8 ms·
This Dumb Industry: Wilson Boxes
- mattmanser 9y agoBad title for great article, it's an excellent analysis about EA's commercial missteps in implementing loot boxes in new games threatening their golden goose of FIFA.
- Already__Taken 9y ago> Disney have a fundamental, core company value of “No Gambling” > For a concrete example: Every cruise line has an onboard casino – except for Disney cruise ships. Wow that puts some teeth behind this debacle. I was under the impression this would be a lot of noise and battlefront 3 would sell a billion copies.
- wlkr 9y agoI was totally unaware that Disney so vehemently stuck to their "No Gambling" value. Searching for further reading I found an interesting blog post [0] which explains how new (Marvel, LucasFilm) Disney IP is (was) being removed from slot machines and gambling games. [0] https://www.onlinecasinoselite.org/post/disney-claims-the-rights-on-star-wars-and-marvel-slots https://www.onlinecasinoselite.org/post/disney-claims-the-ri...
- digi_owl 9y agoThere was also a PC game, Marvel Heroes, that had their contract pulled recently for no apparent reason. Some in the player community has claimed that the CEO had a rap sheet and Disney was pull out because of the whole Metoo thing, but pulling out over the heavy use of loot box mechanics may make more sense.
- Fiahil 9y agoIndeed, this is the most interesting information in this article. I will definitively look for Disney's reaction !
- lettergram 9y agoApparently, they are down 60 percent over the previous versions sales[1]. And their stock is tumbling from all sales. [1] https://www.eurogamer.net/amp/2017-11-20-star-wars-battlefront-2-physical-sales-down-60-per-cent-on-battlefront-1 https://www.eurogamer.net/amp/2017-11-20-star-wars-battlefro...
- BoorishBears 9y ago*Down 60 percent in physical sales Physical sales have been declining across the board. And their stock is at a 5 year high almost exactly 5 years after doom and gloom over how SimCity’s DRM debacle would end EA.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eppsilon 9y agoTo be fair, the stock market in general is near all-time highs. I agree that SimCity didn't have much impact on its own though.
- harlanlewis 9y agoPhysical sales down 60% yoy is far from the industry norm [1]: 2016: down 17% (5 percentage points) 2015: down 18% (8pp) 2014: down 13% (7pp) 2013: down 15% (8pp) (this isn’t a perfect comparison, because the battlefield number is change in count while the industry numbers are change in share, but it’s a starting point) (edit: despite the industry-wide decrease in share, physical sales have actually been increasing in count since 2013 [2], making the Battlefield decline in physical sales look even worse) Unless they significantly changed how they sell in different channels (news to me), there has to be something title-specific beyond delivery format cannibilazation going on. Hard to speculate if that’s primarily the PR backlash or a combination of things (title fatigue, short release cycle since last edition, quality…). I imagine EA is pretty resilient against a single title underperforming though, be it SimCity or Battlefield or whatever else. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/190225/digital-and-physical-game-sales-in-the-us-since-2009/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/190225/digital-and-physi... [2] https://www.statisticbrain.com/video-game-yearly-sales/ https://www.statisticbrain.com/video-game-yearly-sales/
- swivelmaster 9y agoThe most popular Marvel and Star Wars mobile games have used loot boxes since their respective releases 2+ years ago.
- ctrl-j 9y ago> The most popular Marvel and Star Wars mobile games have used loot boxes since their respective releases 2+ years ago. Is it possible Disney execs simply did not recognize that an in-game mechanic not commonly called "gambling" was in fact gambling? Is it possible when they do a more thorough analysis, they may be upset by this?
- swivelmaster 9y agoI worked on Star Wars: Galaxy of Heroes. I can't answer your question without breaking NDA. edit: Okay, I get that this is being downvoted for not contributing to discussion, but I just wanted to be clear about why I'm not chiming in on this one in particular, given that I'm generally very actively involved in discussions about stuff like this. I enjoyed working at EA very much, and I enjoyed working with the folks at Disney/Lucas as well. And as for the person who said 'just violate your NDA' - I openly associate this username with my real name and provide my contact information in my profile. I don't believe in hiding behind a username - this is me, these are my thoughts and opinions, not some amped-up avatar that I use to blow off steam on the internet.
