3 ms·
They're the people making dumb comments like "give 'em the chair" and other right leaning authoritarian junk on the comments of local news stories about minor c
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
They're the people making dumb comments like "give 'em the chair" and other right leaning authoritarian junk on the comments of local news stories about minor crimes and "speeding fines should scale with income" and other socialist authoritarian junk on platforms like HN.
They walk among us.
- arcticbull 9y agoOut of curiosity, why do you think speeding fines shouldn't scale with income? The pain that's intended to dissuade behavior is that you can do X amount less this month, but if your income is enormous you don't feel X at all, it's not really a punishment is it? If I were a billionaire and I could drive around with impunity with my checkbook open is that achieving the desired outcome? Scaling with income scales the pain and therefore the dissuasion. Legitimately curious to the counterargument. Crime is dissuaded in percentage of your life behind bars, shouldn't infractions be dissuaded in percentage of your income or net worth?
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoBasically because 99.9% of speeding isn't a serious crime that merits harsh punishment 1) Harsh punishment for something trivial that everyone does but is of negligible harm to society is worse for society than handing out slap on the wrist type fines. Speeding infractions, especially on limited access highways, are only slightly worse for society than parking infractions. For example, the speed limit on the highway I take to work is 55mph. 55 is pre/post rush our speed. Typical traffic flow when traffic is light is up to 80-85 as permitted by weather conditions. Writing people tickets for 30-over when 30-over is a reasonable speed does nothing good for society. 2) Why should I work hard to be a six figure software engineer if "winning" that reverse lottery gets me just as screwed as someone who's barely living paycheck to paycheck? 3) Most states have appropriate fines and penalties attached to sufficiently broad criminal violations to cover actual bad behavior. I.e. write someone a summons for reckless driving if they're actually being reckless and then fine them $500 in court rather than fine them $500 for "speeding" according to some table and formula. 4) Then there's the whole problem of misaligned incentives that comes with aggressively policing minor infractions for revenue (traffic or some other group). I'd rather have a police department of x officers all doing real work than a police department of 2x where on any given day x of the officers are always on traffic detail to pay for the costs of running the department. 5) If people want to drive "too fast" on the road then the road either needs to be redesigned (there's visual tricks the engineers can play to make the road feel smaller and make people want to go slower) so people want to go the desired speed or the desired speed needs to increase to reflect reality. If I'm being a normal person going 80 in a 55 that should be an 80 on a normal night I don't want to get a $500 ticket because my tail-light was out but it just so happened that my otherwise unremarkable speed of 80 was 25 over for that location.
- SamReidHughes 9y agoSpeeding gets points on your license and it can get taken away. So the rich can't just speed willy-nilly, and in practice they don't.
- freeone3000 9y agoPoints systems mean there's a speed quota, an amount of speeding you can do that's monetary-penalties-only. There's a reason the vehicle you see going 95 is a Maserati and not a Golf.
- SamReidHughes 9y agoHuh? In my experience the vehicle going 95 is a 2011 Honda Fit. Want to make a prediction about whether the top 1% or the bottom 20% have more moving violations per capita?
- mrguyorama 9y agoSome states allow you to pay double the fine and avoid the points that way.