4 ms·
I think you could be right, long term. In the short to medium term I don't think it is clear. To grow employment, the US needs to grow its manufacturing sector
by nl 16y ago
I think you could be right, long term.
In the short to medium term I don't think it is clear. To grow employment, the US needs to grow its manufacturing sector. Many people think that is impossible because of lower costs in China.
However, Chinese manufacturing costs are under increasing wages pressure (see http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/business/2010-07/19/content_10123116.htm http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/business/2010-07/19/content_101...). For some thing that isn't going to matter - the cost of labor is the main cost in manufacture, so China will be cheaper.
For some industries, though, there are significant capital costs up front. China doesn't necessarily have such a big advantage there, and it's the kind of thing that properly targeted government stimulus (direct or in the form of tax concessions etc) can make a big difference.
Unfortunately it seems that a large part of the political dialog in the US revolves around how bad any form of government intervention in the market is.
The US's competitors don't have that weakness, though.
- tkahn6 16y agoI definitely agree that growing manufacturing is a short-to-medium term solution to unemployment. However, I think it's only a partial-solution going forward in that a) employers won't need to (and therefore won't) employ as many workers per plant and b) the skill-sets required for those positions will be more demanding[1] than those in the past. As for the long term, I think it's safe to say that robotics and automation will eventually remove entirely the need for human factory workers and (nearly) all manual labor. I'm intensely interested the type of society that this will give rise to and I don't know if it's possible (I suspect not) for this type of market to sustain our current population. [1. I could probably find you an article saying this, but I heard this on PBS Newshour about a week ago.]
- nl 16y agoAs for the long term, I think it's safe to say that robotics and automation will eventually remove entirely the need for human factory workers and (nearly) all manual labor. Maybe. People are surprisingly cheap in some parts of the world, and robotics are pretty expensive. Even in the future, the raw materials in machinery won't magically get cheaper. For some industries the upfront costs associated with automation won't be worth it for a long, long time.
- tkahn6 16y agoEven in the future, the raw materials in machinery won't magically get cheaper. True, and raw materials will probably get more expensive. Another thing to consider, however, is that newer industrial techniques might not even be employable without the use of machines. For instance, humans can't make processors regardless of how cheaply their willing to be payed. For some industries the upfront costs associated with automation won't be worth it for a long, long time Right. It's always going to be a cost benefit analysis and I think that's a fair assessment.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]