- joshuas 9y agoCan I buy a Lootbox that might have your answer in it?
- username223 9y agoThen break it. They can hardly fire "swivelmaster."
- mdorazio 9y agoYou're downvoted for providing no value in your comment. If you want to comment a tease "I know the answer but can't tell you.", just don't comment at all.
- jasonlotito 9y agoExcept when you look at all the other areas that Disney allows it's products to be sold via gambling mechanisms. Such a fundamental, core value that it can be proven false within a few seconds of searching.
- Spooky23 9y agoDisney has a long-term outlook for their brands and business. Disney as an entity will almost certainly exist in 2117. EA? I doubt it. They are doubling down on lazy skinner-box type gameplay models. Their entire business is one act of congress away from total vaporization.
- hkmurakami 9y agoFascinating. Across the pond, Nintendo has a pretty hard stance against it (but not explicitly since their corporate history has strong gambling ties in the early 20th century), and Akira Toriyama has refused to license his IP to the pachinko slot machine industry while almost every other peer of his has done so.
- Dreami 9y agoThanks to the author for transcribing the video! He made an important point and I likely wouldn't have read the article if I had to watch a video for that.
- stefs 9y agohe mentions that this is not a transcript.
- new2424141 9y agoForbidden You don't have permission to access /twentysidedtale/ on this server. -- im getting this error
- otakucode 9y agoLooking at the situation from the point of view of the business angle is the correct way to understand the actions of large publishers, and it's refreshing to see someone doing so. I'm not sure that the numbers are interpreted in the same way by the author and by the executives at EA, though. When they see $800 million from loot boxes in FIFA, they don't see just 'hey this can work, lets try to make it work elsewhere.' They see 'hey, this is what gamers actually want.' Also, I'm a little unsure about some of the things said because I don't have a ton of knowledge about the performance of the different games discussed. Like at one point the author mentions "The SimCity backlash."... I do know a bit about that one. That SimCity game that got all the backlash? It immediately became the best-selling game of all time on the Origin service right after its launch. There is simply no way to classify that as anything except a resounding success from a business perspective. It is a fundamental mistake to listen to online talk from gamers as the audience has proven themselves to be their own worst enemy. They shovel mountains of money at the things they claim to hate, and withhold money from anything that deviates. It's not like there aren't games that don't follow these predatory practices. There are tons of them. And they don't make very much money. How can you back up a claim that gamers actually do want those different practices followed if every game which follows them languishes miles behind the titles which don't? If the public pronouncements of gamers actually mirrored their actions, listening to backlash might make sense for a company. But as it is, when the gaming community lights up with anger and "boycotts", that is the most reliable indicator of stellar sales. There really isn't a solution to this problem outside of gamers doing the one thing they seem constitutionally incapable of - not playing the games. Not preordering them, not buying them after release, not even pirating them, straight up not playing the games. (Buying the game and then stopping playing it shortly after release is actually the ideal situation for any publisher, it enables them to more rapidly reduce their spending on server resources and even piracy drives other sales.) I'm not sure why videogames have such a different audience compared to all other forms of media. In other forms of media, the audience vehemently defends their chosen medium, combatting censorship, responding to exploitative practices with substantial actions to back up their complaints, fighting for the rights of the audience over those of the publishers, etc. But we see no significant amount of any of that when it comes to videogames.
- Shivetya 9y ago
- swivelmaster 9y agoIt's astounding to me how these articles and videos get passed around without some cursory fact-checking. EA's revenue at the end of the last fiscal year was nearly five billion dollars. I do believe the $800m quote about FIFA is correct, but that puts it at around 20% of total revenue, not the 80% or so this article asserts. Don't ever assume that Some Random Guy On Youtube has his numbers correct. If CGP Grey (or someone as respected) does a video about this, he/they will probably get it right, but I don't trust many others to do this kind of analysis without getting the numbers wrong. To further highlight the silliness of the original video, it includes some assertions about the cost of game development - EA has claimed it's going up, the author notes that EA's publicly available R&D expenses have gone down in the last four years, therefore the cost of developing games has gone down. This is a completely false claim, because the number of games EA has released has gone from 20+ per year to less than 10. The cost per game has gone way, way up. (I'm not going to take a position on loot boxes here because I spent seven years working on games that had them and I don't want to get into that debate right now.)
