8 ms·
The German Amateurs Who Discovered ‘Insect Armageddon’
- s_m_t 9y agoI used to notice a lot more bugs when I was a kid. Until recently I thought it was because I was closer to the ground back then :)
- sogen 9y agowindshields filled with bugs
- raarts 9y agoI remember my father cleaning the windshield and head lights at the gas station to remove dead insects every time he filled up the tank. That was in the sixties. I almost never do that.
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoHas anyone considered that "no more bugs on windscreen" is an expected effect of the vastly improved aerodynamics of cars since the 1960s? On a modern car (anything made in the past 15-20 years), the windshield is swept such that it's almost parallel to the airflow, so it would be very hard for bugs to hit it. I'm not saying whether or not there are less insects, just that this is a huge confounding factor. Perhaps someone who frequently takes classic cars for long trips at highway speeds can chime in?
- imeron 9y agoAbout 5-10 years ago you could see the difference between a German highway or any other Eastern European highway. In my experience there was much less bug splatter in Germany than in Hungary. It was so well known in my family that this being a recent headliner surprised me a lot. I guess it's not that easy to count those pesky little insects :).
- mvdwoord 9y agoI actually notice a lot more bugs when I have driven a longish stretch of Autobahn in Germany. My guess is that it is due to the higher speeds. Driving elsewhere is 100-130 kmph, on the autobahn it regularly is 180-240 kmph. Catches the little buggers by surprise :D
- gasbag 9y agoI drive a Scion xB, which has the aerodynamic efficiency of a toaster. When I bought it in 2005, the huge amount of bugs that the windshield caught was one of the few things I didn't like about the car. I'd estimate conservatively that during the past few summers, driving in the same areas, I see at least one third fewer splats than I did a decade ago. However, the area I live in has also had a big growth in sprawl, with lots of new housing developments especially, and that is almost certainly a factor.
- mikestew 9y agoI drive a Scion xB, which has the aerodynamic efficiency of a toaster. When I bought it in 2005, the huge amount of bugs that the windshield caught was one of the few things I didn't like about the car. Hello, fellow '05 owner! And yup, all I have to add is "me, too", because our experience has been identical. As one last anecdotal data point to add to our VW and Scion, I keep a can of cleaner in the motorcycle tank bag to clean the helmet face shield. I used to buy stuff packs of three. Lately, I think I'm still on the can I bought three years ago. I used to also keep a little scrubby sponge in the tank bag for those extra stubborn bugs. I haven't used that thing in so long I don't even know where it's at anymore.
- sogen 9y agoWow
- sogen 9y agoBut not even bugs getting caught in the air intakes or radiator?
- mikestew 9y ago> Perhaps someone who frequently takes classic cars for long trips at highway speeds can chime in? We own a 1981 VW Vanagon. It's a camper, it travels. 8-9 hours to see the eclipse this summer, as just one example. These days, I clean the windshield more to get the dirt off than remove the bugs. Anecdotal, but hey, you asked. :-)
- mc32 9y agoRide a motorcycle without a full face helmet, or at least visorless and without a mouth mask. But do wear some goggles or glasses.
- b0rsuk 9y agoAnd I thought it was because my parents replaced their plot of tulips. But now there are more flowers than ever and very few bugs.
- jaggederest 9y agoI think it's interesting to look at these kind of things related to the "expected armageddons" of nuclear war, disease, gray goo, etc. I suspect it's far more likely that, if humanity goes extinct, it's due to some other subtle cause, rather than one of the big headliners. Pretty terrifying thinking about all the various pesticides in use today and wondering "Will one of these bioaccumulate and sever some critical link in an ecosystem humanity depends on?"
- michaelchisari 9y ago"Not with a bang but a whimper."
- QAPereo 9y agoIt may have already happened, but it would take years and years for us to even notice.
- arnoooooo 9y agoClimate change is a big contender (see http://climate.btmx.fr http://climate.btmx.fr). But what's most scary is that there are multiple credible slow or fast ways the whole of humanity is at risk, and that most are our own fault.
- giardini 9y agoThis study appears to be an alarmist rehash of what was previously discussed on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14323533 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14323533 Here's one of the original papers: https://www.farmlandbirds.net/sites/default/files/Orbrioch%20Nature%20reserve.pdf https://www.farmlandbirds.net/sites/default/files/Orbrioch%2... The 75% decline number appears to be from two data points from a 220-acre plot. From that paper: "What follows is a description of measured Insect-Biomasses from samples collected in the Orbroich Bruch Nature Reserve, near Krefeld, using Malaise Insect Traps. The results show that, in the same two areas, sampled in the years 1989 and 2013, there was a dramatic fall in the number of flying insects. Using the same traps, in the same areas, significant reductions of insect populations, of more than 75%, were found. Our data confirms, that in the areas studied, less than 25% of the original number of flying insects collected in 1989, were still present in 2013." "The Orboicher Bruch, to the Northwest of Krefeld, is a designated Nature Reserve of around 100 hectares (220 acres). Due to the reserve’s relatively remote location and its rugged landscape, intensive farming came to the area only recently." So alarmists are extrapolating from two data points (years 1989 and 2013) for a 220-hectare plot of German farmland to the entire world. I think that is a bit of a stretch, even for statistics. Since different bugs breed in different seasons, and numbers depend on the fruitfulness of previous generations, food supply, predation, disease, temperature and so on, this bug weight could vary considerably from year to year (or site to site) for any number of reasons. While one year cicadas thrive, the next year there may be none. BTW they're measuring the weight of dead bugs - not how many bugs or what species of bugs - just the weight of bugs. Actually they're not even measuring that, they're measuring the weight of dead bugs' soaked in 70-80% alcohol. I could go on and on about controls in statistical experiments but I think you get the idea. See the original HN posting for discussions pointers to the earlier papers.
