3 ms·
It's an interesting criticism, because while I don't much like TV these days, I feel that, in a lot of ways, for me the internet is a lot more dangerous than TV
by _delirium 16y ago
It's an interesting criticism, because while I don't much like TV these days, I feel that, in a lot of ways, for me the internet is a lot more dangerous than TV ever was. At least traditionally, there were only so many TV stations, and you could only watch them so long before getting bored. The internet will waste essentially infinite amounts of your time, though. Granted, I do things he sees as useful, like edit Wikipedia (I have like 30k edits). But I'm not sure if the shift in medium necessarily implies any sort of improvement in utilization of cognitive resources. We've still got YouTube, Facebook, Reddit, and all manner of time-wasting going on here.
- alextp 16y agoMaybe, but I think internet time wasting is a lot less toxic than TV time wasting. For me the main differences are: tv channel-surfing is a variable-rewards skinner box (more so than internet) tv has an essentially higher cost to stop watching (getting up from your couch is a lot harder than alt+tabbing back to emacs), and due to the immersive quality of video it is also harder to multi-task with useful stuff, like alternating between reading HN and an academic paper due to the rigidity of tv programming, it has an incentive for you to just stay where you are (if a show you like starts in 10 minutes you're unlikely to do anything useful in these 10min) and for you to structure your life around it (staying up late to watch a late show, for example, means you're probably going to look for thing to watch on tv before that late show you wanted to watch) tv creates a social illusion (at least here in brazil almost everybody knows tv-related inside jokes and comments, and not watching tv means being left out of these conversations) tv programming comes in very long and rigid quanta of time (just like WoW playing; half an hour easily goes by without anything significant happening), unlike reading stuff on the internet or watching 5min-long youtube videos tv tends to be (although this can be said to be changing) more about the tv experience (sit on couch, relax, watch "interesting", beautiful people doing "interesting" things in a funny way) and less about the specific content, while the internet is a lot more about the content, so there's a higher chance you can get something out of it tv is completely passive, no comments allowed.
- carussell 16y agotv has an essentially higher cost to stop watching (getting up from your couch is a lot harder than alt+tabbing back to emacs) On the other hand, it's physically more difficult to come back to the TV once you've gone away.