- QAPereo 9y ago(I'm not going to take a position on loot boxes here because I spent seven years working on games that had them and I don't want to get into that debate right now.) And yet, that's the core of the piece, and that core is pretty well articulated and damning. Edit: I just want to add that on a personal level, I avoid any game with these manipulative elements in them. I love the idea of for example, For Honor, but the mechanics are perfectly tuned to abuse the player. Who has time in their life for that nonsense? I'll just play another CDPR game.
- swivelmaster 9y agoAnd yet the argument is underpinned by financial data and analysis that is wrong. Basically, if you (not YOU you, but rather the impersonal 'you') want to have a discussion about the morals and ethics of loot boxes, fine, but don't try to back it up with false claims. Using numbers in a moral argument fools everybody into thinking that there's more certainty around the situation than there actually is. At best it's misleading and at worst it's malicious and dishonest.
- whywhywhywhy 9y ago>A clever CEO would have rolled out an optional new game mode built around Wilson Boxes, waited until players were used to the idea, and then tried to encourage players to engage with this new mode of play by quietly neglecting the original mode and focusing their free content updates on the mode driven by Wilson Boxes. That would be scummy and money-grubbing, but it would at least be the cunning form of scummy money-grubbing. GTA 5 comes to mind, single player has nothing to do once the main quest is over and unless they fixed in the car spawning uses a seed based on mission completion (I suspect) so it gets stuck spawning the same 3 bad cars over and over. No DLCs no extra missions no nothing but cosmetics and events for GTA:O
- onychomys 9y agoThe mention of Mass Effect 3's loot boxes (...which were also in Andromeda, for the twelve people who bought that game) is a little different, and I think the difference is important. In both ME games, it's a co-op player team against computer-controlled enemies. Yes, you could pay real-world money to buy loot boxes to gamble and hopefully get better gear, but doing so doesn't hurt any other player. If player A has amazing gear while player B doesn't, it's pretty much a non-issue, because they're always on the same team. That's very different than the PvP modes of both FIFA and the Star Wars game.
- cheshire137 9y ago> Andromeda, for the twelve people who bought that game I was one of those twelve. First Mass Effect game I didn't finish, let alone play over and over again, because I realized I just didn't care about my party members.
- reificator 9y agoI've caused friction in my core gaming group for playing certain built-in characters in co-op games. To the point where it was mandated that we restart and lose hours of progress just so I switch characters. Someone getting advantages from pay-to-win would absolutely make people upset, myself among them.
- jasonlotito 9y agoThe argument is that loot boxes are gambling. The contents are not important. Either loot boxes are gambling, or they are not.
- reificator 9y agoThe contents are important. For years I've been hearing about how people hate these kinds of systems but put up with it because "at least it's only cosmetic". If Battlefront hadn't made it pay to win, the gambling conversation wouldn't be happening yet.
- jellicle 9y agoTry playing a D&D game where one player is level 20 and everyone else is level 1. "Hey, we're all on the same side so it doesn't matter"... no. "Dave paid the DM $50 so he gets the level 20 character. That's just the way it is, you can like it or leave." Differences in player power will break cooperative games just as much as they'll break competitive games. "Okay, so here's the kill stats. Dave: 1,422 kills. Sally: 3 kills. Bob: 4 kills. Lacey: 7 kills. Good job working together everyone!"
- slavik81 9y ago> The loot boxes of Overwatch and Team Fortress 2 came after this point, and their designs were much more friendly. They were focused on cosmetic items[...] The cosmetic items were the rarest and most valuable items in TF2 crates, but gameplay-affecting weapons and equipment were the bread and butter. > Once in power he announces his vision for the future: Marshmallows in everything, without regard to flavor or the intended market. It was before my time, but didn't this actually happen? In the 1950s, the industrial process for the modern marshmallow was developed and recipes put marshmallow in all sorts of inappropriate dishes.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DiThi 9y agoThis comment is downvoted because it was sent unfinished by mistake. Maybe you should empty it.