- b0rsuk 9y agoIf it makes you happier, these results confirms what me and my family simply see in an adjacent country (anecdotal evidence from several data points). There are barely any bugs. Mosquitos used to be a nuisance, everyone shared tips how to protect against them. You don't have to anymore, you can leave windows open at night. There was buzzing all over the garden, now you have to look close to spot a bug.
- b0rsuk 9y agoMy mother is a lover of birds and she installed several nesting booths in her garden. All but one are empty. I think it's not a problem with birds, it's just they don't have anything to eat.
- partycoder 9y agoWe take insects for granted as they have always been there. Sometimes science is not always about having all the answers but about thinking in the right questions. Even if the data is not accurate, bringing attention into this matter seems a positive outcome.
- genki 9y agoI wrote up a root comment but this is actually a better place. I agree with this sentiment! The rest of this is additional commentary on the rest of the discussion on this article. I don't know why but I'm seeing a lot of anecdotes to support or dispute the linked article. The world is much bigger than any one person's experience, and the data indicates that overall, there are fewer insects. We may have anecdotes that agree or disagree with that statement, but that doesn't disprove the statement or in fact provide any useful content to the discussion. The real question here is 1. is this a bad sign (magic 8ball says yes) and 2. what can we do about it (this is a deeper question that can't be easily answered because we haven't done in-depth analysis of why these insects have started to disappear, but the suspicion would be that large-scale agricultural and suburban pesticide use is having a much larger and potentially disastrous effect on the earth's ecosystem). The discussion I'd like to see here is about the ways we can verify this study (trust but verify), determine the source of the problem, and work torwards eliminating that source.
- singularity2001 9y agoIs there any millionaire here who can (secretly) hire a lawyer to shut the pesticide industry down? The destruction of whole ecosystems and causing of many diseases (even cancer and death) is a capital a crime without any doubt. (Yes, lawyers still need to read the proof to put them on trial).
- lambdadmitry 9y agoYou do realize that "pesticide industry shutting down" will cause widespread famine, right? This attitude strikes me as incredibly privileged. Sure, the HN community (which is definitely in global top 1% by income) may be able to cope with x10 food prices. Too bad for the rest, it seems
- singularity2001 9y agoIf Monsanto kills all the insects (and some humans on its way) famine could follow too.
- DennisP 9y agoIf a million dollars in legal fees could shut down the pesticide industry, then someone would surely do it, but pesticide companies can spend billions of dollars on lawyers, and on lobbyists and political contributions to change the laws in their favor.
- misja111 9y agoAnd to be able to pay their lawyers and lobbyists, the pesticide industry could simply increase the prices of their products. Most farmers would have to buy them anyway to be able to grow enough stock to make a living.
- TausAmmer 9y agoDestruction of environment because of this silent killer is very noticeable in last 5 years. Drastic changes around. I wonder how next 5 years will look. Will be interesting. Don't you worry, there are plenty of spaces left for insects. And human life, it is worthless.
- ptha 9y agoDon't worry about the insects, see the last quote: As the scent of 82 proof alcohol that preserves the bugs wafted, just a little, through the room, a reporter asked if, at this rate, all the insects were going to disappear. “Oh, don’t worry,” said Mr. Sorg, the wasp expert. “All the vertebrates will die before that.” However, agreeing that we are indeed hastening the next mass extinction, might be a good start to avoiding/postponing it.
- QAPereo 9y agoThe only way is population control, and how does that work outside of nightmares and cautionary tales from history? Great Filter here we come.
- jdc0589 9y agoits really hard to have a serious conversation about population control. It's just one of those topics that immediately label you as some kind of crazy murdering nut-job in the eyes of lots of people. Honestly, it may not have been super effective for certain reasons, but China's child limit laws are about the least crazy solution I can think of.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoPopulation control probably isn't necessary. No one (informed) thinks that the human population is going to grow out of control. It's likely to become stable at around 10-11 billion within 100 years. Birth rates are declining in developed countries and the undeveloped world is rapidly developing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projections_of_population_growth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projections_of_population_grow...
- QAPereo 9y agoIt isn’t necessary only if massive inequality persists, and our tech just plain saves us all. What a crazy fucking bet when the stakes are the future of human civilization.
- polskibus 9y agoThere's a common anecdote among Polish drivers that drive through Europe. When you wash the front of you car just before entering Germany from Poland, you will have almost no bugs on the front of the car when you exit to France. I also noticed almost no mosquitos in my several trips in the summer to and passing through Germany.