we can turn it off for companies that don't do it right; and we talk about our experiences - companies develop reputations...
- risotto 16y agoGreat point. I love the auto-update feature on Chrome but I share the same fear as you if Adobe was to start doing it. Only software companies with mature software, good release management and clear product vision should go down this road. Google earned their rep here. There are white papers about the binary diff algorithms they developed to push down Chrome updates as efficiently as possible. I can see Adobe trying to "silently" push Reader 10 down the pipe, with the installer weighing in at 600 megs and throwing up tons of horrible dialogs and thrashing your CPU as it's "automatically" installed and resulting in a broken Reader. Hyperbole of course, but Adobe has long been banished from my computers because of their awful updater agent and performance regression in new versions of software.