4 ms·
Nick Carr: Tracking Is an Assault on Liberty, With Real Dangers
- zaidf 16y agoThis is Murdoch's attempt to hurt the online ad world which subsidizes many sites Murdoch thinks should be paid. And because they are not paid, they are hurting sites that are going paid...such as the WSJ. Ah Murdoch.
- pavs 16y agoI dislike Murdoch (and WSJ) as much as the next guy, but from what I understand, Nicholas Carr has been writing this type of articles all over the place recently (not only on Murdoch's newspapers) to promote his book "The Shallows: What the Internet Is Doing to Our Brains".
- zaidf 16y agoFair enough. Though I think this goes beyond Nicholas Carr. WSJ's been doing hit pieces on cookies and online advertising pretty regularly the past few months. In that case, Carr may be someone they invited to join their attack team.
- pavs 16y agoIf you try hard enough eventually you will find a reason to justify a conclusion you have already reached in your mind. While I can only assume why Carr was invited to write on WSJ on this specific topic, it would seem that promoting his book would be the most probable reason. Carr has some very valid points however.
- zaidf 16y agoNote that it is unlikely that WSJ would invite Carr so that he could promote his book. WSJ doesn't really give a shit about Carr. They do give a shit about certain stances and promoting them.
- hga 16y agoThe Wall Street Journal is famous for always having been a on-line subscription site and apparently a successful one. Murdoch would only care about this in the context of his trying to transform the WSJ into a replacement for The New York Times ... and I'm not sure how that would work.... (On the other hand he has more than a few other newpaper properties where he thinks he has a problem, something he's experimenting with by putting the London Times behind a pay-wall in stages.)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- hexis 16y agoThe WSJ also ran an editorial taking the opposite view, which I just submitted - http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1586680 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1586680
- bigiain 16y agoIt might just be one of my personal pet peeves, but when I read "The incorporation of GPS transmitters into cellphones" I automatically switched to the assumption that the author is an idiot. (or at the very least, so careless with his writing that he's unlikely to be saying anything worth spending the time to read)
- zeynel1 16y ago''The very idea of privacy is under threat'' it is very possible that the author wrote this piece -or at least he had it in his laptop- while he was in an airport waiting to get scanned - or at least once in his lifetime embarked on an airplane in an airport - while he was in an airport his privacy is not --under threat-- he has -no- right to privacy - his lagguage is opened - his body is scanned naked -- his privacy is violated to the core and he can do nothing about it - except to take the humiliation and rationalize it later -or- the author may be walking in the streets of new york -or any big city- where he is vidotaped non-stop - he has no privacy - some entity is violating his privacy by videotaping him and he can do nothing about it - his privacy is not -under threat- his privacy is non-existent -because- his privacy -is- violated - he has no privacy while he is walking in the streets of new york you may say that his home is his castle -and- he has his -right- to privacy at home - even this is not true the fact that he appears to have privacy at home is because the enity who -owns- his right to privacy does -not- care what he does at home --but-- if the entity who owns his right to privacy -suspects- that he is doing something in his -castle- that he is not supposed to do according to the entity who owns his right to privacy - his privacy at home will be violated just like his privacy is violated in the airport the fact that at a certain place at a certain time --supposedly at home-- he has a -semblance- of privacy does not mean that his privacy is not violated - he has lost his ---right--- to privacy long time ago i dont know how to explain this - if he had his -right- to privacy no one -can- violate his privacy -but- his privacy is violated all the time and he can do nothing about it - this means that he has no -right- to privacy -because- his privacy can be violated any time by the entity who own his privacy the right to privacy is not something that you have it here now and not there and then -- as a human being he has no -right- to privacy if anyone can explain what i am trying to say in a better language i would be most grateful
- slvrspoon 16y agoI appreciate it's hard to write in a non-native language (i'm assuming English is not your first language) and a lot of your observations about the loss of privacy in everyday life are true. However, you are wrong about not having "right" to privacy. Why do search warrants exist? Why do newspapers get sued for slander? I'd love to hear more about what HN thinks about online privacy.
- dennisgorelik 16y agoI think privacy would become less and less important over the years. There is no much harm from lack of privacy. There is a bad component in privacy violation though: it's when privacy is violated _exclusively_ by some powerful entity, such as government. But if privacy is just not there and life of all individuals is available to the public -- there is almost no real harm in it.