4 ms·
I slept in a usually 7x7 tent for 5.7 years with my two adult special needs sons. I am not asserting that their quiet desperation is invalid. But please don't
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
I slept in a usually 7x7 tent for 5.7 years with my two adult special needs sons.
I am not asserting that their quiet desperation is invalid. But please don't dismiss my experience as invalid.
I do a lot of writing on things like homelessness and housing issues. I wish tech giants would abandon their advocacy of UBI and replace it with trying to solve affordable housing for this country. But I cannot begin to tell you what a kick in the stomach it feels like for you to try to "educate" me on the issue of homelessness here, like I have no clue whereof I speak.
- deftturtle 9y agoI think they were just trying to contribute to the discussion. Why assume a hostile position towards the comment?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoIf it is mere contribution to the discussion, it is quite badly handled. If they did not intend to rebut me, they could have posted it as a top level comment instead of as a reply. If they wished to engage me without coming across as dismissive, the framing of it needs a lot of work. Your comment also comes across as subtly dismissive and accusatory due to what you choose to comment on here. If you only wish to engage in discussion, why feel the need to criticize my reply? Why not say something constructive in response to my top level comment above? Women, people of color, the poor and other disenfranchised groups face this sort of thing a great deal. It is rather maddening as it puts people in a no win situation. Such groups get no respect. When they complain of it, it is yet another thing to criticise them for. It would be nice if the world stopped such insidious patterns.
- adrianN 9y agoNo offense, but I think you're misinterpreting a normal pattern of discussion on this site. jpatokal's comment was pretty clearly not trying to dismiss your experience as invalid but simply contributed a similar story.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoNo offense, but your comment merely continues the insidious pattern I wish would end. Edit: If you are assuming I am new here because of the green handle, you are in error.
- mrunkel 9y agoYou seem to be reading a lot into some very innocuous responses. I read jpatokal's response as simple addressing your point that the original author didn't make his point. There was no explicit criticism in the post. Several of us now have tried to point out that we didn't detect any implicit criticism either, but you've take all of these very friendly responses as further attacks. As far as I can tell, nobody is being hostile or making assumptions here except for you.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoAnd yet the pile on of criticism continues while I get downvoted for calmly replying. I was asked a question. I answered. That has been downvoted and more and more people pile on to explain to me the error of my ways for answering the question in good faith, yet no one seems to see how that pattern is inherently dismissive of me.
- the-dude 9y agoThere exists corrective upvoters. Why have you chosen not to use your regular account?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- musage 9y agoJust because it's normal here doesn't mean it's not what it is.
- totalZero 9y agoPerhaps it's because some startup nerd just rolled along and quoted an Atlantic article in response to a very personal comment about very difficult circumstances, quoting something in disagreement without contributing a shred of original conscious thought.
- jpatokal 9y ago"Startup nerd" (LOL) here. I linked to the article because I thought it was an insightful illustration of the life of the "motel homeless". No more, no less, no disagreement (with what, exactly?) intended or implied.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- totalZero 9y agoWe're on Y Combinator's news aggregator and anything said in this environment is being read, voted on, and replied to by a bunch of startup nerds. That's largely what we are. It's not an insult, and it applies to me too. Along with the positive things about this cohort, this means that the easiest things to say around here are a combination of CS/engineering social cluelessness and startup founder "hey, look at this useless but trendy/interesting thing." --- Parent is posting about how there's something missing in the article -- a sense of normalcy in a motel room that comes from being able to do regular things for a moment. The passage you quoted takes a contradictory tack, indicating that motels have a sad side as well for many homeless folks. You describe the sentiment as "quiet desperation," without really taking the time to say anything about the parent comment. Neither is right, neither is wrong, both are simply vantage points on an experience. However.... It's bizarre, to me at least, that one person shares thoughts from a deeply difficult personal experience and the response simply quotes a block of text from a magazine (...owned by Steve Jobs' billionaire widow, no less. Welcome to HN, where even the commentary about homelessness comes from the mouthpiece for a tech billionaire in Palo Alto.) It's like there's a human element missing, a nonfunctioning ligand that would make it a bit easier to connect. It's pretty obvious from the parent comment that you're talking to someone who has seen some rough times, but you literally just quoted a passage from an article that's contradictory to the parent's message without cribbing it in any sort of meaningful way. I mean, this isn't even my thread. I've never been homeless and I like reading magazines too. But I see why the parent commenter reacted defensively, and I am trying to tell you what I see.
- totalZero 9y agoI see UBI as a means to make life more affordable. Assuming price stasis across introduction of UBI, can't a family just use the extra money to help pay rent/mortgage costs? Ultimately, cost of living is one of the big differences between first-world society and the rest of the world. UBI is a way to share the fruits of productivity of the first world among its common classes, effectively reducing their net monthly expenses.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThere are a number of problems with UBI. The largest issue is that tech giants say they want to create a UBI because many jobs are going away permanently. These jobs pay like $20k to $50k annually. Proposed UBI is usually $10k. The most generous figure I have seen (from Sam Altman) is $18k. Then the rest of the article talks in glowing terms about how lovely it will be for underpaid workers to have this extra money. These articles never actually explore what life would be like if your $50k job disappears, you are doomed to only get $10k UBI and have no hope of getting another job. Another issue is that we have a serious, long standing shortage of affordable housing. We tore down about 80% of SROs in a couple of decades and never replaced them. Average size of new housing has more than doubled since the 1950s. If you do nothing to address the issue of affordable housing, then UBI solves nothing. My fear is that tech giants focusing on UBI means that restructuring work to better distribute it, addressing the need to fix health care and affordable housing will all get ignored because UBI is supposed to be some panacea. But it's not. It is basically rich people imagining they can solve this by cutting a check. They can't. That doesn't work. If there simply isn't affordable, basic housing, UBI won't get you off the street.
- thriftwy 9y agoIf you're on UBI you don't need affordable housing because the huge array of very cheap housing in currently non-desirable areas. The kind that is described in the article. Some of those will probably pay you for moving in. And then you have whole day to yourself to figure out additional income on top of UBI.
- jopsen 9y ago
- jpatokal 9y agoWhoah there, you're completely misreading my comment. The single sentence I wrote, "This recent story in the Atlantic does a good job of capturing the quiet desperation of motel-homeless life" isn't even directed at you personally, but at HN readers who want to understand more about the topic. So: of course staying in motels is far preferable to life on the streets, and it sounds like you had it far worse than the family profiled in the Atlantic. My sole point was that precarious living in a string of motels is still homelessness and -- as the article explains -- far more challenging than the average HNer (like me) might think.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoIt would have made an excellent top level comment, with much less room for misinterpretation. Thank you for clarifying.