- scotty79 9y agoLoot boxes are amazingly well done in Clash Royale despite being totally linked to the core progression system. It's a PVP game that all players get points for winning and loose points for loosing. Power of your deck comes from lootboxes you get at decent pace for playing or can buy for real money. The great thing is that thanks to the ranking people are matched with players of the same strengh (either skill or money/time investment) so you are always facing challenging but not impossible opponents. Getting higher in ranking just makes few new cards available when you are above respective ranking thresholds. Those cards are not obviously stronger than others because units are well balanced. All this makes the game fun for all players no matter what is their time/money investment. My take is that it's not worth spending money on this game but I recently found out that TotalBiscuit came to that conclusion only after he spent few thousand dolars on this game. So it's a great game for everybody, rich, poor and the game developers themselves.
- ygaf 9y agoNo opinion on its microtransactions, but I couldn't believe it when that game became an esport. For one, I looked down on mobile games (is one of them really this good?). And you've got a casting team and studio audience to watch two guys sit and twiddle on tablets.
- swivelmaster 9y agoIt's an astoundingly well-designed game.
- scotty79 9y agoYes. Core mechanic is incredibly fun and it starts when you start playing. Cards you get by reaching higher ranking are not necessarily more fun to play and you don't win more with them because you are playing always with players of similar strength to you.
- GFischer 9y agoIndeed, but it's definitely a hardcore pay-to-win game (at least ladder definitely is). If you play well, you get to a point where your opponents' cards are way overstatted against yours. And that's where the temptation to give in and make a purchase comes...
- partycoder 9y agoLoot boxes come from Japan, where they are extensively used in mobile games and all sort of products. In there the concept is known as gacha. https://www.serkantoto.com/2012/02/21/gacha-social-games/ https://www.serkantoto.com/2012/02/21/gacha-social-games/ In Japan, gambling is illegal and the games industry looked for ways to bypass this regulation. Gacha is what they found. But after gacha was perfected into its ultimate addictive form, Kompu Gacha, the government had to take action and regulate it. Now Kompu Gacha is illegal. The legal alternative is Box Gacha, and that is what all westerners are copying. The idea is to not sell you what you want, but rather to sell you a low probability of getting what you want for a lower value. This causes people to underestimate and lose track of what they're spending. But Box Gacha is not the only thing, there are millions of other ways in which those guys have perfected the art of taking money from addicted gamers. Pay to win is a race to the ground. Some players won't mind throwing $10,000 to win, you will never beat them. And if you do beat them, you are a chump.
- Cyberdog 9y ago"They copied it from Japanese games!" is kind of a cop-out. It implies that the loot box concept would not have developed in Western games in isolation, which I don't believe at all, and this article, which highlights how EA was developing the concept well before smartphones went supernova, lends more weight to that non-belief.
- partycoder 9y agoBefore smartphones the Japanese still had feature phones, and games with micropayments and gacha ("loot boxes") in them. Btw you are talking with someone who worked in the games industry so unless you've got certain credible source to refute what I am mentioning here just concede the point.
- Cyberdog 9y ago> Btw you are talking with someone who worked in the games industry so unless you've got certain credible source to refute what I am mentioning here just concede the point. Wow. Well, I'll turn it back on you. What evidence do you have that loot boxes would not have come about in something very close to their current form if the Japanese game industry did not exist? And "because I work in the games industry" is not an answer. I mean, this is a ridiculous hypothetical in the first place. But the broader point is that the fault for the current condition cannot be blamed solely or even primarily on the Japanese industry alone. "The merchants and the traders have come; their profits are pre-ordained."
- egypturnash 9y agoA friend who works at PopCap (now an EA subsidiary) once told me that the Plants Vs Zombies slot machine has made more money for EA than the entire rest of that franchise. Yay gambling.
- byron_fast 9y agoThe impact of these things on in-game cheating is eventually going to make them not worth the trouble in my opinion. They make cheating profitable in the real world, destroying the fun for regular players which at some point will impact the value of the game. The simple fix - other than eliminating them - is to eliminate the possibility of rare items that become valuable.