3 ms·
One thing tacitly not mentioned in the article is the guns and the Navy of the British Empire that made the Hong Kong deal work. If any country decides to cede
by varjag 16y ago
One thing tacitly not mentioned in the article is the guns and the Navy of the British Empire that made the Hong Kong deal work.
If any country decides to cede sovereignty over some territory, they should agree that the guest power will asserts its sovereignty over it. And it has to be full way, without option to be undone after next coup, mood swing or populist elections. And that can be guaranteed only with implicit threat of violence from superior power.
Anyway the big problem these days is actually finding a progressive nation willing to commit to such threats.
- arethuza 16y agoDoes anyone else find it rather ironic that an American economist is citing an example where a mini-state (Honk Kong) created as the results of a war fought by the UK to support drug dealing (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opium_Wars http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opium_Wars) is cited as a great example of how to run a country?
- Confusion 16y agoI don't find that ironic, because a) We don't know this economists ideas about drug prohibition and the fact that he is American is quite irrelevant. Whoever asserts something, you can always find something to deem it 'ironic' or even 'hypocritical'. In the vast majority of cases, that does not detract in any way from their argument. That would require counterarguments. b) Different times, different customs. It's anachronistic to use todays moral standards to argue that behavior back then was considered immoral back then.
- cwp 16y agoNot at all. It doesn't matter how or why Hong Kong was became what it is. What does matter is that 50 years of British rule in a small piece of China had a stunning effect on China as a whole. It's a great example, not of how to run a country, but how to transform one.